About 2 o'clock the donkeys come down. They are such dear, little, obstinate creatures, and are about eleven in number; but more are to come from New Zealand, where they are bred. The children are delighted with the novelty. They pet and fondle them, and discover their names engraved on their halters. There is Gipsy, Topsy, Madcap, Murmur, Bland Holt, Seddon, and Napoleon. This last donkey objects to carrying adults or boys, he likes the girls best. It is strange how he knows, instantly a man or boy is wont to get on his back he bucks most viciously, and yet for the girls his temper is angelic. Double-seated wicker saddles are provided for the very little children, and the donkeys look so pretty with a double-freight of chubby babies; on their backs. I am sure they feel their twofold responsibility in carrying such precious burdens. Boys and girls ride straddle-saddle, so there is little fear of a fall. Even if such a catastrophe should happen, it would not be serious on the sand. Boys accompany the riders, whipping the donkeys up, until they break into a fast trot, and judging by the beaming faces of the children, it must be great fun, and well worth a trial. Several timid little girls want a ride badly, but they are afraid unless an elder sister walks beside the donkey to held then on. Then the difficulty is to get them off, as they have enjoyed the ride so much. (1)
With the ebb and flow of time, a little of Victoria's jettisoned past has washed up upon my desk: a discarded photo, a worn postcard, or a fading newspaper. Their long forgotten characters now retell their stories in a digital sampling, post by post. Their voices are my blog's vignettes. Researched and written by Heather Arnold.
Saturday, May 4, 2024
Donkeys on the St Kilda Beach
About 2 o'clock the donkeys come down. They are such dear, little, obstinate creatures, and are about eleven in number; but more are to come from New Zealand, where they are bred. The children are delighted with the novelty. They pet and fondle them, and discover their names engraved on their halters. There is Gipsy, Topsy, Madcap, Murmur, Bland Holt, Seddon, and Napoleon. This last donkey objects to carrying adults or boys, he likes the girls best. It is strange how he knows, instantly a man or boy is wont to get on his back he bucks most viciously, and yet for the girls his temper is angelic. Double-seated wicker saddles are provided for the very little children, and the donkeys look so pretty with a double-freight of chubby babies; on their backs. I am sure they feel their twofold responsibility in carrying such precious burdens. Boys and girls ride straddle-saddle, so there is little fear of a fall. Even if such a catastrophe should happen, it would not be serious on the sand. Boys accompany the riders, whipping the donkeys up, until they break into a fast trot, and judging by the beaming faces of the children, it must be great fun, and well worth a trial. Several timid little girls want a ride badly, but they are afraid unless an elder sister walks beside the donkey to held then on. Then the difficulty is to get them off, as they have enjoyed the ride so much. (1)
Saturday, April 20, 2024
Sister Hollins and Sister Lewis and the Pakenham Infant Welfare Centre
In 2012 a new Childrens Centre opened in Pakenham, called the Hollins Children Centre. It has two kindergarten rooms, a toy Library, a meeting room and rooms for the Infant Health nurse. When Councils and developers are looking for appropriate names for new buildings, parks, streets or other infrastructure, they sometimes contact Local History Societies or me, when I was the Local History Librarian at Casey Cardinia Libraries, for ideas. At times, they decide that the name we suggest is a suitable name and this was the case with the Hollins Children Centre. I was reading through the Souvenir Booklet from the Back to Pakenham celebrations held in March 1951 which has the history of various institutions in Pakenham, including the Infant Welfare Centre. The article mentioned that Sister Hollins and Sister Lewis were the first nurses involved with infant welfare in the area, so I suggested that the new Centre could honour the nurses and in the end it was decided to call the centre after Sister Hollins. I was very excited and thrilled that the Cardinia Shire Council selected one of 'my names' and I attended the official opening on November 20, 2012.
I first wrote this post in December 2012, for my work blog, Casey Cardinia Links to our Past, and this is an updated and expanded version of my original post.
