Showing posts with label Churches. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Churches. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 15, 2025

Catholic Churches in the old Shire of Berwick and Shire of Cranbourne

The Catholic newspaper, The Advocate, is available on Trove from 1868 until 1954-
The Advocate was first published on 1st February 1868 by Samuel Vincent Winter and his brother, Joseph. Its goal was to “fairly and intelligently represent the Catholic and Irish section of the community, and, while defending their legitimate interests, would aim at promoting the prosperity of the colony, and cultivating a friendly feeling among all classes of the community.” In 1902, The Advocate imported a font of Irish type and became the first newspaper in Australia to be able to print the Gaelic language. In 1919, the ownership and management of The Advocate passed to the Catholic Archdiocese of Melbourne until it ceased publication in 1990. From 1868 -1990, The Advocate remained a “reliable record of Catholic life.” (1) 

In this post we will look at the type of local historical information we can find in The Advocate, concentrating on reports of the opening of Catholic Churches in the old Shire of Berwick and Shire of Cranbourne; but before we do here is a short overview of the Parish structure in the area. 

As early as the 1840s Priests from Melbourne used to visit the area - Pakenham, Nar Nar Goon and the Western Port region. In 1853 the Brighton Mission was established, a very large area that covered the south east part of Melbourne, the Mornington Peninsula, Bass Coast and West Gippsland. In April 1883 the Dandenong Parish or Mission was established which covered nearly all of the Shire of Berwick and Shire of Cranbourne (the Casey Cardinia region), plus Dandenong, Phillip Island, down to Wonthaggi and the Mornington Peninsula. This Parish was eventually split up with the Iona Parish being created in 1905, Koo Wee Rup in 1946, St Mary's North Tynong (or Maryknoll) in 1950 (combined with Iona in 1968), Pakenham in 1954, Berwick (including Cranbourne) in 1956, Doveton in 1962, Cranbourne in 1973, Endeavour Hills in 1980 and Narre Warren in 1982. This information and some of the information in the rest of this post comes from A Parish carved from the bush: the centenary history of the Dandenong Parish, 1883-1983 (2)

St Agatha's Church,  Cranbourne
Back to The Advocate - the first Catholic Church in the area was St Agatha's at Cranbourne which was opened on February 6, 1861, by Archbishop Goold (3);  so a bit too early to be reported in The Advocate. However, the second St Agatha's which was opened on January 20, 1929 had a full page report, which you can read here. This church was opened by Archbishop Mannix; it was designed by Architect, Mr P.J. O'Connor and the contractor was Mr Taylor. The church cost £3131/5/.

The current St Agatha's was built in 1981. This Church was partially funded by a generous bequeath of $492,000 from Mr Eddie Donnelly who passed away in 1979. You can read more of the history on their website http://www.stagathas.org.au/



The opening of St Agatha's Church at Cranbourne in 1929 with the original 1861
weatherboard Church next to it.


The opening of St Agatha's in Cranbourne in 1929
The Advocate, January 24, 1929 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article171655207


St Patrick's Church, Pakenham
The next church to open was St Patrick's in Pakenham which opened in 1871. The existing Church was built in 1976. The original Church is still standing and is now part of the St Patrick's School. The Advocate published this report on construction of this Church - 
New Church, Pakenham - On the Gippsland road, about 35 miles from Melbourne, in the wilds, we may say, of the Australian bush, a beautiful little church is being built. It is so situated, and both in material and design is so pleasing, that more eloquently and impressively than all the churches in this crowded city it will bear testimony to the Christian character of the people of Victoria. On the Feast of SS. Peter and Paul the Rev. J. P. O'Sullivan turned the first sod for the foundation in the presence of several members of the Catholic congregation in the district. Since that time the building operations have been rapidly progressing. (4)  
 
I can't actually find an opening date for the Church, but A Parish Carved from the Bush notes that the first wedding which took place was on October 2, 1872, between Johanna O'Brien and  Phillip Boland. (5)


Marriage of Johann O'Brien to Matthew Boland, at 
The Australasian, November 2, 1872 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article137575458




An early photo of St Patrick's at Pakenham.
Source: North of the Line: a pictorial record published by the Berwick Pakenham Historical Society in 1996.


St Michael's Church, Berwick
The first Berwick Catholic Church was officially opened by Archbishop Goold on March 31, 1878. It was originally known as St Joseph's, but later changed to St Michael's. The name change seemed to gave occurred around 1910 - I found references to St Michael's in 1910, even though St Joseph's was still be used as late as 1914, presumably by long-term parishioners. (6)

The Advocate had a report of the opening - 
Church of St Joseph, Berwick - This handsome and commodious edifice was solemnly opened and consecrated to divine worship on Sunday, 31st March, by his Grace the Most Rev. Dr. Goold, Archbishop of Melbourne. The Archbishop was assisted by Rev. M. Carey, pastor of the district, and Rev. W. Kelly, S.J., who preached a very eloquent and impressive sermon on the occasion. He took his text from Galatians iv., and read in the Mass of the Sunday, " we are children of promise." The rev. preacher dwelt on the promises of God, through Christ, pointing out that the material temple in which they were assembled was the memorial and manifestation of men's best and highest hopes, and that it was by turning to good account the grace that would be so largely conferred within these walls that  our hopes of pardon, perseverance, and final bliss were to be realised. After the sermon his Grace addressed the congregation, urging in highly and well chosen words, the importance of complying with the paschal obligations of confession and communion. The attendance was very numerous, considering the very extreme inclemency of the weather, and must be regarded as highly creditable to the zeal and earnestness of the Roman Catholic, pastor and people of Berwick. (7)  


The original wooden Church at Berwick
Image: Church on the hill: a history of St Michael’s Parish Berwick by Maree Chapman (St Michael’s Catholic Parish, 1996)

The second Church at Berwick was opened on January 24, 1937 by Archbishop Mannix. The Advocate had full report, including photographs, which you can read here. The old wooden church was removed having been sold to Dan Cunningham of Nar Nar Goon, but burnt down before he could use it (8) The current St Michael's Church was opened in 1984.


