Frankston Avenue of Honor and War Memorial

Frankton established a Avenue of Honor, to commemorate their Great War Soldiers in 1918. The first tree was planted on July 13 and The Age had the following report -
In wintry and showery weather conditions the State Governor on Saturday afternoon performed the opening ceremony in connection with the planting of an honor avenue in Point Nepean-road, Frankston, in memory of the men who enlisted from that district. There was a large attendance of local residents and about 200 invalided soldiers from the base, Caulfield, M'Leod and Highton military hospitals, in charge of Warrant Officer Arrowsmith. The men were convoyed to Frankston by about 50 cars belonging to members of the voluntary motor corps. The Langwarrin band attended, and there was also a guard of honor from Langwarrin camp. In planting the first of a line lot of eucalyptus botryoides in honor of Private A. Bolger, who was the first local soldier killed in action, Sir Arthur Stanley congratulated the people of the district on the splendid patriotism they had always shown, and the whole-hearted hospitality the lady members of the Wattle club had extended to the soldiers. He said the avenue of trees, individually supplied by the people, would be a lasting memorial to those brave fellows who had shown a magnificent example of self-sacrifice in the Umpire's cause. The names of those men would live for ever and be always cherished for generations to come....The trees were then planted under the supervision of Mr. Hartland, of the Forestry department, and extended for a distance of nearly a mile. (1)  

The planting of the Frankston Avenue of Honor

1. Mr. and Mrs. James Grice planting a tree in honor of their son, Lieut. Grice. 2. Guard of Honor. 3. The Governor (Sir Arthur Stanley) addressing the residents. 4. Tree in Honor of Pte. E. M'comb, planted by his brother-in-law, Sergt. Moon. 

Avenue of Honor at Frankston in Memory of Men of the District who have Enlisted.

Weekly Times, July 20, 1918 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article129476803 

However, two years later the Avenue was a sorry sight, as recorded in this letter to the Editor of the Mornington Standard -  

Frankston Honor Avenue, Sir- The avenue of trees planted along the Melbourne road last year, after a years growth, do not at present give the indications of their ever attaining to the noble avenue of trees which is so much desired, considering the purpose for which they were planted, and it must be a disappointment to many to seen such unsatisfactory results. As it is, some trees that have been looked after have made good growths, one in particular having taken such a lead that may always leave it far ahead of the rest. This is not  desirable, as I take it an avenue should have for its greatest beauty and glory a uniform growth with each tree. This could best be attained by attention to each tree during the first year of planting, and by such attention as watering and stimulating the weaker trees by reinforcing the soil around their butts, an providing a litter to conserve moisture, they would have made a better growth, and perhaps all would have survived the past summer's long dry spells and the avenue being a fair way to become what we all wish: To glory and pride of all. Yours. etc, VISITOR. (2)

The Avenue did survive and in 1931 in a report of the  Provincial Press Association's Outing to Frankston we find that it was thriving -  

As the cars turned again toward the town along Point Nepean-road the Honor Avenue was passed. This is a double row of Australian Gums about half a mile in length. Point Nepean-road at this part is two chains in width and contains some beautiful homes and some of the finest hedges in the state. The Honor Avenue is in the centre and provides a sheltered walk for pedestrians. (3)

The Avenue was removed in the 1960s for road widening and there is now a memorial to mark the original location (4) 

This wasn't the only Great War memorial in Frankston, there was also a monument. The Frankston Soldiers' Memorial Committee was established in 1919 (5). There was much discussion as to the location of the memorial, outside the Mechanics' Institute was a favoured location, however, in the end the site selected in Bay Street, opposite the Post Office (or essentially outside the Grand Hotel, on the intersection of Bay Street (the Nepean Highway) and Davey Street)  (6).  In September 1921, designs were invited for the War Memorial, which was to cost £1200. (7) 

Designs invited for Frankston War Memorial

The Age, August 6, 1921 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article206704866

In November 1921, the Frankston Standard could report that -

On Tuesday last, Cr Mason and Messrs Utber and Vicars, representing the Frankston Soldiers'

Memorial Committee, visited Melbourne and inspected the designs submitted for the Frankston Memorial in the competition arranged by the War Memorials Advisory Committee for Victoria. There were seven competitors, and the adjudicators placed Mr. Alex S. Hall's design first, a decision which was fully endorsed by the Frankston committee. This design is now on view in the window of Mr W. P. Mason, Bay Street, Frankston. (8)

Alexander Sergeant  Hall was a Melbourne Architect and had trained with the firm Bates, Peebles and Smart. Alec enlisted in the  A.I.F in July 1916 at the age of 21 and was discharged in June 1919.  In 1928 he won first prize in the competition to design the Ararat War Memorial; in 1935 he entered into a partnership with Architect Frank Stapley, who was also a Melbourne City Councillor from 1901 until his death in 1944. In 1948, along with Architect, E. E. Milston, Alec won the competition to design the memorial to the fallen soldiers of World War Two at the Shrine of Remembrance. He died on January 6, 1972 1972, aged76 and left behind his wife Eileen and sons David and Peter.  (9)

The project moved slowly as there was shortage of funds; in April 1922 the committee held £622 and still required another £500 (10). A year later in April 1923 a meeting was held to discuss modifications to the original design -
Mr. Hall, the architect whose design for a Soldiers' Memorial at Frankston was accepted, met the committee at the Council Chambers, Frankston, on Wednesday evening last. Cr. W. J. Oates was in the chair, and others present were: -  Cr. Mason, Dr. Maxwell, Messrs. P. Wheeler, M. Brody, H. Morrison, A. Hill, J. D. Jenings, W. M. Hanton, W. C. Young, and Lieut.-Colonel Lazarus (hon. sec.). The object of the meeting was to discuss with Mr. Hall the practicability of the proposal to reduce the cost of the memorial, without materially altering the original design. Mr. Hall agreed that granite and blue-stone could with advantage replace the free-stone provided for in the original estimates. It was ultimately resolved that the architect prepare a fresh estimate of cost, allowing for substituted material, but retaining the original brass tablet, bearing the names of soldiers. It is hoped that the revised specifications will permit of the Memorial being erected for about £800. The original estimate was £1180. (11)

Tenders invited for the construction of the War Memorial

The Argus, June 9, 1923 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article2012078

Finally in June 1923, the Architect, Alec Hall, could advertise for tenders for the construction of the new memorial. (12) Seven tenders were received (13) and on June 27, 1923 the Frankston Soldiers' Memorial Committee met and -
The secretary then read a letter from the architect, giving details of the tenders received for the erection of soldiers' memorial at Frankston. The lowest tender was that of Messrs. Corben & Sons, and the architect recommended the acceptance of same. It was resolved on the motion of Cr. Mason, seconded by Mr. Brody that Corben & Son's tender at £580 be accepted. (14)

The Memorial was unveiled by the Prime Minister, Mr Bruce on Anzac Day, 1924. The Age began their report with a description of the monument -
A memorial to the Frankston soldiers, erected on an elevation in the main thoroughfare, was unveiled yesterday by the Prime Minister (Mr. Bruce). The monument, which takes the form of a sandstone drinking fountain, contains a bronze plate, on which are engraved the names of the local volunteers. (15) You can the rest of the article here and another account of the unveiling from the Frankston and Somerville Standard, here.

The Frankston War Memorial

Frankston and Somerville Standard, April 30, 1924  http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article73499570

Recently, I came across the photograph, below, which was the catalyst for all this research and when I saw the original illustration I realised that the memorial had been altered with a more elaborate addition, on the top. This addition took place in 1928, although not without some controversary as reported in the Frankston and Somerville Standard in the April -
The additions to the Soldiers' Memorial, the proposed alteration of which raised a good deal of controversy in architectural circles, are now being carried out. The work is being done at the direction of Mr. H. M. Collins, of "Gracehill," Frankston, and those who have been dissatisfied with the present memorial will be grateful to Mr. Collins for his generosity. Many, on the other hand, are opposed to any alteration of the original structure. Those versed in art and with an eye for the beautiful in architecture contend that the original design ranked with the finest war memorials in the State. (16)

The War Memorial, on the right.

Shopping Centre, Frankston, around late 1940s. Photographer: Rose Stereograph Co. 