This is the information from the Souvenir Booklet -Infant Welfare Centre
Infant welfare work was unknown in the Pakenham district till Sister Hollins(who was in charge of the Pakenham Bush Nursing Hospital) took upon herself the task of trying to get mothers interested in this work. Using one of the single bed wards in the hospital, Sister Hollins started her task in 1934 by persuading mothers as they left the hospital after their babies were born to come back regularly to have their infants weighed and measured and to ask for any advice they might need. Although this was not an easy job, trying to persuade the mothers to come (their mothers managed without health centres, etc), they soon realised what a help the Health Centre was to them, as they could follow their babies' progress week by week. This necessitated moving out of the hospital to a separate room, which was made available adjoining the nurses' sleeping quarters. This room was officially opened at the end of 1935 by Dr. Scantlebury-Brown, accompanied by Sister Muriel Peck. Sister Lewis was then officially appointed Infant Welfare sister for the district, which later extended through the Berwick Shire. In these days there was no modern equipment, and apart from the scales (which were owned by Sister Lewis) the rest of the very limited equipment was made and got together by both Sisters Hollins and Lewis. Sister Lewis carried on in her cramped quarters till she thought the mothers should have a more up-to-date centre in which to have their babies attended to. So at a public meeting convened by Sister Lewis on May 11, 1945, a committee was formed for the object of raising money to build this so badly needed modern centre. So much interest was shown that by February, 1949, this building in the main street was ready to be used. It was officially opened in March, 1949, by Dr Barbara Meredith, Director of Infant Welfare and Maternal Hygiene. It is a pleasure to visit the centre each week with its modern equipment and heating arrangements, and we have much to thank Sister Hollins and Sister Lewis for, for their tireless work and the interest they created throughout this district in infant welfare work. (1)
Mr Thomas Lewis - It is with genuine regret that we have to record the death, at his residence, Camberwell, on Wednesday night, of Mr. Thomas Lewis, retired inspector of police, at the age of 60½ years. The deceased, who left the force about six months since, had been in good health till about a month ago, when he contracted a cold which developed into pneumonia, and though carefully nursed, he eventually succumbed to the attack. Very few members of the Victorian police had as fine a record as Mr. Lewis has, though he did not unduly harass the public, he succeeded in maintaining law and order wherever stationed, gaining the appreciation of the public and the warm commendation of his superiors. It is some 15 years since he was attached to the force at Beechworth, subsequently removing to Benalla where he was occupied by clerical duties in the Superintendent's office. Promotion to the rank of sergeant was followed by duty at Kerang, whence he was transferred to Ascot Vale where, after two years, he passed on to Russell Street, ranking as inspector. Here he was, as in his previous positions, highly respected. Reaching the age of 60 in the early part of this year, he retired, and having made a comfortable home, earned a well deserved rest. Sympathy from all who knew Mr. Lewis goes out to his wife and two daughters. On Friday his remains were laid to rest in the Wangaratta cemetery beside those of his parents. (4)
Muriel Lewis first appeared in the Electoral rolls in 1922 and 1924 when she was a trainee nurse at the Royal Children's Hospital and she successfully passed the Royal Victorian Trained Nurses' Association’s examination in May 1924.
In the 1925 and 1927 Electoral Rolls, after she was qualified, she was living at 37 St Leonards Avenue, Ascot Vale with her parents. The 1931 rolls show Muriel and Hannah living at 99 Highfield Road, Camberwell. I believe it was in 1934 that Muriel began employment at the Pakenham Bush Nursing Hospital where she was also the Infant Welfare Sister for the Pakenham District. (5) In March 1945 she was appointed the full-time Baby Health Sister for the entire Berwick Shire, a position which she held until around October 1948 when Muriel became the Matron of the Koo Wee Rup Memorial Hospital. (6) However it appears that Infant Welfare work was her true calling and in May 1951, she returned to the Shire of Berwick as the Infant Welfare Centre Sister. (7)
I believe Sister Lewis held that position at the Berwick Shire until late 1954. In the 1954 and 1963 Electoral Rolls, Muriel was back at 99 Highfield Road with Hannah, and in 1968 in 33 Abercrombie Street, Deepdene, which is where she was living when she passed away on March 23, 1970. She is buried at Springvale Cemetery. Hannah passed away in 1963, aged 91 (8).
Sister Lillian Ada Clarissa Hollins
Lillian Ada Clarissa Hollins was born in 1899, in Bath, England to Percival and Ada (nee Hounsell) Weare. She was married on March 15, 1919 in Bath to Australian soldier, Lieutenant Roy Digby Hollins, who was about 28 at the time. The couple arrived in Australia in December 1919 and lived in Williamstown, then Dalyston and in March 1921 he took up a block of land at Red Cliffs. Lillian lived with Roy on occasions and in 1926/1927 returned to England for ten months to visit her father. On her return she lived with Roy for some months, then moved to Mildura to work at a private hospital. Lilian wrote to Roy in April 1928 saying she would not be returning to Red Cliffs and she moved to Melbourne to train as a nurse at the Alfred Hospital. We know all this because in October 1930 Roy filed for a divorce on the grounds of her desertion, and the information formed part of his affidavit. He also noted in his affidavit that the cause of the trouble between the respondent and myself was that the respondent was addicted to unnatural sexual practices with other women, of which she knew I was aware. Shortly before the respondent left me I spoke to her about this matter. At such conversation the respondent evinced no inclination to desist from such practices and indicated a determination to leave me. The divorce was finalised on June 3, 1931.(9)
Interesting case - I feel for Roy that his marriage did not turn out to be 'happy ever after' on the other hand, I can see that a farm at Red Cliffs could have been very isolating and stultifying for Lillian, whether or not she was addicted to unnatural sexual practices with other women. Roy married Daisy Brownlaw in 1931 and he died in 1964. (10) 1931 was also the year that Lillian became a qualified nurse, by passing the Royal Victorian Trained Nurses' Association’s examination.