St Michael's Berwick
The Advocate, January 28, 1937,  http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article171926375



Archbishop Mannix at the opening of St Michael's in Berwick in 1937.
The Advocate January 28, 1937  http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article171926375


St Joseph's Church, Iona
St Joseph's at Iona was the next Church to be opened, which took place on December 16, 1900. Iona was known as Bunyip South until 1905. The Advocate reported - 
The Dandenong Mission - Last Sunday a new church was opened at Bunyip South by the Very Rev. M. J. Maher, C.M. (Malvern), who also delivered the dedicatory discourse, his theme being the excellence of the August Sacrifice of the Mass. The custom of offering sacrifice to a Supreme Being was traced from the earliest history of the world down to our own day. Fr. Maher was assisted in the function by the pastor of the Dandenong mission, in which the new church is situated (Rev. J. Gleeson). The building is of wood, and is considered very good value for the sum of £250, the contract price. The preacher concluded with an appeal on behalf of the debt on the new structure, and a generous response was made, the sum £48 being received. (9)  


St Joseph's Church, Iona, 1922
The Advocate November 16, 1922 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-page20363246

The current St Joseph's Church was opened on April 14, 1940. The comprehensive report in The Advocate started with - 
A new church was blessed and opened at Iona on Sunday afternoon by his Grace the Archbishop, who was accompanied from Melbourne by Right Rev. Dr. P. F. Lyons, V.G., Adm. Built of multi-red brick, with a tower rising to a height of 60 feet, and with seating accommodation for 450 people, the new church is one of the best country churches in the Archdiocese. It has been well furnished and the High Altar, altar rails and pulpit are of Mt. Sommers (New Zealand) stone. The site is most central, but, because of the treacherous state of the ground, the foundations were specially strengthened. The cost of erecting the church was £5300, and it was designed by Mr. W. P. Conolly and built by Mr. Donald McLennan. Messrs. Lodge Bros, executed the stonework.  (10)   

St John the Baptist Church, Koo Wee Rup
The first decade of the twentieth century continued to be a busy time for the Dandenong Mission with three other Churches  established. Two years after Iona, another Church, St John the Baptist, was opened on the Koo Wee Rup Swamp, at Koo Wee Rup, on August 24, 1902. The Advocate reported -
A new Catholic Church was solemnly opened and blessed at Koo-wee-rup, in the Dandenong Mission, on Sunday last, 4th August. Notwithstanding the inclemency of the weather, a large congregation had assembled to witness the opening ceremony, the entire seating space being taken up. After the blessing of the new church, Mass was celebrated by Rev. Fr. J. Hagarty, C.M., of Malvern, who also preached the sermon, after which a collection was taken up, which realised upwards of £50, including a donation of £25 received from His Grace the Archbishop. The pastor (Rev. J. Gleeson) assisted in the function.  (11)  

The current Church, built in Modernist Design, was opened on December 23, 1962, by the Bishop of Sale, the Most Reverend P.F. Lyons.


St John the Baptist Church, Koo Wee Rup, 1930s.
Image: Koo Wee Rup Swamp Historical Society


St James' Church, Nar Nar Goon Catholic Church opened on May 29, 1904 -
A new church recently built at Nar-Nar-Goon at a cost of between £300 and £400, on land given by
Mr. James Kelly, of Nar-Nar-Goon, was formally opened on Sunday by the Very Rev. J. T. Colgan, S.J. The choir from Pakenham assisted. There was a large congregation.
(12)  
The current St James' building was opened on March 13, 1971. 

St Mary's Church, Lang Lang
On September 14, 1908 the Lang Lang Church was opened, it is called St Marys. The Advocate reported - 
The Vicar-General's Visit to Lang Lang - New Church opened and Blessed - Last Sunday the Very Rev. Dean Phelan, V.G., visited Lang Lang (Iona Mission) for the purpose of solemnly blessing and opening a new church. It being the feast of the Holy Name of Mary, the church was placed under the invocation of Our Blessed Lady under that title. There was a large congregation people attending from all parts of the mission, and not a few of our separated brethren were present.

After the ceremony of blessing the church, in which the Dean was assisted by the respected pastor (Rev. James Byrne), and previous to delivering the occasional sermon, he congratulated Fr. Byrne and the parishioners on the wonderful progress made during the few years he had been in charge of the district. Four churches had been erected in the parish, and a fine presbytery and Catholic Hall at Iona. Over £2000 had been paid off during the past four years, leaving but a small debt on the parish. Considering the growing needs of the place, the Dean told the congregation that at Fr. Byrne's request he would send him an assistant priest within the next couple of months. In future, the Vicar-General said, you will have Mass every Sunday at a fixed hour in each of the four churches. This announcement gave pleasure to the people of the Lang district, who, in the past, had Mass only on week-day.

The Dean preached on the necessity of a church as a home for the Blessed Eucharist, and touched on the Sacrifice of the mass and the Doctrine of the Real Presence as a reason why Catholics erected churches. The collection made after Mass was a very generous one, and realised over £150. There remains, in consequence, a debt on the building of only £120. Amongst the larger donations received were:—Dean Phelan, V.G., and Fr. Byrne, £10 each; Messrs. P. Kennedy, £15; J. O'Connor, £11; P. Doyle, £8 8s.; J. Glasheen, T. Lonergan, and M. Coghlan, £6 each; R. Gray, £5 5s. Fr. Byrne, in announcing the result of the collection, thanked the Dean for his presence and generosity, the people for their earnestness in building the church, and the many non-Catholics who were present and contributed generously to the building fund. (13)   
The Church is still in operation.

St Peter's Church, Tooradin
The  Tooradin Catholic Church  opened on December 3, 1922 and, as befits a fishing village, it was named St Peters, after the Patron Saint of Fishermen. The Advocate published this report -
St Peter's - of Tooradin. New Church for Fishing Village. Opened and Blessed Last Sunday.
A fine spirit exists amongst the handful of Catholics in the fishing village of Tooradin, one of the outer parts of the Dandenong parish, and this has found expression in the erection of a large wooden church in the district. Situated on Westernport Bay, about 36 miles from Melbourne, Tooradin is a long way removed from Dandenong, the centre of a very extensive parish. In such a scattered place, where the Catholics are few and far between, the visits of a priest from Dandenong are not very frequent and Mass has only been celebrated at irregular intervals. Despite these drawbacks, the district Catholics pressed their claim for the building of a church,, and expressed their readiness to shoulder the responsibilty. The Rev. F. A. Merner, P.P., knew the genuine spirit that prompted the people to ask for a church, and now their wish has been acceded to. 

The new church, which is dedicated to St. Peter, is practically completed, and it is a credit to the district. Designed by Mr. Fritsch; it has been built by Messrs. Claude and Len McCarthy, whose work is most thorough. The site is an admirable one, and commands a good view of a wide expanse of country. With many natural advantages, and enjoying a well-earned reputation as an established fishing ground, Tooradin is bound to progress in the near future. With the development of the place, it will become more and more apparent what a wise step has been taken in erecting the church. Future requirements, in a spiritual sense, have indeed been well provided for. 

The new church was blessed and opened on Sunday afternoon by his Grace the Archbishop of Melbourne (the Most Rev. Dr. Mannix). Sultry, conditions in the early part of the morning gave way to a cool change later, and in the latter part of the afternoon light rain fell. There was a fine gathering at the function, many having come from Melbourne, lona, Koo-wee-rup, Pakenham, Lang Lang, Dandenong, and other parts. Irish and Australian flags were placed at the entrance to the church grounds, which will be planted with buffalo grass, later. When his Grace, who motored from Melbourne arrived with Fr. Merner, he was greeted with rousing cheers by the men of the district, who formed a guard, of honour in and about the church grounds. His Grace's visit was regarded as a most important event in the district, and it was quite a sight to see the large collection of motors and vehicles drawn up in the grounds.