State Library of Victoria image H32492/6366

Henry Michael Collins, was the benefactor of this addition; he had previously donated £5 to the Memorial building fund in 1922 and another £10 towards the fund in 1925. He was a man to whom memorials were important; in October 1925 there was dedication service at St Paul's Anglican Church in Frankston of window in honour of his son, Major Percy Robert Murdoch Collins, D.S.O., R.G.A., who was killed in action near Ypres, on June 25, 1917 aged 26 and Percy's widow, Anne Elinor Lula Collins (nee Grice), who died on December 8, 1918 at the age of 23. At the same service a memorial tablet was unveiled to Henry's wife, Isabella Maria Collins, who died in England, on February 11, 1917. Sadly, the memorial window was destroyed by fire in 1957. (17)

Henry was born in 1844 in England and spent his working life with Reuters Agency; he worked all over the world and in 1878 he was appointed General manager for Reuters Australasia, a role he held for 30 years. Henry was also on the board of management of the Alfred Hospital from 1895. Mr Collins died on June 11, 1928. (18) His last local deed of benevolence was his order for the improvement of the Frankston Soldiers' Memorial. Although architects and artists differed on the question of adding to the centre portion of the memorial there is no room for argument that the scheme which was being carried out under Mr. Collins' direction for the beautification of the surroundings and approach to the memorial itself is a vast improvement. It is a matter for lasting regret that this public benefactor did not live to see the fulfilment of his plan for a more fitting tribute to the memory of those to whom he never tired of doing honor. (19)

There are not many photographs of the War Memorial (that I can find) but here are four of  various quality, which give some indications of the location and what it looked like.

Hard to see, but the War Memorial is on the left, you can see the steps which lead to it. 

Post Office and Portion of shopping centre, Frankston, around late 1940s. Photographer: Rose Stereograph Co. 

State Library of Victoria image H32492/3649

The War Memorial in 1935

Adelaide Chronicle, January 17, 1935 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article92363405

The War Memorial in 1946. 

Frankston Standard, November 14, 1946 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article73594317

The War Memorial in 1947

Frankston Standard, May 1, 1947 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article73596240

What happened to the Frankston War Memorial? It was removed around 1962 and the brass plaque with all the names of the soldiers was added to a new monument at the Civic Centre in Davey Street, which also honours service personnel  from other conflicts. The Civic Centre memorial appears to be just a number of plaques mounted on brick wall. (20) A  new memorial was created in 2016 in Beauty Park in Frankston in 2016, a half circle of concrete with the names of the 228 men and women who served in World War One engraved upon it (21).  It is equally as bland as the Civic Centre memorial was. 

The original brass plaque from the World War One soldiers does not appear to have been relocated to Beauty Park - where is that now? In fact, what happened to the original sandstone monument and Mr Collins's addition? 

Footnotes

(1) The Age, July 15, 1918, see here. 
(2) Mornington Standard, May 7, 1920, see here.

(3) Horsham Times, January 16, 1931, see here. 
(4) Virtual War Memorial Australia https://vwma.org.au/explore/memorials/6801
(5) I believe it was 1919 - that's the earliest mention I can find. Mornington Standard, August 16, 1919, see here. 
(6) Location - Mechanics' Institute - Mornington Standard, April 30, 1920, see here; Bay Street - Frankston and Somerville Standard, April 9, 1920, see here and  Frankston and Somerville Standard, June 29, 1923 see here;  Frankston Standard, October 17, 1941, see here.  

(7) The Age, August 6, 1921, see here.  
(8) Frankston and Somerville Standard, November 25, 1921, see here. 
(9) Alexander Sergeant Hall - WW1 enlistment papers https://recordsearch.naa.gov.au/SearchNRetrieve/Interface/ViewImage.aspx?B=3007001  The Herald, July 23, 1928, see here; The Argus, July 11, 1935, see here; Frank Stapley obituary The Argus, September 13, 1944, see here;  Sun News-Pictorial, February 28, 1948, see here.    

Death notice of Alec Hall

The Age, January 7, 1972, p. 13 from newspapers.com

(10) Frankston and Somerville Standard, April 7, 1922, see here. 

(11) Frankston and Somerville Standard, April 20, 1923, see here. 

(12) The Argus, June 9, 1923, see here.  
(13) Frankston and Somerville Standard, June 20, 1923, see here. 

(14) Frankston and Somerville Standard, June 29, 1923, see here. 

(15) The Age, April 26, 1924, see here.  

(16) Frankston and Somerville Standard, April 13, 1928, see here. 

(17) Henry Michael Collins - donations Frankston and Somerville Standard, August 30, 1922, see here and Frankston and Somerville Standard, March 4, 1925, see here; Church memorials - Frankston and Somerville Standard, October 23, 1925, see here and https://www.stpaulsfrankston.com.au/stained-glass-windows

(18) Henry Michael Collins obituary - Prahran Telegraph, June 15, 1928, see here. 

(19) Frankston and Somerville Standard, June 15, 1928, see here. 

(20) Monument Australia https://monumentaustralia.org.au/themes/conflict/multiple/display/31353-frankston-war-memorial-original 

(21) Virtual War Memorial Australia https://vwma.org.au/explore/memorials/2923 and Bayside News https://baysidenews.com.au/2016/03/21/memorial-on-way/

Fairfield's £250 Campaign and Barometer, 1918

I came across this photo of the State Savings Bank in Railway Place, Fairfield and noticed the barometer on the outside and what seemed to be a Red Cross sign. It turns out that it was part of a Red Cross appeal in May 1918 to raise money for their Comforts Fund,  to enable them to continue to carry out their work supplying comforts for sick and wounded soldiers and prisoners of war. This service cost the Red Cross £15,000 per month and they only had a reserve of  £70,000. As the only way to decrease this expenditure was to reduce the allowance to soldiers, which nobody would like to see done, the Red Cross launched the appeal and the people of Fairfield decided to raise £250, by donation. (1)

As a newspaper report said - Carnivals, raffles, concerts and displays of all kinds mean an immense amount of work and expense to make them a success. This time we want the generosity of the people and the objects of the appeal to stand on their merits by relying on the straight-out donation mostly to provide the amount required. (2)

Railway Place, Fairfield, 1918

State Library of Victoria image H84.427/1/37

On May 3, The Herald reported on the committee formed to raise Fairfield's contribution - 

Fairfield has set itself the task of raising £250, at least, as a contribution to the State School appeal for the Special Red Cross Fund, in one month from Monday, May 6. An executive committee, consisting of representatives of the Fairfield State School committee and Red Cross and patriotic bodies, has been formed, with Councillor F. Bryant, Shire President, as chairman. Councillors G. F. Pitcher (treasurer), J. Coate and A. May are also assisting the movement.

A feature of the effort will be straight-out donations from residents, and a barometer will he erected on the Fairfield Savings Bank to indicate each day's progress. Band performances and concerts will be held, and a personal canvass made of each house in the district. Large coppers will be placed at the station for pennies. The joint honorary secretaries are Messrs L. W. Barke and P. W. Hutchinson. (3)

The scheme to raise the £250 was publicised in the local paper.

Heidelberg News May 4, 1918 https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/89078417

The barometer on the State Savings Bank was made by the working committee of the Red Cross and painted by Mr Bryning (4) and provided a focus for community activities, as this report attests -  

A large crowd gathered in Railway place Fairfield, last evening, before the barometer erected on the Savings Bank to indicate the progress of the Fairfield effort to raise £250 in a month for the  Red Cross Fund. A band played and appeals were made by well-known citizen. A large Union Jack was carried among the crowd so that coins might be thrown into it. There was loud cheering as the indicator of the barometer moved up point after point. (5) Each point represented £5. (6)

As well as the visual reminder of the barometer right opposite the railway station and the lady collectors on duty at the station collecting copper coins from railway patrons and going door-to-door, there were newspaper articles explaining the scheme and 4,000 flyers were distributed - the local school children folded them and addressed them and the Scouts delivered them (7). 4,000 was the number of adults in the Fairfield school district, which was from Miller Street to Victoria Road. (8)

In the end after a month of concentrated effort, the Fairfield community raised £348/19/9. A financial report itemised the Receipts as - Direct donations £230/1/3; Boy Scouts' Sunday service £4/8/3; Band performance £6/5/; recruiting picture show 11/3, copper collections (Fairfield station £18/15/, Alphington station £7/6/) £26/1/; proceeds State school concert £71/0/9; scholars' self-denial at State school £25/9/6, total £363/17/.  The Expenditure was listed as - Stationery £1/3/9, printing and advertising (News) £13/13/6, balance £348/19/9 (9)

The £230/1/3 raised through direct donation was £20 short of their hoped for £250. However during the month, as well as the other fund raising, there had also been collected £85 for badges and £39/7/3 for buttons, making a grand total of £473/7/.  As joint secretaries Mr Barke and Mr Hutchinson reported - is very gratifying to know our efforts have met with such good results, and to know also that Fairfield has done its share in helping to send the necessary comforts to the boys at the front, which, of course was the ultimate object of all our efforts. (10)

The State Savings Bank in Fairfield, where the barometer was located, was a new building having been erected in 1916. As the local  paper reported in January 1916 -

Workmen have just finished pulling down two old shops in Railway Parade South, Fairfield, and at
present are engaged in excavating in connection with the erection of brick premises for the State Savings Bank of Victoria. The situation is ideal, and it is anticipated that the building will be a credit to the town. (11) The bank opened for business on May 24, 1916. (12)  As well as displaying the barometer, the bank manager, Percy Hutchinson was the joint secretary of the £250 campaign. The bank was also used for committee meetings, proved refreshments for the Heidelberg Brass Band when they performed in aid of the campaign, as well as taking care of the funds raised.