In the 1934 Electoral Rolls, Lillian is listed at Dunolly, employed at the District Hospital. She started at the Bush Nursing Hospital at Pakenham in November 1934. (11)
At Pakenham Presbyterian Church on Wednesday of last week, in the presence of a large number of relatives and friends, Sister Lillian Ada Hollins, matron of Pakenham and District Bush Nursing Hospital, was united in marriage to Mr Sydney C. Banbrook, formerly of Berwick Shire engineer's office staff.
The Church had been beautifully decorated for the occasion by friends of the bride. Spring blossom, Iceland poppies, daffodils, etc., were effectively used in the decorative scheme.
The ceremony was performed by Rev. C. Jones, of Berwick. Mrs H.L. Keys presided at the organ.
Sydney died in Adelaide on October 27, 1963 and Lillian on July 30, 1965. They are buried at the North Brighton Cemetery in Adelaide. (21). As a matter of interest, even though Sydney was born in 1904 in Sydney, New South Wales, his parents Alfred Banbrook and Matilda Usher had married in Victoria in 1890 and they had three children in Victoria. There was a short obituary for Matilda in the Dandenong Journal in January 1951 -
formerly of Spring Vale and Dandenong. The end came at her home last Wednesday at the age of 83. Deceased was the wife of the late Alfred Banbrook, who pre-deceased her about eight years ago, and was the daughter of the late Silas and Lucy Usher, nee Jewis. She was born at Spring Vale and her remains were interred there last Monday. Rev. W. J. Clarke conducted the service and W. J. Garnar and Son carried out the funeral arrangements. (22)
Tuesday, April 16, 2024
The Corner House Drapery and the Ordish Timber Yard, Dandenong East
Wednesday, April 10, 2024
Miss Beatrice Thomas - Berwick Shire Secretary
The Dandenong Journal reported on January 23, 1952 (1) that Miss Beatrice (Trixie) Thomas had been appointed as the Berwick Shire Secretary. Miss Thomas had been employed by the Shire for 27 years and had been acting as the Assistant Secretary for 'some time.' She was the daughter of Albert Thomas, who founded the Berwick Shire News, later the Pakenham Gazette in 1909 and the sister of Herb Thomas, who took over the paper from his father. As a matter of interest, Beatrice Evelyn Victoria Thomas was born on January 22, 1901, the same day Queen Victoria died, so not surprising she has Victoria in her name. She died on February 10, 1997. (2)
Miss Thomas followed Mr K. A. McKay in the role, who had served for four years and resigned in December 1951. Keith McKay had taken over from the long serving James Joseph Ahern who was in the role from 1906 until he retired December 1947. (3)
Clearly, Miss Thomas was well qualified for the position, however the Returned Soldiers League (RSL) and the Pakenham Upper Progress Association protested against the appointment as the newspaper article from the Dandenong Journal of February 27, 1952 reported (see below). I have transcribed the article as it gives the rationale for the appointment of Miss Thomas and the support she had from the Councillors.
Emphatic Protest - Pakenham Upper Progress Association forwarded an emphatic protest against the departure from the principle of preference to ex-servicemen in the appointment of Shire Secretary.
R.S.L. asks for reasons - Pakenham Branch R.S.L. asked that council inform them of its reasons for departure from the established policy of extending preference to returned service men in the recent appointment. Members of the branch desired to know how many returned service men made application for the position, and, if any, what were their qualifications and experience in municipal administration.
One month later, the R.S.L. requested more information from the Council about the appointment. Once again, the Dandenong Journal reported - this is an abridged version of the report, read the full report here.
the appointment of a non-returned service secretary, Pakenham R.S.L. last week repeated its request for this information: “How many returned servicemen applied for the position? What were their qualifications?”, it asked. It is getting the information it sought, but not before several brushes between councillors not over any desire to withhold the information but over the claim of some councillors that they had been in favor of giving the information in the first place, but couldn’t get support. This was challenged.