After the blessing ceremony speeches were delivered in the church building. It was intended to have an outdoor demonstration, but the showery conditions necessitated the change of plans. In addition to his Grace, there were present the Rev. F. A. Merner, P.P.; Rev. J.Carroll, Rev. W. M. Collins, D.D., and Rev. L. Hartnett. The proceedings were of an enthusiastic character, and his Grace's address was followed with close Interest. (14)  

The Church was closed and the building was moved to St Peter's College in Cranbourne in 2003 where it is used as a Chapel.  


St Peter's Tooradin in 1923


Sacred Heart Church, Gembrook
A few weeks later, on December 31, 1922 Scared Heart Catholic Church at Gembrook was blessed and opened by Archbishop Mannix - and dedicated to the Sacred Heart of Jesus according to the beautiful and inspiring formulary prescribed by the Roman Ritual.

The Advocate report commences with -
New Church at Gembrook. Blessed and Opened by the Archbishop. On Sunday 31st December, within the Octave of the Nativity of Our Lord, his Grace the Archbishop of Melbourne (the Most Rev. Dr. Mannix,) who motored from Melbourne accompanied by the Very Rev. Dean Carey. P.P., visited Gembrook for the purpose of the solemn blessing and opening of the new Church at Gembrook. There was a very large assemblage, many coming from Pakenham, Nar Nar Goon, and every part of the parish, not a few journeying from the metropolis.

As explained by Father Little, the Church was originally to have been opened in July  - 
Fr. Little, who was cordially received, said that a well-known expression rose to his mind on that occasion, "All things come to those that wait." The blessing and opening of the church was originally intended for July; adverse weather caused the function to be postponed till 15th October, and the same reason was responsible for a third postponement to that day. There had been, of course, much disappointment. However God had blessed them and gave a beautiful day for the function. (15) 

This Church was described as - The new church, of timber construction, is pleasing in appearance, and was built by contract for £825, according to the design Mr G. Vanheems (16).  

Gembrook was in the Fern Tree Gully Parish and the Church is still in operation, read more about it here - https://pol.org.au/Portals/30/ParishData/Id39/Uploads/Type3/Gembrook.pdf


Sacred Heart, Gembrook, 1922
The Advocate, October 5, 1922  http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article176522966


Holy Family Church, Maryknoll
On September 3, 1950 at St Mary's Rural Settlement at North Tynong (as Maryknoll was originally known) the Holy Family Church was blessed and  opened by Archbishop Mannix.  The original Church was designed by Smith and Tracey, architects, Sydney-road, Brunswick. 

The comprehensive Advocate report began - 
The widespread interest in St. Mary's community settlement, Tynong North, was shown last Sunday, when more than 3000 people attended the blessing and opening by Archbishop Mannix of a church-school and presbytery for Rev. Father Pooley and his pioneer co-operators at St. Mary's. Visitors came in hundreds of private cars and some fifty parlour coaches and vans from Melbourne and its suburbs, from nearby country centres and from towns as far apart as Geelong and Sale. So large was the concentration of cars on Tynong North that a special mobile police squad directed the traffic......A large tract of bush land at Tynong North is being converted into a Catholic rural settlement for 150 families. Fine work has already been done in clearing the land and home building is now in progress. Each family will have a holding of two or three acres to grow its own vegetables and fruit and keep poultry. There will be a community dairy farm and craft shops and later, it is hoped, a fruit cannery (17)

The Church was enlarged at a later date. I have written  more about the history of the settlement here


Caption: This is Holy Family Church-School, opened by Archbishop Mannix of 
St. Marys Rural Settlement, Tynong North, on September 3. The building was erected from a design by Smith and Tracey, architects, Sydney-road, Brunswick, who also prepared the large-scale map of the settlement which appeared last week. The erection of the first seven permanent homes is now being undertaken and these will be occupied by settlers, at present housed in temporary quarters in the vicinity.
 The Advocate, September 14 1950 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article172514072


Other Catholic Churches in the area
There are other Catholic Churches in this region which were opened after 1954 - The Holy Family Church at Doveton was opened in 1960. On October 21, 1962 St Kevin's at Hampton Park was opened - this was in a building that had been transported to the site - the old St Leonard's Church from Glen Waverley.  They appear to have  a newer building now, but I don't have any details on it. Our Lady Help of Christians Catholic Church at Narre Warren was opened in February 1980; and the St Paul Apostle Catholic Church at Endeavour Hills was opened on August 14, 1983. (18)


St Kevin's, Hampton Park
Image: A Parish carved from the bush: the centenary history of the Dandenong Parish (St Marys) 1883-1993, 
compiled by Greg Dickson (St Marys Centenary Committee, 1983)



Sources -
  • 100 years of a faith community: St Joseph’s Iona 1905-2005 by Damian Smith (St Joseph’s Catholic Church, 2005)
  • A Parish carved from the bush: the centenary history of the Dandenong Parish (St Marys) 1883-1993, compiled by Greg Dickson (St Marys Centenary Committee, 1983). Also covers the Catholic Parishes of Iona, Koo Wee Rup, Pakenham, Berwick, Cranbourne and Narre Warren.
  • Church on the hill: a history of St Michael’s Parish Berwick by Maree Chapman (St Michael’s Catholic Parish, 1996)
  • Parish of St John the Baptist Catholic Church: 50th anniversary as a Parish 1946-1996 (St John’s Catholic Church, 1996)
  • St Agatha’s Parish Cranbourne Silver Jubilee 1973-1998 (St Agatha’s Catholic Parish, 1998)
  • St Patrick’s Pakenham, 1840 - 2016 by Patrick Ferry (St Patrick’s Parish, 2016)

Footnotes
(2) A Parish carved from the bush: the centenary history of the Dandenong Parish, 1883-1983, compiled by Greg Dickson and  published by the St Mary's Centennial Committee, 1983.
(3) A Parish carved from the bush, p. 16.
(4) The Advocate, July 29, 1871, see here.
(5) I have written about the O'Brien family in an article about the Nar Nar Goon Hall, here https://kooweerupswamphistory.blogspot.com/2022/05/mechanics-institute-soldiers-memorial.html
(6) Yarragon Settlement News, July 21, 1910, see hereThe Argus, July 7, 1914, see here.
(7) The Advocate, April 6, 1878, see here.
(8) Chapman, Marie Church on the hill: a history of St Michael’s Parish Berwick by Maree Chapman (St Michael’s Catholic Parish, 1996)
(9) The Advocate, December 22, 1900, see here.
(10) The Advocate, April 18, 1940, see here
(11) The Advocate, August 30, 1902, see here.
(12) The Advocate, June 4, 1904, see here.
(13) The Advocate, September 19, 1908, see here.
(14) The Advocate, December 7, 1922, see here, report continues here and here.
(15) The Advocate, January 4, 1923, see here.
(16) The Advocate, June 29, 1922, see here.
(17) The Advocate, September 7, 1950, see here.
(18) Opening dates - A Parish carved from the bush; Hampton Park - The Age, March 23, 1962, p. 11; The Age, October 19, 1962, p. 17; 