You can just see the State Savings Bank on the right with the barometer, so obviously taken the same day as the photograph at the top.

Fairfield Park Railway Station, 1918. (The name changed to Fairfield in 1943 (13))

 State Library of Victoria image H84.427/1/38  

Trove list - I have created a list of articles on Fairfield's  £250 appeal, access it here.

Footnotes

(1) Heidelberg News May 4, 1918, see here. 

(2) Ibid

(3) The Herald, May 3, 1918, see here.

(4) Heidelberg News May 4, 1918, see here. Mr Byrning was either Bertram Byrning of 8 Arthur Street, Fairfield, a coach painter or William Knowles, 4 Austin Street, Alphington, a signwriter. (1918 Electoral Roll information)

(5) The Herald, May 30, 1918, see here.

(6) Heidelberg News May 4, 1918, see here. 

(7) See various reports on my Trove list, here.

(8) Heidelberg News, June 22, 1918, see here.

(9) Ibid

(10) Ibid

(11) Heidelberg News, January 15, 1916, see here.

(12) The Herald, May 24, 1916, see here.

(13) https://vicsig.net/infrastructure/location/Fairfield

St Kilda Park State School Great War Honour Board designed by George Dancey

The St Kilda Park Primary School, No.2460,  is located in Fitzroy Street, St Kilda. The School opened on August 1, 1882 and a noted alumni is Sir Zelman Cowen (1919-2011), Governor General of Australia (1). The School was designed by Education Department Architect, Henry R. Bastow and the Victorian Heritage database describes it thus -The two storey school building is designed in the Gothic style, which was commonly adopted for larger school buildings from the late 1870s. It is a brown brick building with polychromatic contrasts in black, cream and red brick, set on a bluestone base. Asymmetrically composed on a corner site, it contains an unusual two storey splayed corner element which provides a visual transition between the two facades. Steep slate gable roofs, tall chimneys and a prominent tower provide a picturesque skyline, and pointed and trefoil arches with render label mouldings give a Gothic character. (2). 

St Kilda Park School, c. 1970s. Photographer:  Laurie Burchell. 

State Library of Victoria Image H2006.165/356

Not only is the school itself an elaborate confection of design, but it has a elaborate Great War Honour Board, one of the most glorious school Honour Boards I have seen. It commemorates the 150 past students who served overseas.

St Kilda Park School Honour Board

Image: Isaac Hermann, 2023

The Honour Board, designed by George Dancey and was unveiled by the Minister for Railways, and M.L.A for St Kilda,  Frederick Eggleston (3)  after  the Empire Day celebrations on May 23, 1924. The Herald reported on the event -

Mr Eggleston told the children that if the qualities exhibited by the men whose names appeared on the honor board wore displayed in the civil life  of the community, all its problems, social and political, would be solved. He reminded them of the splendid examples of courage and chivalry set by the Australian fighting forces during the war. Messrs Syme Harris, chairman of the school committee; R. Davey, district inspector; R. H. Trembath, headmaster; B. Ramsay, ex-headmaster, and Cr. Burnett Gray also spoke. The new honor board is a handsome piece of work designed by the late Mr George Dancey, the artist. It was executed in opus sectile by Brooks Robinson Pty. Ltd. The composition is tile-like and assembled in mosaic effect, the colored design being burnt in by a special process. The whole is enclosed in a copper frame. From the children's point of view the best part of the ceremony came this afternoon. Every State school child in the St. Kilda district was entertained at the Palais pictures by the Mayor and councillors and presented with a packet of sweets (4). 

Detail of the St Kilda Park School Honour Board, encased in the copper frame, showing George Dancey's signature. Fecit - 'He made'

Image: Isaac Hermann, 2023

The Honour Board was designed by George Henry Dancey. George was born in London on March 26, 1865 to Joseph and Clara (nee Bursill) Dancey (5).  He trained as an ecclesiastical artist at Clayton and Bell in London, one of England's most prolific stained glass studios in the Victorian and Edwardian eras (6).  Whilst at Clayton and Bell he worked on the stained glass windows for St Paul's Cathedral in Melbourne, which were then installed by Brooks, Robinson Pty Ltd, who made the St Kilda Park Honour Board (7). After his arrival in Victoria, he married Annie Maria Wills (nee Jenkinson) in 1893. She was the widow of John Wills and they had a daughter Ethel, who had been born in South Africa, where her parents were from.  In 1903,  Ethel married Alek Williams. Williams was an illustrator and cartoonist whose work appeared in the Bulletin, Punch and Smith's Weekly, under the name of Alex Sass. Alex died December 1, 1922 aged 44. George and Annie had the one daughter, Clara, in 1896 and she married Cyril Devenport in 1923. Just three weeks after the death of Alex, another tragedy struck the family when George died at his home at 11 Beaconsfield Parade, St Kilda on December 23, 1922 at the age of 58 years old, so he did not get to see see the Honour Board completed. He is buried at the Brighton Cemetery, with his wife Annie, who died in 1934, aged 78 (8).

George Dancey, 1908

Photographers: Johnstone, O'Shannessy & Co. 

State Library of Victoria Image H28902/17

The Prahran Telegraph printed a very informative and touching obituary - 

GEORGE DANCEY'S DEATH. Mural Painter and Cartoonist. Resident of St. Kilda.

Recently there passed away at his home in Beaconsfield parade, St.Kilda, one, George H. Dancey, cartoonist and mural painter. It would be interesting to know what this signifies to the ordinary St. Kilda citizen. It is very certain that he does not realise what a great artist had he had his opportunities and been appreciated as his merits deserved, has been lost to Australia. George Dancey was, unfortunately, a martyr to an art, mural decoration, which is in little demand as yet in this young country, still in the crysalis stage of commercial progress. But it is safe to say that had Mr. Dancey remained in England his fame would have been known throughout the civilised world. 

St. Kilda is fortunate in having two very fine examples of his work in war memorials, which are

to be found in Christ Church, Acland street, (9) and Holy Trinity Church,  Balaclava (10). It is a great pity that he was not commissioned to decorate in fitting manner the St. Kilda Town Hall. It would then have numbered among its visitors art lovers, who would have been further impressed with this beautiful city, and the city fathers might have had the pleasure of boasting of another reason for their pride in the 'Queen City of the Metropolis.' But, alas, the chance has gone by!

As a cartoonist on Melbourne 'Punch' Mr. Dancey was best known to the public. While his inclination was not towards this work, he persistently applied himself to it, for bread and butter reasons, and succeeded. His best cartoons are on nobles lines, seldom found in other work of this nature. After fifteen years study at the Kensington Art School, London, Mr. Dancey was forced by ill-health to come to Australia, some twenty-five years ago, and finding small demand for mural decoration, he became a cartoonist. In his mural painting Mr. Dancey was deeply influenced by Lord Leighton. Several of Mr. Dancey's original cartoons were shown in London about five years ago, when they attracted much attention. 

Among other branches of his art Mr. Dancey devoted himself largely to the designing of stained glass windows, at which he had been engaged for many years. Among his works of a purely decorative nature are two panels, Comedy and Tragedy, which adorn the proscenium slope of Her Majesty's Theatre.

To those who knew him personally the late artist was the most gentle, kindly sympathetic man imaginable, who had a good word for all, especially for those who tried to appreciate his art. For many years he was an invalid, and was attended by a devoted wife, who with a daughter and a stepdaughter, wife of the late Alex. Sass, the cartoonist, he has left behind to mourn his loss. As a result of his long illness and lack of support of his art, the family is not well provided for. The Victorian Artists' Society, it is understood, will hold a gift exhibition, at which the works shown will be presented by the artists and the proceeds will go to the dependents. (11). 

This was not the only time the Prahran Telegraph had bemoaned the lack of recognition and respect for George Dancey's art by the Australian public. This was written after the Honour Board was unveiled - 

The Honour Board at the St. Kilda Park Central School is a specially fine one, being the conception of that very fine artist, the late George Dancy, whose artistic worth was barely recognised in this country, we being apparently not sufficiently cultured to appreciate what a master he was in mural decorative art. In Europe Dancy would have found the fame and the fortune which lack of appreciative knowledge of this form of a great art failed to give to him in his own country. (12).

The Dancey Memorial Exhibition was held in May 1923 and raised for than £500 for the family (13).

Acknowledgment

Thank you to my research colleague, Isaac Hermann, for telling me about this wonderful Honour Board and allowing me to use his photographs, and thus leading me to George Dancey, whom I had not heard of before.

Trove list - I have compiled a short list of newspaper articles relating to this Honour Board and George Dancey, access it here.