Cr Houlihan said he felt the R.S.L. was entitled to this information. Their purpose was to watch the interests of the returned servicemen and they couldn’t do this unless they had the information. When the advertisement appeared one clause in it was “Preference to Returned Soldiers.” There were 22 applicants for the position, but no one outside the committee of the council knew whether any returned soldier was included or not. Pakenham R.S.L., had been placed in a very awkward position. They were responsible to the League to see that preference was given to returned soldiers in their district. “They do know” proceeded Cr. Houlihan, "that the secretary who was appointed is not a returned soldier although our advertisement stated that preference would be given to returned soldiers. And while I’m in this council I hope to see that preference is given to returned servicemen, or an opinion voiced in support of that policy. ... I feel that the branch is entitled to this information so that they can take proper action. Cr. Houlihan moved that the information be supplied.
Seconding this motion, Cr. Greaves claimed that he had tried to get a more adequate reply in the first place.
There was some support for Miss Thomas - Cr. Kinsella said - I feel this matter has gone far enough. I came to this council table with one purpose only - and that is to get the best service possible for the ratepayers. I took the action in moving as I did in furtherance of that policy and I was supported by 10 councillors. I have nothing against telling the R.S.L. what it wants to know. Certainly tell them. I would say that ’when the position became vacant we should have appointed Miss Thomas there and then if that was our intention. We can’t appoint a member of the staff unless it is unanimous'. 'I may-be wrong', proceeded Cr. Kinsella, but I believe that for a returned soldier to serve this council he would have to have qualities at least equal with one who has given this council long and loyal service and who has nothing against them. I would always support the appointment of one whom I believe, rightly or wrongly, has served this shire well. ... I do object to councillors now getting up and saying they said things they definitely did not say when this matter first came before council. (6)
The controversy was still raging a month later when the Dandenong Journal conducted a 'vox pop' on the issue.
Mr. Vernon Clark, Pakenham R. S. L. branch honorary secretary,who wants an ex-serviceman appointed, was not admitted to the meeting. Mr Clark will seek the advice of a Queen's Counsel on whether the Council violated it's agreement to grant preference to returned servicemen.
Shire residents yesterday supported Mr Clark's protest.
Mr. L. C. Futcher, Pakenham shopkeeper, said: 'Rejection of the promises made to returned servicemen is a thing that should be stopped before it spreads to other Councils and other employees'.
Miss Alma Lang of Berwick: 'I have two brothers who went right through the War, so I'll always stick up for servicemen'.
Miss Joyce Berry, cook, at Berwick Hospital: 'How can we expect men to join up for the next War if those who fought in the last one aren't given a fair go'.
Misses Evande Trebilen and Pat Fritzlaff, Berwick dressmakers: 'The Shire Secretary's job is a man's job whether he's a returned soldier or not'. (7)
The Dandenong Journal of May 21, 1952 published another article on the issue, this time reporting on some support Miss Thomas was receiving from a number of high profile women's groups.
The National Council of Women wrote: "We desire to express to the President and the members of council our appreciation of your action in not allowing any discrimination on the grounds of sex to
prevent you from appointing the most suitable applicant for the position".
Dr Janet P. Cooper of Albert Park, wrote: "Having read of your selecting Miss Thomas as Shire Secretary, I am pleased to congratulate you on recognising her service and ability. While fully appreciating and remembering what we all owe to the ex-service people, there are situations when the ratepayers are entitled to the most efficient service".
"The League of Women Voters of Victoria congratulate your Shire Council on having appointed as Shire Secretary, your very experienced officer, Miss Thomas’ wrote the president of that organisation. 'The officers and members hope that, in spite of any protests that may be made you will continue to employ Miss Thomas in that position, and to enjoy her services, which after 25 years experience, must be entirely adequate".
Expressing concern at the press statement made by an R.S.L. representative, 'That we will oppose the appointment of a woman as Shire Secretary", the Women’s Christian Temperance Union of Victoria, wrote: "We feel that the appointment would not have been made unless the council is assured that the best interests of the shire would be served by this officer, and trust that your council will adhere to the decision to make qualifications rather than sex, or other issues the basis of the appointment".
Voicing their congratulations on the appointment the Business Professional Women’s Club of Melbourne stated: 'This club considers that in the interests of the community, appointments should made having regard only for the ability and experience of the candidates, and without discrimination because of sex". (8)
So what happened in the end? Miss Thomas retained her appointment and served the Shire of Berwick until she retired in January 1966.