The opening of St Kevin's, Hampton park
The Age, October 19, 1962, p. 17 from newspapers.com

Narre Warren - not sure where this date came from;  Endeavour Hills - https://www.melbcatholic.org/s/articles/a198w00000000tfAAA/parish-history




A shorter version of this post, which I wrote and researched, appears on my work blog, Casey Cardinia Links to Our Past

Friday, April 21, 2023

Church of Christ, Scientist churches in St Kilda Road, Camberwell and Elsternwick

I was driving around Elsternwick recently with a friend, and we went down Gordon Street (which as I found out runs at the back of Ripponlea mansion) and across the way, saw an interesting looking building with an unusual tower. When I got home, I typed 'Elsternwick Church' into the State Library of Victoria website to try to identify it, and this photo of the building came up. The building was the Third Church of Christ Scientist, Melbourne and it is in Ripon Grove. The name comes from the fact that this was the third Christian Science Congregation in Melbourne. This post looks at the first three Christian Science Church buildings in Melbourne (1).


Third Church of Christ, Scientist, Melbourne in Elsternwick.
Commercial Photographic Company photographer.
Harold Paynting Collection, State Library of Victoria Image H2009.177/18

In 1922, The Herald published a short history of the denomination in Melbourne - 
The first record of Christian Science in Melbourne is the following advertisement which appeared in the local papers of June 4, 1898:- "Christian Science (as taught by Mrs Eddy) Meeting, Sunday afternoon, June 5, at three o'clock, Victoria Buildings, 80 Swanston street." A few persons attended the meeting, and this was the beginning of Christian Science in this State. After holding several meetings in Victoria Buildings, the small band moved to Oxford Chambers, Bourke street, where the first regular Sunday service was held July 20, 1898. The society thus formed eventually disbanded, and on February 28, 1903, thirteen members of the Mother Church met at Oxford Chambers and organised the First Church of Christ, Scientist, in Melbourne. (2).


First Church of Christ, Scientist, in St Kilda Road, Melbourne, c. 1920s.
Photographer: Ruth Hollick.
State Library of Victoria Image H93.500/10

The First Church of Christ, Scientist congregation held services at the Athenaeum Hall in Collins Street, until their new Church was built on St Kilda Road, on the corner of Dorcas Street (3). The Argus reported on this new building which was officially opened May 7, 1922 -  
The design was prepared by Messrs. Bates, Peebles, and Smart, and the contract price was £25,000 to which must be added £5,000 for the land. The treatment is in  the free classic style, with the classic feeling specially emphasised by a columned portico of the Ionic order. To relieve severity of line, the large semi-circular windows have curved pediments. An additional relief is afforded by a dome roofed with copper plating specially treated so as to give it a metallic green surface. The building is in two storeys, the upper being used for the church services. Here then will be accommodation for 600 persons. The lower story, which it slightly smaller, will serve as a Sunday school.... An unusual feature for a church is the lift. This, it is explained, is provided for the benefit of those infirm members of the communium [sic] who attend the faith healing services. (4).

On October 11, 1925, the Dedication services of this Church were conducted as Christian Science churches are not dedicated until the churches are free from debt. (5)The Church was extended in 1934, with the work complete in the March, and The Argus had this report -
Although not included in the original design of the church, the additional block has been designed in the same free classical style as the main building and the Sunday school block. Complete conformity of style between the main building and the new block has been the object of the architects, Messrs. Bates, Smart, and McCutcheon, who designed the original building in 1920 (6).  The building is still in use by the Christian Scientists. 


First Church of Christ, Scientist, in St Kilda Road, Melbourne, 1970.
Photographer: Mark Strizic
State Library of Victoria Image H2011.55/1433

The Second Church of  Christ, Scientist in Melbourne was established by only 19 members in the middle of 1924, to relieve the overflowing congregations of First Church, Melbourne. (7)The congregation held services at the Masonic Hall in Launder Street, in Hawthorn and later erected  a substantial church in Cookson Street, Camberwell, which was opened November 22, 1936. This building was designed by the firm of Bates, Smart and McCutcheon. The building won the firm the Street Architecture Medal for 1938. The award, presented by the Royal Victorian Institute of Architects, was to encourage excellence of design in street architecture. (8).
The Age reported -
In recommending the award of the medal the jury reported that the building illustrates the architectural dignity which may be achieved with simplicity of massing, well proportioned voids and the judicious placing of appropriate enrichment. Elimination rather than decoration tends to characterise accepted standards of good architecture to-day, and this building reveals a particularly happy balance between these two considerations. It represents a satisfactory solution to the architectural problem of a modern church without resort to traditional ecclesiastical motifs. The chief interest in the front elevation centres in three large vertical openings which feature glazed decorative wrought iron screens, superbly designed and executed. Unity of design has been produced with cream toned bricks used throughout the exterior, even to the cornices and ornamental features over the doorways, the large plain surfaces being relieved with horizontal, recessed bands at regular intervals. (9).


Second Church of  Christ, Scientist, at Camberwell. 
Image: Building : the magazine for the architect, builder, property owner and merchant.
Vol. 60 No. 355 (12 March, 1937) From Trove. 

The Church could seat 450 people and included features such as double glazing, theatre-style seating, automatically controlled heating and ventilation and a lift. On September 2, 1945 the Dedication services were held as the Church, erected at a cost of more than £16,000, was debt free (10).   The building is still in use by the Christian Scientists. 

This brings us to the Third Church of Christ, Scientist, at 12 Ripon Grove,  Elsternwick. This church
was formed on account of the crowding, for the second time, of  First Church of Christ, Scientist, Melbourne (corner St. Kilda Road and Dorcas Street). To relieve the congestion somewhat, 30 members of that church living southwards from Balaclava withdrew and organised Third Church, and began holding their services in the Masonic Hall, St. George's Road, Elsternwick, in February, 1927 (11).

In  August 1928, they purchased land in Ripon Grove and by February 1929 the congregation had paid off the debt; the building of the grand Romanesque-style edifice commenced in August 1930 and it was officially opened on June 28, 1931.  The Church and furnishings were designed by architect, Louis R. Williams of Little Collins Street and the completed cost was £12,000. (12).  Louis Williams was a noted Church Architect - other examples of his work are Anglican Churches in Flemington (1925), Albert Park (1925);  Frankston (1933), Alexandra (1937), Harrietville (1938), Caulfield (1939), Mansfield (1940) and Box Hill (1952) and Presbyterian Churches at Murrumbeena (1933) and Ormond (1937). Louis Reginald Williams died March 1980, aged 89 (13). 