Footnotes

(1) Vision and Realisation: a centenary history of State Education in Victoria edited by Les Blake (Education Department of Victoria, 1973);

(2) Victorian Heritage Database https://vhd.heritagecouncil.vic.gov.au/places/1109 

(3) Sir Frederick William Eggleston (1875-1954) see Australian Dictionary of Biography entry here  https://adb.anu.edu.au/biography/eggleston-sir-frederic-william-344

(4) The Herald, May 23, 1924, see here.

(5) Church of England Births and Baptisms, 1813-1923, London Metropolitan Archives on Ancestry.com

(6) Clayton and Bell - https://www.visitstainedglass.uk/artist-page/clayton-bell and 

https://www.claytonandbell.org.uk/home 

(7) George's entry in Who’s Who in Australia, 1921-1950, on-line at Ancestry.com, lists his connection to Clayton and Bell.  

Brooks, Robinson Pty Ltd - more information https://www.emelbourne.net.au/biogs/EM01420b.htm 

Who’s Who in Australia, 1921-1950, on-line at Ancestry.com

(8) Victorian Indexes to the Births, Deaths and Marriages; Family notices notices - see my Trove list; and his obituary, as transcribed above. Alex Sass - obituary in Smith's Weekly, here; and Sydney Evening News, here.

(9) Christ Church, Acland Street - read about George's work here. It was unveiled December 11, 1921.

(10) Holy Trinity Church, Balaclava - read about George's work here. It was unveiled August 6, 1922. 

(11) Prahran Telegraph, February 2, 1923, see here.

(12) Prahran Telegraph, May 30 1924, see here.

(13) The Herald, May 26, 1923, see here.

World War One soldiers with a connection to Narre Warren, Narre Warren North and Narre Warren East

This is a list of any men I could find with a Narre Warren or Narre Warren North or Narre Warren East connection who enlisted in World War One. Twenty nine of the men are on the Narre Warren War Memorial. They are listed as J. Brown / E. Buchanan / C. Burns / J. Dewar / D. Duncan / J. Duncan /  F. Dunwell / A. Hillbrich / E. Hillbrich / H. Hillbrich /  P. Ireland / A. Kent / C. Kent / N. Kent /  D. McKenzie /  A. McLure / G. Mouser / J. Muffit /  W. Neil / S. Nutter / L. Sage / G. Smith / 

W. Smith / A. Stedman / W. Stedman / A. Wanke / F. Wanke / N. Wauchope / G. Woodley (1).

Eighteen of the men are on the Narre Warren North War Memorial. They are listed on the monument as C. Asling / H. Asling / H. Battersby / H. Battersby / A. Brown / R. Brown / A. Collis / M Collis / H. Curtis / J. Dean / P. Hill / J. Moors / R Moors / G. Rae / W. Rae / H. Randle / L. Sage / A. Sheriff (2).

One soldier, Louis Sage, is on both. The other names I found in newspaper reports including a report of the eight men who worked for Donald Rowe, a baker of Narre Warren, who all enlisted. If you know of anyone else, connected to Narre Warren or Narre Warren North, I would be interested in hearing about them. 

Narre Warren originally referred to the township of Narre Warren North, which was surveyed around 1860. This was later known as Old Narre Warren to distinguish it from New Narre Warren which developed around the Railway Station, which opened in 1882. It is likely that some of these men who have their birthplace as Narre Warren, were actually born in 'old' Narre Warren or Narre Warren North.  Narre Warren East is a small town off Wellington Road in the Berwick Road and Mountain Flat, Edebohls and Haysey Roads vicinity. The State School No. 3719, opened in February 1912, in the Anglican Church Hall. It initially operated half time with Menzies Creek, No. 2457, but they both became full-time in 1914. In February 1921, a new school building was erected. The Church of England was called St Mungo's, there was also a public hall, which was opened on November 30, 1928 (3).

The Narre Warren War Memorial was officially unveiled by Colonel George Knox on March 12, 1922 (4).  It was originally erected on the corner of the Princes Highway and the Narre Warren North Road at the recreation reserve. The original memorial had a lovely arch, which you can see in the photograph, below. The arch was removed in 1949 or 1950.  The War Memorial was moved in 1993 to a location near the Civic Centre at Narre Warren and is now located on the Bunjil Place forecourt.  It's interesting to note that seven of the men listed on the Narre Warren War Memorial have their connection to the area because their fathers were Victorian Railway employees and had been appointed to the Narre Warren Railway Station.

Narre Warren War Memorial, erected 1923.

Image: Oak Trees and Hedges: a pictorial history of Narre Warren, Narre Warren North and Harkaway (5).

The Narre Warren North War Memorial was unveiled by Lieutenant Colonel Knox in March 1922. There is also an Avenue of Honour at Narre Warren North, which was dedicated in September 1919 (6).  

The Narre Warren North War Memorial

Photograph courtesy of the Casey Cardinia Remembers website. There are more photos of the memorial here

http://www.caseycardiniaremembers.org.au/narre-warren-north-war-memorial/

What follows is the list of First World Soldiers connected to Narre Warren, Narre Warren North and Narre Warren East and their Service Number (SN) so you can look up their full service records on the National Archives website, www.naa.gov.au

Asling, Charles (SN 69229)
Asling, Henry (69230)
Charles and Henry were twins, born February 24, 1899. They enlisted on August 17, 1918 at the age of 19. They embarked on November 2, but the troopship was recalled due to the War ending and they were discharged in January 1919. The boys, both farmers, were born in Narre Warren North. They were the sons of Charles and Elizabeth (nee Meade) Asling of Narre Warren North. The brothers are listed on the Narre Warren North War Memorial.

Social for the Asling twins and Price Hill.

South Bourke & Mornington Journal October 31, 1918 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article66194926

Battersby, Herbert David (SN 1218) Herbert was born in and lived in Narre Warren North. He enlisted at the age of 21 on March 11, 1916. He was a labourer and his next of kin was his mother, Jane. He was wounded in action in Belgium and died as a result on May 29, 1917. His injuries were horrific - right leg blown off as were toes of his left leg. Herbert was the son of Edward and Jane (nee Crowley) Battersby of Granite Grove, Narre Warren North. He is listed on the Narre Warren North War Memorial.

Report of the sad death of Lance-Corporal Battersby

Dandenong Advertiser, June 21, 1917 https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/88662435#

Battersby, John Henry (SN 2582) Henry as he was known, was a 23 year old timber worker when he enlisted on July 14, 1915. He Returned to Australia on March 28, 1919. His next of kin was his father, John Battersby of Hallam Road, Dandenong. John and Susan (nee Skinner) had ten children and built Cloverdale Cottage in 1870. Cloverdale Cottage is still standing in Hallam North Road and is listed on the City of Casey Heritage Conservation Study. Henry is listed on the Narre Warren North Memorial

Brown, J. The Narre Warren War Memorial lists a J. Brown, my best guess at the moment is that it could be John Alfred Brown (SN 64160).  John was born in Hallam but was living in East Caulfield when he enlisted on May 7, 1918. He was 20 years old and a clerk with the Victorian Railways.  He left Australia in September 1918, suffered from pleurisy (right lung, very severe was the notation in his record) and he Returned to Australia on July 26, 1919 and was discharged on medical grounds on September 13, 1919.
Brown, Alfred Hart (SN 1217)
Brown, Robert Woodside (SN 3040) 

Robert and Alfred are brothers from Narre Warren North and they are both listed on the Narre Warren North Memorial.

Robert Woodside Brown (SN 3040) enlisted on July 21, 1915. He was a 24 year old farmer.  Robert Returned to Australia on May 18, 1919. His brother,  Alfred Hart Brown (SN 1217) was a 21 year old carpenter and he enlisted on November 8, 1916.  Alfred Returned to Australia on December 11, 1918. They were the sons of Edward and Claudia (nee Kerr) Brown of Narre Warren North. 

Farewell to Alf Brown, Herbert Battersby and Walter Young.

Berwick Shire News May 3, 1916 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article92089861

Buchanan, Eric Alexander  (SN 1676) Eric was from Station Street, Berwick and enlisted on July 14, 1915. He was a 21 year old Clerk, the son of Charles and Christina (nee McPhail) Buchanan. Eric Returned to Australia on July 23, 1919. I am not sure of Eric's full connection to Narre Warren  - he was born in Yarrawonga, but his mother changed her address as next of kin in January 1919 to Narre Warren North. The Dandenong Advertiser had an article on October 10, 1918 (see here) about the death of Trooper Louis Tchampian of Cockatoo and it mentioned that he was a pal of Sergt. Eric Buchanan of Narre Warren, so Eric was obviously identified with Narre Warren.