The Herald described the Third Church of Christ, Scientist at Elsternwick thusly - 
In tone, the whole of the church is mellow, the walls being of clinker brick, with roofing tiles of chocolate to harmonise. Violent contrast in colors has been avoided. The outline of the main front, facing Rippon [sic] Grove, although not symmetrical, yet presents a sympathetic building up in
varying heights leading up to and culminating in the corner tower, a distinguishing feature from many viewpoints. In plan the edifice is two storied, the church being built over the Sunday school. The ground floor foyer, paved with carefully selected tones of Terazzo, leads to a double flight of concrete stairs taking one to the upper foyer and so to the church auditorium. The nave of the church will accommodate about 450 persons.

The whole of the walling is panelled, the design being arranged so as to link up with and form part of the seating construction. The roof is of the open timbered variety, heavy semi-circular trusses sweeping overhead from floor to roof: these, together with the large arches of the transept and crossing, create an impressive interior, severe and dignified. Pressed cement tracery windows give due accentuation to the church. Leaded glass of interesting formation is provided, while the mellow toned glass diffuses a soft light over the whole, harmonising with the softly textured plaster of the walls. The accommodation of this upper floor also provides for a board room, committee room, clerk's room, ushers' room, and rooms for the readers, organist and soloist, and organ chamber and staircase hall leading to the gallery.

On the ground door, besides the Sunday school, which is equal in size to that of the church, there are provided three committee rooms, cloak room, reading room and retiring rooms. Provision has been made throughout the building for heating by electricity, and sound proofing. (14).

On April 15, 1945 the Dedication services were held at the Elsternwick Church, as it was debt free. (15).


Third Church of Christ, Scientist, Melbourne in Elsternwick.
Image: Third Church of Christ, Scientist as published in  From sand, swamp and heath...a history of Caulfield (16). 

The building is no longer used by the Christian Scientists. I don't have an exact date as to when they ceased using the building, but as the advertisement below shows, they were still active in November 1986, as a free lecture was held in the building, but after that I cannot find any advertised Christian Science activities held in Ripon Grove. By July 1988 the building was occupied by the Australian College of Metaphysical Studies. 


Christian Science lecture held at Third Church of Christ, Scientist, in November 1986
The Age November 6, 1986. p. 52, from newspapers.ocm


July 1988 - Third Church of Christ, Scientist, now occupied by 
Australian College of Metaphysical Studies
The Age, July 9, 1988 p. 160, from newspapers.com

I love Church architecture and I have an interest in the social history of churches and the much larger role Churches used to play in the social life (as well as the Spiritual life) of the community, so this has been an fascinating piece of research for me. The other thing to note is just how much Church news appeared in the newspapers in the past -  reports of sermons, photographs and information on new Church buildings; information about the Ministers  and Priests; service times - it was all reported. 

Trove list - I have created a list of articles on Trove connected to the building of the first three Church of Christ, Scientist churches in Melbourne,  access it here

Footnotes
(1) For more on Christian Science https://christiansciencevictoria.com.au/
(2) The Herald, May 6, 1922, see here.
(3) Ibid
(4) The Argus, May 4, 1922, see here.
(5) The Argus, October 14, 1925, see here.
(6) The Argus, March 15, 1934, see here.
(7) The Age, September 4, 1945, see here.
(8) Box Hill Reporter, September 10, 1926, see here; The Age, November 21, 1936, see here; Street Medal criteria -  The Herald, January 18, 1928, see here
(9) The Age, March 25, 1939, see here.
(10) The Argus, October 23, 1936, see here; The Age, September 4, 1945, see here.
(11) The Herald, May 13, 1931, see here.
(12) The Herald, May 13, 1931, see here; The Argus, June 29, 1931, see heregrand romanesque quote from City of Glen Eira Thematic Environmental History (Refresh) 2020, p. 100.   https://www.gleneira.vic.gov.au/media/7583/glen-eira-c214glen-city-of-glen-eira-thematic-environmentla-history-refresh-2020.pdf  
(13) Various references on Trove; Louis Reginald Williams - Melbourne University - https://minerva-access.unimelb.edu.au/items/e97e135c-b251-50a1-a553-d4e8a18eaa4a/full 
(14) The Herald, May 13,  1931, see here.
(15) The Age, April 16, 1945, see here.
(16) Murray, John R and Wells, John C From sand, swamp and heath...a history of Caulfield (City of Caulfield, 1980), p. 222.

Thursday, June 2, 2022

Honour Board at St James the Great Anglican Church East St Kilda

The War World One Honour Board at St James the Great Anglican Church in Inkerman Street,  East St Kilda lists the names of parishioners as well as students from St John's Theological College who served. There are 79 men who are commemorated on the board, including the Reverend Garnet Shaw, the first vicar.

St John's Theological College opened in 1906 in  Alma Road, East St Kilda, on the site of the recently closed Cumloden Grammar School. The College closed in 1919. The Parish of St James the Great, East St Kilda was created in 1914 and services were initially held at the chapel at the Theological College, until a Sunday school and hall were built for the Church in Inkerman Road (1).


The foundation stone of St James the Great, East St Kilda
Image: Isaac Hermann

This original building has had a number of extensions and internal refurbishments and redecorations over the years.  In the 1960s during one of the building extensions a number of pillars from demolished Melbourne mansions and other buildings (2) were incorporated in the works. When Father Paul Bower gave us a tour of the building in May 2022, we found seven different sets of pillars in the building, 22 pillars in all. The building has changed substantially from when the men on this Honour Board would have worshipped there. 


Four historic pillars in the Lady Chapel at the Church.
Image: Isaac Hermann.


Another set of pillars at the High Altar.
Image: Isaac Hermann.

This post looks at the men on the Honour Board. I have included the Service Numbers (SN) of the men, so you can look up their files at the National Archives of Australia www.naa.gov.au. Extra information comes from the Australian War Memorial, articles and personal notices in newspapers, accessed on Trove;  the Indexes to the Victorian Births, Deaths and Marriages and the Electoral Rolls on Ancestry.com or as footnoted.


The Honour Board at St James the Great, East St Kilda.
Image: Heather Arnold


Allen, Arthur John Harward (SN 10382) Arthur was a 32 year old salesman when he enlisted on August 18, 1915 and his next of kin was his father, Arthur Harward Allen of 8 Chomley Street, East Prahran.  He was awarded the Meritorious Service Medal and was Mentioned in Despatches. Arthur Returned to Australia March 25, 1919.
Allen, Herbert Percy (SN 1966) Herbert was 31 years old, a cycle shopkeeper and he enlisted on August 14, 1915. His next of kin was his wife, Lily. Herbert Returned to Australia on September 5, 1919. Lily's address was also listed as 8 Chomley Street, East Prahran. 
Arthur and Herbert's father is listed in the Electoral Rolls as a Professor of Music.


Captain John Aram
Australian War Memorial Image P00249.002

Aram, John Thomas Hamilton (Lieutenant) John was commissioned as a  Lieutenant on March 29, 1915 and he was later promoted to Captain.  He was a accountant and his next of kin was his mother, Sarah Ann Ostberg of Glenfern, Inkerman Street, East St Kilda. John was Killed in Action, at the age of 30, on September 25, 1917 near Polygon Wood, France. 

Archard,  Lisle Urwin George (SN 2102) Lisle enlisted on July 12, 1915. He was a 23 year old clerk. His next of kin was his father, Thomas Archard, of 12 Shirley Grove, East St Kilda, and later of Quamby, Keeran Street, Caulfield. Lisle Returned to Australia January 18, 1919 and he married Ethel May Martin in 1920.

Ball, William John (SN 33222) William enlisted on October 10, 1916. He was 21 years old and his occupation was listed as Soldier/Bootmaker. William's next of kin was his father, Frederick, of Truro, 526 Inkerman Street, East St Kilda. William was granted leave from the Army in April 1919 to undertake farming training, after which he Returned to Australia September 7, 1919.

Barber, Alfred Thomas (SN Depot) Alfred enlisted on November 16, 1914. He was a 21 year old motor driver and his next of kin was his father, William Thomas Barber, of Main Street, Maldon. Alfred was discharged on medical grounds on April 2, 1915. He enlisted again on August 10, 1915 and was discharged again December 23, 1915 on medical grounds - regurgitation of mitral valve. On his second enlistment he said he was still 21 years, 9 months and a clerk. His next of kin listed was his mother, Mary Ellen barber, of 29 Leslie Street, East St Kilda.
Barber, William Owen (SN 540) William was a 19 year old labourer when he enlisted on November 16, 1914, the same day as his brother Alfred. He was Killed in Action at Mussalabeh, Palestine on July 19, 1918 and is buried at the Jerusalem War Cemetery. His father, William, see below, was listed as his next of kin and his address was 42 Chaucer Street, St Kilda.
Barber, William Thomas (SN 346) William served in the Royal Australian Naval Bridging Train (RANBT).  He enlisted May 29, 1915 and was demobilized two years later on May 29, 1917. William's next of kin was listed as his wife, Mary Ellen Barber, of 13 Nelson Street, Balaclava. He was 39 years old, a butcher and they had five children, including Alfred and young William. It appears that William and Mary Ellen may have separated after his return as young William's Roll of Honour circular at the Australian War Memorial was completed by his mother and there is no mention of his father (her address at the time was 38 Stuart Street, Malvern) and his death notice also does not mention the father.


William Owen Barber's death notice


Barr, W.A -  I cannot find a W.A Barr with a local connection, however this may be
Barr, William Ernest (SN  2487). William was a 22 year old engraver when he enlisted on August 3, 1915. His next of kin was his mother, Mary Barr, initially of Rathdowne Street, Carlton but she later changed her address to 5 Shirley Grove, East St Kilda, which is just a few metres from Alexandra Street and then two blocks to the church on the corner of Inkerman Road. William Returned to Australia on April 13, 1919 and married Maud Jeffries in 1920.

Bates, R - I cannot find a R. Bates with a local connection, however I believe this is
Bate, Richard William (SN 7445). Richard first enlisted at the age of 21 on March 5, 1915. He was a tram conductor and his next of kin was his father, Richard, of 36 Andrew Street, Windsor. Richard was discharged as medically unfit - Epilepsy - at the end of June 1915. He re-enlisted on July 2, 1917. He was then 24, his occupation was a motorman, and his next of kin was his wife, Florence, of 33 Duke Street, St Kilda. He embarked on August 4 on the Themistocles. There is a note in his Attestation papers from Major Ryan, who was on board the Themistocles saying Several men  are on board who are obviously unfit for service and should never have been passed, Richard being one of them. He Returned to Australia in December 1917 and was discharged again due to Epilepsy in March 1918.

Baxter, Frank (SN 4672) Frank enlisted on October 16, 1916, he was a 35 year old mechanic and his next of kin was his wife, Mary, of 123 Inkerman Street, St Kilda. Frank Returned to Australia June 19, 1919.

Beach, Victor Henry (SN 1655) Victor was an 18 year old marker gardener when he enlisted on February 7, 1916. His next of kin was his father, Henry, of 1 Malakoff Street, St Kilda. Victor Returned to Australia September 6, 1919. Victor married Dorothy Mary Taylor in 1920 and in the 1924 Electoral Roll they were listed at 13 Young Street, Malvern East and his occupation was a gardener.

Brewster, Arthur Clarence Lieutenant  Arthur enlisted July 15, 1915 at the age of 27, he was a farmer of Rupanyup. He was commissioned as a Lieutenant and was awarded the Military Cross. He was Killed in Action in Belgium on October 4, 1917. His next of kin was his father Frank of Shoobra Road, Elsternwick, later of 2 Lambert Grove East St Kilda and then of 45 Milburn Avenue, East St Kilda. Frank's occupation was listed in the Electoral roll as an Evangelist. After Arthur's death, his father received a letter from the Reverend Cleverdon, the padre of the Battalion - I am not saying too much when I tell you he was one of the most popular officers in the battalion, both with the officers and men. He made his name at Bullecourt, last May, and ever since the men have almost worshipped him. Another letter was received by Lieutenant Fethers of the same battalion - Brewster was a great favorite in the Battalion, and his men thought a lot of him. He would have received the military cross very shortly as his name had been sent in to receive it among the New Year honors. He should have got it for Bullecourt; he was recommended." (3). 


John Wallace Bull

Bull, John Wallace (SN 7122)  John was a 22 year old Theological student at St John's College when he enlisted on October 5, 1916. His next of kin was his father, John Bull of Williamstown. John was Killed in Action on September 20, 1917 in Belgium. John's Roll of Honour circular at the Australian War Memorial notes that he was originally employed with the Post Office and that later was assistant to Church of England clergymen at Aspendale and Chelsea. The Circular also lists people with whom reference could be made by the Historian for future information and his father has listed the Reverend Frank Travers, Curate, All Saints, East St Kilda - his companion who enlisted with him. 

Chapman, Thomas Arnold (SN 6390) Thomas enlisted at the age of 19 on April 11, 1916. He was a clerk and his next of kin was his father, Percy, of 22 Hotham Street, East St Kilda. Percy later changed his address to 6 Kalymna Grove in the same suburb, then to The Shack, Ontario Street Caulfield. Thomas Returned to Australia March 25, 1919. The family was still living at The Shack, when Thomas became engaged in 1924 to Rene Letcher.


Thomas Chapman's engagement notice.

Coulthard, Roland Claude (SN 782) Roland was a 22 year old carpenter when he enlisted on August 18, 1914. His next of kin was his father, Walter, of 29 Malakoff Street, East St Kilda. Roland Died of Wounds on May 11, 1915, received while fighting  at Gallipoli.