Farewell function for Eric Buchanan

Berwick Shire News October 13, 1915 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article92091152

Burns, Charlie. Charlie Burns is on the Narre Warren War Memorial. I have not positively identified him as yet but there are various reports in local papers at the time of his talents as a entertainer at local functions. At the annual cricket club concert held October 9, 1914, it was reported that Charlie was again to the fore with his humorous songs, clog dances and spoon items (see here)  There was  a report of his recent enlistment in the February 16, 1916 issue of the paper (see below).  The AIF Project website has five Charles Burns who enlisted from Victoria and going by occupation (he's  a labourer) and date of enlistment I believe (but I cannot confirm) that our Charles has the Service Number of 4373 and enlisted on December 24, 1915. He Returned to Australia May 29, 1919.

Charlie Burns and Arthur Sherriff enlist

Pakenham Gazette  February 16, 1916 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article92095559

Charman, Herbert Henry (SN 3360). Herbert was born in Narre Warren and enlisted at the age of 19 on February 9, 1917. He was a carpenter. His parents, Thomas William and Kate (nee Brown) Charman, gave their consent to his enlistment. They lived at Oxford Street, Oakleigh. Herbert Returned to Australia February 19, 1919.

Chitts, Vic  (SN possibly 1715) Vic was employed by Donald Rowe, the baker of Narre Warren, and was one of his eight employees to enlist.  As the article, below, notes Mr D.H. Rowe, a baker, of Narre Warren, has been considerably inconvenienced by the quick changes in his staff but he has shown his patriotism in recognising that the needs of the Empire should have consideration before his personal requirements. Donald Hartley Rowe is listed in the Shire of Berwick Rate books from 1912 to 1922, renting his bakery from Sidney Webb. You would think with such a distinctive name that Mr Chitts would be easy to identify, but not so. There was a Clarence, a Hector and a Russell Chitts who enlisted - Russell was a painter from New South Wales; Clarence was a Dairyman from Sandringham and I have found him and his wife Alice in the Electoral Roll both before and after the War and there is no local connection. That leaves Hector Rudolph Chitts as the most likely, so maybe he was known as Vic (for some unknown reason). Hector  was nearly 20 when he enlisted on March 7, 1916, his next of kin was listed as his sister, Mrs Downs of East Malvern. His occupation was a farm hand. He Returned to Australia on February 2, 1919.

Mr Rowe's patriotism.

Berwick Shire News November 10, 1915 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article92090828

Colliss, Alfred (SN 6780) Alfred said he was 44 years and 3 months old when he enlisted on January 18, 1917. He lived at Narre Warren North and was a labourer. His next of kin was his sister Helena Smith, the mother of Harold Curtis (see below). In reality Alfred was actually 46 and looks his stated age...and not capable of carrying on full training according to his medical report. He was sent home from England in November 1917 and discharged on medical grounds, and the fact that he was overage,
in February 1918. Alfred is listed on the Narre Warren North War Memorial.
Colliss, Malcolm John (SN 6980) Malcolm enlisted on October 18, 1916 at the age of 31. He was a labourer, lived at Narre Warren and his next of kin was his brother, Joseph Colliss of Yallock. Malcolm Returned to Australia November 1, 1917 suffering from Tubercular peritonitis. He was discharged on July 2, 1918 and died on August 14, 1918. Malcolm is listed on the Narre Warren North War Memorial.
Alfred, Malcolm and Helena were born in Narre Warren and were the children of Joseph and Elizabeth (nee Charman) Collis.

Report of Colliss family War service

Berwick Shire News February 28, 1917 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article92093612

Cook, John Francis (SN 129) John enlisted on January 20, 1915. He was a 21 year old grocer. He Returned to Australia April 11, 1916 and discharged on medical grounds - he had Enteric fever (typhoid) and had also been wounded - shrapnel wound to knee and face.
Cook, Thomas Frederic (SN 10598) Thomas was a teacher at Warrandyte State School when he enlisted on January 19, 1916. He was 25 years old. He Returned to Australia April 30, 1919.
The brothers were born in Narre Warren. Their parents were Thomas Galliard and Annie Maria (nee Hayden) Cook of Westgarth Street, Northcote.

Crotty, Gerald Francis Xavier (SN 6983) Gerald enlisted on October 24, 1916. He was a 23 year old Military clerk. Gerald Returned to Australia September 25, 1919.

Crotty, John Patrick Joseph (SN 2783) John was 26 years old when he enlisted on April 26, 1916. He was a clerk. He did not serve overseas and was discharged as medically unfit on May 19, 1917.
John and Gerald were both born in Narre Warren. They were the sons of John Patrick and Teresa (nee Logan) Crotty of Frederick Street, Hawthorn.

Cunningham, Albert (SN 1245) Albert was a 30 year old butcher and farmer when he enlisted on February 25, 1916. He was wounded whilst serving - gun shot wound - shell right eye and Returned to Australia November 20, 1918.
Cunningham, Claude Sydney (SN 1246) Claude enlisted on March 18, 1916 at the age of 24. He was a farmer. Claude Returned to Australia April 30, 1919.
Albert was born in Dunedin in New Zealand; Claude was born in Sydney. Their next of kin was their mother, Emma Cunningham, of Narre Warren East.

Currie, Reg (SN 1840)  Reg was also employed by Donald Rowe (see above under Vic Chitts). He was the son of Donald and Margaret (nee Doran) Currie of Reserve Street in Berwick and he enlisted on November 6, 1915, at the age of 22.  His occupation was Horse Driver. He Returned to Australia April 13, 1919.

Curtis, Harold David (SN 4763) Harold was only 18 when he enlisted on September 28, 1915. He was  a blacksmith. His next of kin was his mother, Helena Smith, of Narre Warren North. Harold Returned to Australia April 13, 1919.  Harold is listed on the Narre Warren North War Memorial, along with his uncles, Alfred and Malcolm Colliss (see above).

Dean, James  (SN 2999) James was born in Sydney and was a 42 year old market gardener when he enlisted on March 17, 1916. His next of kin was his wife Frances, of Narre Warren North. James Returned to Australia March 28, 1919. James is listed on the Narre Warren North War Memorial. James was granted a Soldier Settlement farm, you can read his file, here.

Farewell to James Dean and Louis Sage

Dandenong Advertiser August 17, 1916 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article88658212

Dewar, Alfred James.  Alfred enlisted on July 20, 1915 and he died of 'cerebro spinal meningitis'  less than a month later on August 15, 1915. His father's address was Drouin on the enlistment papers, but they had previously lived in Harkaway. Private Dewar had returned home suffering form what he thought was influenza, but it turned out to be meningitis and his mother, who was nursing him contracted the disease and died after 24 hours illness, and he died soon after. A tragic story. Alfred is commemorated on the Narre Warren War Memorial.

Alfred Dewar's mother dies of meningitis; and even though it was reported that he had recovered he sadly  also died.

The Age August13, 1915 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article1548396

The Dewar Family and their connection to Harkaway.

Berwick Shire News, August 18, 1915  http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article92090119

Drury, Wilfred (SN 566) Wilfred enlisted March 13, 1916. He was a 23 year old farmhand and his address was c/o Mr H. Hillbrick, Narre Warren. His next of kin was his mother, Margaret Taylor, of Geelong. Wilfred was wounded in action - gunshot wound to the scalp - and Returned to Australia September 27, 1917 and was discharged on medical grounds in January 1918. 

Duncan, David Baird (SN 2366)  There is a D. Duncan on the Narre Warren War Memorial who I believe is David Baird Duncan based solely on his occupation of Orchardist. The Bailey family had established  an orchard at Narre Warren North in the 1890s and this was the first of many orchards in this area, thus being an orchardist is a likely occupation for someone from Narre Warren, but I cannot find any actual connection to this area. David was born in Scotland and enlisted on May 10, 1915 at the age of 20. He Returned to Australia April 5, 1919.  There are actually two other D. Duncans who enlisted from Victoria -  David John Duncan (SN 2292) was a coach builder and David Francis Duncan (SN 6665) was a jeweller, both have a Melbourne address, so I feel that David Baird Duncan is the right man.

Duncan, James Ramsay (SN 432) James was born in Berwick and he enlisted on September 28, 1914. He was a 30 year old commercial traveller and his next of kin was his mother, Elizabeth Duncan, of Kew.  James was a Lieutenant and he returned to Australia on April 15, 1918. He was discharged on medical grounds suffering from Pulmonary Tuberculosis. James is listed on the Narre Warren War Memorial

Dunwell, Fred   (SN 1392)    Fred was from Narre Warren and he enlisted July 31,  1915. He was a 25 year old carpenter, born in Yorkshire, and his next of kin was his sister, Hannah, also of Narre Warren.  Fred returned to Australia on July 18, 1919. Fred is listed on the Narre Warren War Memorial.

Edebohls, Arthur (SN 3135) Arthur enlisted on October 31, 1916. He was a 23 year old labourer and he Returned to Australia March 2, 1919.
Edebohls, Edwin John (SN 3136) Edwin enlisted at the age of 26 on July 13, 1915 and was discharged at Broadmeadows on December 13, 1915. He re-enlisted on October 27, 1916 and this time was accepted, served overseas and Returned to Australia July 24, 1919.
The brothers were born in Narre Warren and they were the sons of Henry and Mary (nee Troup) Edebohls. At the time of enlistment the family was living at Frankston Road, Dandenong. Mary was the daughter of John and Elizabeth (nee Fox) Troup. John Troup had purchased land in the area in 1855. Mary was also the sister of Ann Rae, so the Edebohls boys were first cousins of the Rae brothers, written about below.