Report of Roland Coulthard's death


Cox, A. This could be either Alan Cox or Arthur Cox
Cox, Alan Clive (SN 6775a)  Alan was 21 student at St John's Theological College when he enlisted on July 13, 1917. His next of kin was his father, Alfred, of Woolloongabba near Brisbane.  Alan Returned to Australia November 22, 1919. I have no information if Alan completed his studies, but from the early 1930s, according to the Electoral rolls,  he was living in Five Dock, a suburb of Sydney, and his occupation was listed as a traveller (salesman).
Cox, Arthur John (SN 3038). Arthur enlisted on August 16, 1915. He was a 28 year old assistant surveyor and his next of kin was his mother, Ada Ellen Cox, of 140 Inkerman Street, East St Kilda.  Arthur Returned to Australia April 12, 1919. The notice, below, says Arthur's brother Oscar (SN 3807) was Killed in Action in October 1917, and as he is not listed on this Honour, I believe it makes it more likely that the entry refers to Alan, but I think everyone who served deserves a place on a Honour Board somewhere, so Arthur remains in this list. Arthur married Lydia Elizabeth Lee in 1920. 


Report of Arthur Cox being in hospital
 Prahran Telegraph, May 18, 1918 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article75257663


Crawford, Hiram Allen (SN 22060) I believe this is the correct H. A. Crawford, even though his religion is listed as Presbyterian. Hiram was a 19 year clerk when he enlisted on January 11, 1916.  He Returned to Australia June 4, 1919. His next of kin is listed as his father, Walter, of 36 Prentice Street, East St Kilda, but a note in his file says he has not lived with parents for 16 years and it was his guardian who gave permission for him to enlist as he was under 21. The Guardian's signature appears to be H.L. Crawford and the address is 14 Long Street, Elsternwick. Hiram married Alice Hazel Scott in 1920.

Hiram's marriage notice
The Argus, December 25, 1920 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article4563925

Dainty, Harry Robert (SN 106) Harry enlisted on May 1, 1915. He was 25 year old clerk and his father, Frederick, of the East St Kilda Police Station was his next of kin. Harry Returned to Australia May 3, 1919.  


Harry Dainty's father is promoted. As a matter of interest, two of Sergeant Kennedy's sons served in the War, they are listed on the Elwood Presbyterian Church Honour Board, see here.
Prahran Chronicle August 4, 1917 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article88461865


Dark, N. I cannot find a Dark or a Darke who enlisted who has a local connection.

Dossetor, E. The Honour Board has a E. Dossetor; the 1912 and 1913 list a Francis Ernest Dossetor at St John's College, who was apparently known as Ernest.  There are three men with the surname Dossetor/Dosseter who enlisted - Arthur, Howard and Leslie. Howard, Leslie and Ernest were brothers, born in Tasmania to Daniel Rumney and Louisa (nee Green) Dossetor;  Arthur was also born in Tasmania, the son of Daniel Vinson and Emily (nee Ikin) Dossetor (4). I finally tracked down Ernest's war service through Ancestry - The Reverend Francis Dossetor served as a Chaplain with the British Army in World War One. He remained in England after the War and died there in November 1950.

Fookes, E.T. There are no E.T. Fookes who enlisted that I can find, I believe this man is -
Fookes, Charles Thomas (SN 7971) Charles was a 35 year old 'chemist storeman' when he enlisted on September 11, 1915. His next of kin was his wife, Edith May of 20 Malakoff Street, East St Kilda. They had two sons, George and Charles. Charles was Killed in Action in Belgium on October 1, 1917. 


Report of Charles Fookes' death
Prahran Telegraph, December 8, 1917 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article74840498

Forbes, Alfred Ernest (SN 53) Alfred was a 19 year old grocer when he enlisted on January 29, 1916. His next of kin was his mother, Eliza, of 17 Prentice Street, East St Kilda and later of 17 Nelson Street, St Kilda.  Alfred Returned to Australia October 31, 1917 and was discharged on medical grounds - incapacitated due to shell shock. Alfred married Alice Maud Porter in 1918.


Mrs Forbes gives permission for 19 year old Alfred to enlist.
National Archives of Australia www.naa.gov.au
First Australian Imperial Force Personnel Dossiers, 1914-1920

Forsyth, Norman Albert (SN 4496) Norman enlisted on February 19, 1915 at the age of 27. He was a carpenter and his next of kin was his father, Robert, of 340 Inkerman Street, East St Kilda. Norman Returned to Australia January 21, 1916 and was discharged in the June on medical grounds - enteric fever. Norman married Ethel Frances Evans in 1917 and by 1919 they had moved out to Glen Waverley, where he was a market gardener.

Fulton, Noble (SN 1712) Noble was a 23 year old commercial traveller when he enlisted on May 19, 1915. His next of kin was his mother, Catherine, of 21 Alexandra Street, East St Kilda. Noble was sent back to Australia to recover from enteric fever in February 1916, then returned overseas in the September. He Returned to Australia March 5, 1919 and married Ida Carol Crooke in 1923.


Marriage notice of Noble Fulton to Ida Crooke
The Argus November 24, 1923 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article1991073


Furneaux, Francis Albon  (SN 36891) Francis was a builder, the son of Arthur Furneaux of Oakfield, Balaclava Road, East St Kilda. He enlisted at the age of 22 on April 14, 1917. Francis Returned to Australia December 20, 1918 suffering from Trench Fever. Francis married Ida Vera Desailly in 1933.

Gasson, Henry Frederick (SN 3336) Henry enlisted at the age of 21 on July 6, 1915. He was a plumber. Henry was reported missing in action and a Court of Inquiry held May 30, 1917 found that he had been Killed in Action in France on August 5, 1916.
Gasson, Reginald Harold (SN 3809) Reginald was 18 when he enlisted on September 18, 1915. He was a carpenter. Reginald Died of Wounds on April 7, 1917.
Henry and Reginald were the sons of Henry William Gasson, whose addresses were listed as 43 Gourlay Street, Balaclava; 62 Grosvenor Street, Balaclava and later 366 Inkerman Street, East St Kilda. Their  sister was living in Clayfield, in Brisbane when her brothers died and an article (below) about their deaths in the Brisbane Courier noted that these boys have eight cousins at the Front, two of whom were killed early in the War.


Report of the deaths of Henry and Reginald Gasson
Brisbane Courier April 25, 1917 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article20142974

Granter, Joseph Andrew (SN 5452)  Joseph does not have an Attestation file digitised but the Embarkation Roll tells us that he was a 40 year old manufacturing agent when he enlisted on May 12, 1916. His address was 26 Bendigo Avenue, Elwood. His next of kin was his wife, Edith, and her address was listed as 45 Wattletree Road, East Malvern. Lieutenant Granter Returned to Australia September 23, 1919. 

Grey, Henry John (SN 10420) Henry was an 18 year old decorator when he enlisted on July 24, 1915. His mother, Harriett, of 5 Leslie Street, East S Kilda, was his next of kin. Henry Returned to Australia January 16, 1919 and he married Vera Minnie Page in 1920.


Marriage of Henry Grey to Vera Page in 1920.