Fordon, John Henry (SN 1230 / 1462) John was a 39 year old labourer, from Narre Warren, when he enlisted on October 13, 1914. His next of kin was his sister, Mrs Smith,  who lived in Western Australia. John Returned to Australia February 13, 1917 and was discharged on medical grounds - Chronic Alcoholism - in the June. 

Forrester, George (SN 4810)  George, who was a baker,  enlisted on November 6, 1915, the same day as Reg Currie and like Reg he was also employed by Donald Rowe, the baker. George was born in Shepparton, and his next of kin was his father, Zephaniah Forrester of Taradale. He Returned to Australia July 24, 1919.

Notice of Reg Currie  and George Forrester enlist.

Dandenong Advertiser, November 18, 1915 https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/88663150

Gander, Albert Frederick  (SN 7004) Frederick, as he was known, enlisted on October 18, 1916. He was a 28 year old farm hand. He Returned to Australia May 1917 and was discharged on medical grounds - hammer toes and Tachy Cardia. Fred enlisted for a second time on June 4, 1918 in the Australian Naval and Military Expeditionary Force and served in New Britain, and Returned to Australia from Rabaul August 6, 1919. Fred was born in England, his next of kin was his father who lived in Western Australia. His address on his first enlistment was Narre Warren and, on his second enlistment, was Hallam.

Haysey, Norman (SN 6813A) Norman was a 19 year old orchardist when he enlisted on August 12, 1917. He was Killed in Action on July 4, 1918.
Haysey, Robert Ellesmere (SN 2588) Robert was a 20 year old orchardist when he enlisted on May 17, 1915. He was awarded the Croix de Guerre by the Belgium King and he Returned to Australia May 30, 1919.
The boys, were born in Seymour and their address on their Attestation papers was Narre Warren North. Robert listed his mother, Annie Haysey (nee Adkins) of Narre Warren North as his next of kin and Norman, his father George of Seymour, as his next of kin. A notation on Norman's Attestation file said 'Mother, living apart from husband'. There is also a note that Norman's medals were to go to his mother.

Report of the Haysey family

The Age July 29, 1918 https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/1405381

Hill, Abraham Price (SN 1716)  Mr Hill was known as Price and is listed on the Narre Warren North War Memorial as P. Hill. Price was a 37 year orchardist from Narre Warren North when he enlisted on June 22, 1918. His next of kin was his wife, Clara (nee Lehman). He did not serve overseas and was demobilised December 24, 1918. Price enlisted again on January 16, 1919 in the Australian Naval and Military Expeditionary Force, served in New Britain and Returned to Australia from Rabaul February 16, 1921.  

Hillbrich - Ernest and Harold and an A. Hillbrich are listed on the Narre Warren War Memorial. The surname is spelt as Hillbrick on the Attestation papers, Embarkation and Nominal Rolls.

Hillbrich, A  I am not sure who this is. There are only three Hillbrichs who enlisted - Ernest and Harold and the other one was Norman (SN 5326) who enlisted on January 4, 1916 and Died of Wounds on May 6, 1917. He was the son of Gustav Wilhelm and Jessie (nee Neame) Hillbrich and born in Korumburra according to his enlistment paper. His mother was living in Western Australia, which is where he enlisted. 
Hillbrich, Ernest William (SN 3989 and 1045) Ernest was a 19 year old farmer from Narre Warren when he enlisted on March, 9, 1915. He was born in New South Wales, the son of Edward Gustave and Amy (nee Morton) Hillbrich. Ernest Returned to Australia on March 28, 1919.
Hillbrich, Harold Herbert (SN 11760) Harold was born in Narre Warren to Ernst Johann Gottlieb and Maria Augusta (nee Schoppe) and enlisted on November 3, 1915. He was a 22 year old postman. Harold Returned to Australia on June 12, 1919.
The three Hillbrich boys are all descendants of Johann and Maria (nee Wagner) Hillbrich who settled in Harkaway in 1855. Norman and Harold were grandsons; Ernest was the son of Harold's older brother and he was thus a great grandson (or to explain it another way - Norman and Harold are first cousins and Ernest is Harold's nephew.)

Ireland, Percy Markham De Courcy (SN 1116).  Percy is listed on the Narre Warren War Memorial, Percy's parents, De Courcy and Margaret Ireland are listed in the Electoral Rolls at Narre Warren in 1903, so it is possible that Percy went to school at Narre Warren. In 1914 the family was living in Heidelberg. Percy enlisted on May 25, 1915; he was a 21 year old Electrical Engineer. Percy Returned to Australia on April 13, 1919.

Johnstone, Harold. Harold was another one of Donald Rowe's employees, but I cannot identify him. I  have looked for Harold Johnson, Johnston and Johnstone and cannot find a man who enlisted with a connection to the area or to the bakers trade.  

Kent, Alfred Ernest (SN 3336). Alfred enlisted on August 2, 1915 at the age of 40. Alfred is also on the Berwick Grammar School memorial in Church Street, Berwick. He was born in Berwick and was married to Alice Webb, the daughter of Sidney and Ann Webb. Lance Corporal Kent was Killed in Action in France on May 5, 1916.

Kent, Charles Edward ( SN 237) Charles was a 36 year old farmer from Narre Warren and he enlisted on February 28, 1916. He was born in Berwick. Charles Returned to Australia on April 5, 1918.
Kent, Norman Archibald (SN 1009) Norman enlisted on October 1, 1914. He was 32 years old, born in Narre Warren and a farmer. Second Lieutenant Kent Died of Wounds on April 12, 1917.
The Kents were from Narre Warren and their parents, Anthony and Mary Kent, had arrived in Narre Warren around 1875 and purchased Granite Park, which they re-named Oatlands. The brothers are listed on the Narre Warren War Memorial

The sad news of the Kent family

Pakenham Gazette, May 18 1917 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article92155593

Le Mausrier, John William (SN 9564) John was born in Narre Warren, however he was living in Rathmines Road, Fairfield when he enlisted on July 6, 1915 at the age of 22. He was a salesman. His next of kin was his father, John, of the same address. John Returned to Australia June 20, 1919.

Lewis, Frederick (SN 3897)  Frederick was 24 when he enlisted. His occupation was baker's driver and he also worked by Donald Rowe.  His next of kin was his father, Caleb Lewis, of Wilson Street, Berwick.  Fred Returned to Australia March 28, 1919. 

Lyons, Charles Jack  (SN 1394)   Jack enlisted on September 14, 1914 at the age of 27. He was born in South Melbourne and enlisted in Tasmania, but his occupation was baker,  and he was another of Mr Rowe's employees. His actual occupation on his enlistment paper was 'stud groom and baker.' He Returned to Australia on May 12, 1918, suffering from rhuematism and 'bad feet'.

MacKenzie, Dugald (SN 6069) Dugald enlisted on March 22, 1916. He 33 years old, was a widower and his occupation was 'nurseryman labourer'. His address on enlistment was Cecil Street in South Melbourne, but a Dugald MacKenzie is listed in the 1914 Electoral Rolls at Narre Warren, occupation Nurseryman, so I am sure that we have the right man. Dugald was Killed in Action in France on May 4, 1917. He left behind a daughter, Edna, who was being cared for by her grandmother, Kate O'Shea of Footscray. Dugald is listed on the Narre Warren War Memorial.

http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article120982275

I came across this note from the Upper Murray & Mitta Herald of May 31, 1917 about the death of  a Dugald MacKenzie. Firstly, the age does not tally with the age of 'our' Dugald, however Mr Stedman was the Station Master at Narre Warren in from 1898 until 1906 and his two sons are also on the Memorial. Mrs Stedman was Helen Jane Bell and Dugald was the son of Archibald MacKenzie and Jessie Bell. This means that Dugald was the first cousin of the Stedman boys, listed below.

McClure, Alexander David  (SN 516) Alexander enlisted on February 10, 1915. He was the son of Colin McClure. Alexander was a miner from Benalla when he enlisted. His connection to the area is confirmed in the article, below.  The article (7) says that he was known as Yank as he had spent time in America; his friend, Lance Corporal Stringer said of him -  ‘Yank’ McClure was one of my best friends at Anzac. We shared the same dug-out, and lived and fought together, he was, I think, the most popular man in our company. His unfailing good humor and pluck made everyone like him. Alexander Died of Wounds, received at Gallipoli,  November 20, 1915.Alexander  is listed on the Narre Warren War Memorial.

Report of Alexander's death. 

Berwick Shire News May 17 1916  Click on this link to read the full report http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article92089339

McGuire, Harry.  I cannot identify this man, who worked for Donald Rowe.  I have also looked at any Harry or Henry Maguires, but to no avail.

Moore, William Robert - see under Moors.

Moors, James Humphrey (SN 1169) James was 18 years old when he enlisted on October 11, 1915. He was a farmhand. James Returned to Australia January 25, 1919.
Moors, William Robert (SN 581) Enlisted under the surname Moore. Robert enlisted on July 5, 1915 at the age of 21. He was a labourer. He was wounded - gun shot wound hip, penetrating abdomen - and died as a result on July 28, 1916.
William and James were born in Broken Hill and were living in Narre Warren on enlistment. They were the sons of Humphrey and Haddie Moore. Humphrey has a statuary declaration in William's file that says my wife left me 8-9 years ago and that I bore all the responsibility of bringing up my family. There is also a letter in his file from his sister, Mrs H. J. Hall of View Hill, Narre Warren. She had requested her brother's medals as her father considered I was entitled to my late brother's medals having carried out the responsibility of the mother towards the late soldier. The Moors brothers are listed on the Narre Warren North War Memorial.

Mouser, George.  Lieutenant Mouser is listed on the Narre Warren War Memorial. George Mouser  enlisted on May 1, 1916. His next of kin was his father, John Mouser of Narre Warren. John was the Station Master at Narre Warren from July 1915 to August 1918.  He Returned to Australia on July 24, 1919. George is also listed on the Bunyip Methodist Church Honour Roll.  His father was at the Bunyip Station around 1903.

Moysey, William Brown Treeby (SN 239) William was born in Narre Warren and enlisted on March 31, 1916. He was a 29 year old farmer. He was the son of William Henry and Marie (nee Aurisch) Moysey of Jumbuk. William was awarded the Military Medal and Returned to Australia  November 7, 1919. William's grandparents, James Bickford and Susannah Brown (nee Treeby) Moysey arrived in Victoria around 1844 and had a farm in Moorabbin. In 1881 they moved to Narre Warren. 

Muffett, John Henry (SN 3104) He is listed as Muffit on the Narre Warren War Memorial.  John enlisted on January 6, 1917 and was Killed in Action on August 26, 1918. I believe that the connection to Narre Warren can be found in a report in South Bourke and Mornington Journal of April 8, 1903 (see here).  The article reports that railway line repairer, Benjamin Muffit (sic) was killed on the railway line. Muffit resided in a gate house on Lalor's Road, about a quarter of a mile from the Narre Warren Station. He was 42 years old at the time of the accident and he left a wife and four children. There is a birth of a John Henry Muffett in 1892 to a Benjamin and Mary Muffett and his next of kin on his enlistment paper is his mother, Mary. I believe that John is the son of the deceased railway worker and may have went to school at Narre Warren.

Neil, W. This man is listed on the Narre Warren War Memorial, but I have not been able to identify him. There was a William Neill who was the Station Master at Narre Warren from April 1912 until he was transferred to Yarra Glen on June 1, 1914. Is this the connection? He had a son Wilfred Vivian born 1894 but I can't find any evidence that he enlisted.  Any help appreciated on this one.

Nutter, S. This man is also listed on the Narre Warren War Memorial.  There were only four men who enlisted with the surname of Nutter - Alan and Lawrence are brothers from Killara in Sydney; John Nutter was from England and enlisted in Sydney and doesn't seem to have any connection with the area. There is also a William Nutter Scott, born in England and enlisted in Sydney and once again I can find no connection between him and this area.

Pennycook, Ronald (SN 1016 & 38069).  Ronald enlisted on August 17, 1914 at the age of 21. His occupation was Sailor and Labourer. His next of kin was his father, Captain Pennycook, Master Mariner, Liverpool in England. Ronald Returned to Australia May 8, 1916 with a fractured skull.  He re-enlisted April 7, 1917 and this time his occupation was Sailor and Horseman. His address on the Embarkation rolls at both enlistments was Narre Warren North.  Ronald Returned to Australia November 22, 1919. There is a notation in his Attestation file that he signed a Statuatory Declaration on October 13, 1920 that his real surname was Pennycuik.

Rae, George Frederick (SN 5071) George enlisted on January 20, 1916 at the age of 23. He Returned to Australia March 25, 1919.
Rae, Walter John (SN 820). Walter was 18 years old when he enlisted on March 1, 1915. He Returned to Australia April 19, 1919.
The boys were both born in Narre Warren and were farmers from Narre Warren North. Their next of kin was their mother, Ann; their father Frederick had died January 3, 1915 at the age of 48. In the late 1860s Frederick's parents, George and Agnes (nee Webb) Rae, took up land in Narre Warren North and built a store, said to be the first building in the town. Ann Rae was the daughter of John and Elizabeth (nee Fox) Troup and a sister to Mary Edebohls and an aunt to Arthur and Edwin Edebohls, written about above. The Rae brothers are listed on the Narre Warren North War Memorial.

Randle, Henry George (SN 1274).  Henry was born in Narre Warren and enlisted on July 10, 1915 at the age of 27. His occupation was Orchardist and his next of kin was his father, William, of Narre Warren North. Henry Returned to Australia May 15, 1919.  Corporal Randle is listed on the Narre Warren North War Memorial.

Welcome home to Henry Randle and Robert Brown

South Bourke & Mornington Journal July 31, 1919. Click on this link to read the full report  https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/66196497

Rooney, Alfred George (SN 481) Alf was born at Ballarat and enlisted at Ballarat on October 15, 1914. His occupation was a labourer and he was another employee of Donald Rowe, the baker. Alf's next of kin was his father James, of Ballarat East.  Alf was awarded the Military Medal for having carried ammunition and water under heavy fire in the desert fighting of August 9, 1916.  He Returned to Australia on January 2, 1919.

Alfred Rooney's Military Medal

Berwick Shire News, March 28, 1917 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article92090256

Sage, Louis Francis (SN 30437)  When Louis enlisted on March 2, 1916 his next of kin was his mother, Margaret Sage of Narre Warren North and he was 23 years old and a farmer. He Returned to Australia on January 30, 1918. He was discharged on medical grounds, due to acute rheumatism. Louis is listed on both the the Narre Warren War Memorial and the Narre Warren North War Memorial.

Sherriff, Arthur Mason (SN 4529) Arthur was 26 year old Nurseryman when he enlisted on December 24, 1915. Arthur's next of kin was listed as his wife, Violet, of Narre Warren.  He received a gunshot wound to the left wrist whilst serving in France in August 1916 and after treatment,  Returned to Australia in September 1917 and was discharged on medical grounds on December 14, 1917.  Arthur is listed on the Narre Warren North War Memorial. Arthur was the son of Alexander and Margaret (nee Gaskell) Sherriff and he is the first cousin (8) of Mary Alice Sherriff, who was a World War One Army Nurse. I have written about her, here.

Arthur Sherriff returns home

Dandenong Advertiser, November 8, 1917 https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/88818546

Sievers,  Frederick Richard (SN 1615). Frederick enlisted on December 16, 1914 at the age of 26, he was a labourer and his next of kin was his father, Richard, of Narre Warren. He fought at Gallipoli where a bomb burst close to him causing headaches, dizziness and defective eyesight. He was declared permanently unfit for War service. Frederick Returned to Australia October 1915 and was discharged January 24, 1916. 

Report of the return of Frederick Sievers and a presentation to Mrs Rae, for her son Walter and to Mrs Smith for her son, Harold. This is Harold Curtis, see above.

South Bourke & Mornington Journal March 2, 1916 https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/page/6366531

Smith, George Stephen (SN 3679). George was born in Horsham and was living at Longwarry when he enlisted on August 7, 1915. He was Killed in Action in France on March 31, 1917. It took some research to identify George as, according to the Australian War Memorial website, there were 53 G. Smiths who did not return, of these 19 were Victorians, so I concentrated on these 19 and still could not find a Narre Warren connection until I found a George Adolphus Smith listed in the 1903 Electoral Roll, where he was the Station Master at Narre Warren. Then I went back to my 19 soldiers and discovered that our George was the son of a George Adolphus Smith and that the elder George was listed as the Station Master at Longwarry in 1914 Electoral rolls, so it all fitted. George was 19 when he enlisted in 1915. An article in the South Bourke and Mornington Journal in  June 1909 (see below) reports that Mr George Smith was leaving Narre Warren after eight years as Assistant Station Master, so both young George and his brother, William would have attended Narre Warren State School. As a matter of interest, Colin McClure, the father of Alexander McClure, above, 'occupied the chair' for the Smith's farewell social.
Smith, William Edward (SN 20121) William is also the son of George Adolphus and Alice Elizabeth (nee Bail) Smith and was born at Creswick and was living at Longwarry when he enlisted on April 4, 1917, just four days after his brother was killed. He was 18 years old. William Returned to Australia July 18, 1919. The brothers are listed on the Narre Warren War Memorial.

In June 1909, George and William Smith's father was farewelled from Narre Warren after eight years as assistant Station Master.

South Bourke and Mornington Journal, June 23, 1909 - click on this link to read the full report  http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article66200274

Stedman, Albert (SN 3262) Albert enlisted on July 14, 1915 at the age of 18 years and 8 months, or so he said. He was an 'asbestos worker' not an occupation that you hear of today. His father, also called Albert, was Station Master at Outtrim, was listed as his next of kin. Albert was Killed in Action in France on July 28, 1916 and a newspaper report in The Herald (see below) said he was actually on 17 years and 8 months old, so he was only 16 when he enlisted.
Stedman, Walter (SN 3909) Walter enlisted on November 4, 1915. He was 26 years old and a grocer. Walter Returned to Australia February 13, 1917 and discharged on medical grounds due to a gun-shot wound to his right foot.
Albert senior was the Station Master at Narre Warren for eight years and he left in July 1906 as he was appointed to Port Fairy. A report in the South Bourke and Mornington Journal of July 11, 1906 (see here) says that Mrs and Mrs Stedman had a very enjoyable farewell social at the Mechanics' Institute. The boys, who are listed on the Narre Warren War Memorial,  are the first cousins of Dugald MacKenzie, listed above.

Report of Albert Stedman's death.

The Herald November 29, 1916 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article242453294

Thomson, William Henry.  William was born in Narre Warren on December 31, 1897. He enlisted in the Royal Australian Navy on June 1, 1912, when he was not yet 15. His enlistment form says he was 4 feet 9 inches at the time and 'On Advancement to Man's rating' he had grown to 5 feet 3½ inches. His next of kin on enlistment was his mother, Elizabeth, who lived at Mordialloc.  William served until May 21, 1919. 

Wanke, Arthur Robert (SN 1427) Arthur enlisted on March 3, 1916. He Returned to Australia on December 12, 1918.
Wanke, Frederick William (SN 6379) Frederick enlisted on April 28, 1916 and Died of Wounds received May 17, 1918.
The boys were the sons of Emmanuel and Bertha (nee Aurisch) Wanke of Narre Warren and they are both listed on the Narre Warren War Memorial. A report of  Fred's death and his photograph was  published in the  Dandenong Advertiser on July 4, 1918 -

Quite a gloom was cast over the district of Harkaway when the sad news recently came to hand, that Private Fred. Wanke had been killed in action "Somewhere in France," on 17th May. This young hero was born and educated at Harkaway, and took a keen interest in any movement that was likely to improve the district. He was a member of the Harkaway Young Men's Club, and was always a true sport. When in camp, while on many of the numerous expeditions with his mates, his motto was: "Age before honor," and he never could do too much for any of the older members of the party. "Fred" was of most genial and obliging disposition, and was 28 years of age. He left a good home and loving parents, to go forth and do his share with the boys in the trenches, where he made the extreme sacrifice. When on furlough he devoted his time to studying the different methods of farming, and was keen on acquiring a knowledge of new ideas. Much sympathy is expressed by his many friends throughout the district, for Mr and Mrs Wanke and family, of "Hillcroft" who have lost a noble son, and brother. Private Arthur Wanke a brother of this fallen soldier, and who was also a member of the Harkaway Young Men's Club, is on active service in France. (9) 

Wauchope, Neil Andrew (SN 2239)  Neil is listed on the Narre Warren War Memorial. Neil was born at Narre Warren and he enlisted on July 9, 1915. He was 26 years old and a butter maker. He Returned to Australia on August 24, 1918 and discharged on medical grounds due to cardiac insufficiency. Neil was the son of William and Maggie Jane (nee Brunt) Wauchope. 

Webb, Frederick John (SN 28407) Frederick was 19 years old when he enlisted on May 29, 1916. He was a 'striker for blacksmith'. Frederick died of cerebro spinal meningitis in England on January 30, 1917. He was born in Narre Warren, the son of Frederick John and Amelia Webb, who were living in Richmond at the time of Fred's enlistment. Amelia's maiden name was also Webb. As you can see by the death notice, below, he was the brother of Alice, Leo, Doris, Sylvia, Stanley and 'little Reggie'. Reggie was Killed in Action in New Guinea on July 31, 1943, another tragic death for the family. I feel this family must somehow be connected to Sidney Webb, of  Narre Warren, the namesake of Webb Street, Narre Warren, but I am not sure how.

Loving tribute to Frederick from his sister, Alice.

The Age February 17, 1917 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article155187526

Whinfield, David Horace (SN 2776).  David was a 27 year old teacher at Narre Warren East State School, when he enlisted on August 7, 1916. He was born in Macorna and his next of kin was his father, Stephen, of Macorna. David was awarded the Military Medal and he Returned to Australia November 15, 1919.

Report of David Whinfield's Military Medal

South Bourke & Mornington Journal November 14, 1918 https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/66195050

Woodley, Ernest Simmell. Ernest enlisted on August 16, 1915. He was born in Narre Warren and was a 25 year old clerk. Ernest was discharged due to being medically unfit on May 29, 1916 as he suffered from 'traumatic epilspsy'. 
Woodley, George Herbert (SN 4570) George, a brother of Ernest, is listed on the Narre Warren War Memorial.  George enlisted on August 18, 1915. He was a 32 year old salesman and his next of kin was his wife, Maggie, whose address was Powlett Street, East Melbourne. On July 3, 1919 George requested that he be discharged in London, rather than having to return to Australia, as he had a position waiting for me in Calcutta and my presence is necessary there in August.  His request was granted.  

George and Ernest were the sons of Thomas and Hannah (nee Buckley) Woodley. Thomas operated a baker's shop on the corner of the Princes Highway and Webb Street.  Thomas had died on New Year's Day, 1906, he had gone to Melbourne to watch an interstate cricket match and partook of a meat pie after leaving the cricket ground, and that the pie caused ptomaine poisoning, which, with a subsequent sharp attack of peritonitis, was the cause of death (10)

Young, Walter Leslie (SN 632)  A Walter Young was farewelled at a social and dance in April 1916 along with Alfred Brown and Herbert Battersby. There is an Walter Leslie Young listed in the 1914 Electoral Rolls at Narre Warren North, his occupation is a merchant. I believe this is Walter Young who enlisted on February 9, 1916 at the age of 24. His occupation was a grocer. Walter was born in Diamond Creek and his next of kin was his mother, Mary, of Diamond Creek. Walter Returned to Australia May 27, 1919. 

This picture was taken in March 1993, just after the Narre Warren War Memorial was moved to the Civic Centre site. That's long serving Council Officer, David Westlake with a colleague.

Image: Casey Cardinia Libraries

Sources
Early days of Berwick and its surrounding districts (Berwick & District Agricultural and Horticultural Society, 3rd edition, 1979)
Early Settlers of the Casey-Cardinia District compiled by the Narre Warren and District Family History Group (2010)
In the wake of the Pack tracks: a history of the Shire of Berwick (Berwick Pakenham Historical Society, 1982)
Little Hills 1839-1977 by Max Thomson (Narre Warren North State School No.1901 Centenary committee, 1977)
Rigg of the railways: stationmasters of the Victorian railways by Tom Rigg (2001)

Footnotes
(1) http://www.caseycardiniaremembers.org.au/narre-warren-memorial-gates/
(2) http://www.caseycardiniaremembers.org.au/narre-warren-north-war-memorial/

(3) Vision and Realisation: a centenary history of State Education in Victoria edited by Les Blake (Education Department of Victoria, 1973); report of the opening of the Hall Dandenong Journal, November 29, 1928, see here.
(4) A short report of the unveiling can be found in the Box Hill Reporter, March 17, 1922, see here. You can read Colonel Knox's Australian Dictionary of Biography entry here. The City of Knox is named after him. 
(5)  Oak Trees and Hedges: a pictorial history of Narre Warren, Narre Warren North and Harkaway (Berwick Pakenham Historical Society, 2002)
(6) Narre Warren North War Memorial Unveiling - The Argus March 17, 1922, see here; Avenue of Honour - South Bourke & Mornington Journal, September 25, 1919, see here.

(7) Alexander McClure - Berwick Shire News,  May 17 1916, see here.  

(8) Sherriff - Arthur Mason Sherriff is the son of Alexander and Margaret (nee Gaskell) Sherriff. Mary Alice Sherriff is the daughter of Alfred and Maria (nee Auchetto) Sherriff. Alexander and Alfred are the sons of Alexander and Christina (nee Mason) Sherriff. Mary's sister Hilda, like Arthur, has Mason as her second name. 

(8) Frederick Wanke -Dandenong Advertiser, July 4, 1918, see here

(9) Mr Woodley - South Bourke & Mornington Journal,  January 3, 1906, see here.

Some of this information, which I wrote and researched, has appeared in posts in my work blog, Casey Cardinia Commemorates: Our War Years.