Haddon, Roy John (SN 3754) Eighteen year old Roy enlisted on July 14, 1915. He was a porter and his next of kin was his father, John, of 19 Empress Road, East St Kilda. Roy Returned to Australia March 23, 1919. Roy married Nancy Rose Wood in 1921.


Roy Haddon's parents give permission for him to enlist.
National Archives of Australia www.naa.gov.au
First Australian Imperial Force Personnel Dossiers, 1914-1920

Hall, Arthur (SN 762) Arthur enlisted on August 15, 1914 at the age of 19. He was  a cellarman and his mother, Frances, of 30 Malakoff Street, East St Kilda was his next of kin. Arthur was awarded the Military Medal and twice awarded a Bar to the Military Medal. He was also at one stage promoted to  Corporal and Acting Sergeant but later, after a Court martial hearing for being absent without leave, demoted back to the ranks. Not the first time I have seen extraordinarily brave men who had the odd disciplinary issue. Arthur Returned to Australia, five years after he enlisted, on August 28, 1919. In the 1924 Electoral Roll he was still living with his mother at 30 Malakoff Street, and his occupation was a mechanic, but I can't trace him after that.

Hamilton, Henry Edwin (SN 10267)  Henry was a 19 year old plumber when he enlisted on January 20, 1916. His father, Armstrong Hamilton, of 506 Inkerman Street, East St Kilda was his next of kin. Henry was Mentioned in Despatches and Returned to Australia March 12, 1918 and discharged on medical grounds - Synovitis, right knee. Henry married Rubina Mary Howlett in 1920.


Marriage of Henry Hamilton to Bene Howlett,
The Argus, October 30, 1920 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article4574582


Hardingham, James (SN 947)  James enlisted on December 2, 1914. He fought at Gallipoli where he was wounded in the calf on the right leg. He also suffered from dysentry and because of this was sent back home in September 1915 and discharged on medical grounds. James was a 24 year old student when he enlisted and his next of kin was his father, Mr C. Hardingham, of Sunnydale, Wentworth, NSW.  I assumed he must have been a student at St John's College and this was confirmed by the following letter in his file (reproduced below) about the state of his health. The letter is dated November 18, 1915 He arrived here six weeks ago having been told by the medical officer to go to his friends. The letter says he was very ill at first but is continuing to improve...At the College he is at home and has congenial surroundings and constant attention....I believe he will get better here than anywhere else...In fact we have thought that we are doing a small public service by looking after him..... The letter is signed by the Warden, Canon J. Stephen Hart.  James finished his studies and after various appointments in 1940 became the Archdeacon at Hay, in New South Wales. He was also an Army Chaplain in the Second World War, where he ministered to the internees at the Hay Prisoner of War Camp, his son Malcolm also served in the WW2 and died as a prisoner on the Thai-Burma Railway (5).  The Australian War Memorial has a Coventry Cross, made from the medieval nails from the roof of the Coventry Cathedral which was completely destroyed by bombing in November 1940, which is thought to have belonged to the Reverend Hardingham. You can read about this here https://www.awm.gov.au/articles/blog/coventry-cross-of-nails


Letter written from St John's College regarding James Hardingham.
National Archives of Australia www.naa.gov.au
First Australian Imperial Force Personnel Dossiers, 1914-1920

Heron, Albert Leslie (SN 511 / 1751)  Albert was a 31 year old shipwright when he enlisted on December 30, 1914.  His next of kin was his wife, Annie, of  432 Inkerman Street, East St Kilda. He was shot in the hand at Gallipoli and was invalided back to Australia on October 31, 1915 and discharged on medical grounds. Albert was living in Sydney when he enlisted again on April 15, 1918 in the Army Service Corps and served in Australia until April 1920.

Hurst, Charles William Farmer (SN 2046) Charles enlisted on September 17, 1914 at the age of 21 and he was a motor mechanic. He Returned to Australia on October 12, 1918 on 'Special Leave 1914' presumably for soldiers who had been serving since 1914. 
Hurst, Thomas (SN 6967) Thomas was 19 years old when he enlisted on February 8, 1915. His occupation was a farmer. Thomas Returned to Australia April 8, 1919.
Charles and Thomas were the sons of Thomas and Harriett Hurst of Wanvera, Inkerman Road, Caulfield. Charles married Lily May Poulsen in 1922 and Thomas married Dorothy Catherine Dixon in 1925.

Irwin, William Henry (SN 38508) I believe this is the correct man, even though I cannot find his Attestation papers at the National Archives. The Embarkation roll tell us that William was a 32 year old schoolmaster when he enlisted on January 8, 1917. His address was Holyrood, Holyrood Street, Hampton. His next of kin was his wife, Edith, whose address was c/o Mrs Brown, Bamfield Street, Sandringham.  The Nominal roll does not list a Return to Australia date, but says he was a Chaplain. William was still engaged as an Army Chaplain after the War.


Reverend Irwin on the Honorary Chaplains list in 1922
Commonwealth of Australia Gazette, February 23, 1922 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article232525895

Jackson, George Stanley (SN 689) George, a jeweller, enlisted at the age of 21 on August 18, 1914 and  he was Killed in Action at Gallipoli, nine months later on May 19, 1915. Corporal Jackson was the son of James and Sarah Jackson of 11 Leslie Street, St Kilda. He had attended Brighton Road State School and had undertaken his jeweller's apprenticeship at J.W. Handley, Fitzroy. 


Death notice of George Stanley Jackson


Johnson, William Herbert (Chaplain) I believe this is the right man, even though I don't have  a direct link between him and St Kilda or St John's College. William received his commission in the AIF on  June 11, 1917 at the age of 28, he was a Minister of Religion and his address was 35 Davis Street, Kew. His next of kin was his father, Samuel, whose address was the Deaf and Dumb School in Brighton, South Australia. He Returned to Australia April 19, 1919. In 1936, the Reverend Johnson, who was  was the Dean of Newcastle, was consecrated as Bishop of Ballarat (6).

Jones, William Henry (SN 5043) I believe this is the right man as William lived at 27 Henryville Street, St Kilda, which is off Inkerman Road, so a short walk to the Church. He was 25 years old and a driver when he enlisted on September 24, 1917.  His next of kin was his wife, Stella. William Returned to Australia March 5, 1919.

Kelly, M - not sure who this is, as I cannot find an M. Kelly with a St Kilda address. These two men are possibilities as they both have  a middle name starting with M,  are Church of England and have a St Kilda / Elsternwick address - 
Kelly, Richard Meredith (SN 21337) Richard enlisted on May 21, 1917. He was an 18 year old surveyor and his next of kin was his father, Richard Terrence Kelly, of 43 Loch Street, St Kilda. Richard Returned to Australia July 26, 1919.
Kelly, Robert Mathew (SN 2532) Robert was 42 when he enlisted on March 10, 1916. He Returned to Australia September 26, 1917 and was discharged on medical grounds due to senility. His next of kin was his sister, Rhoda Coulson, of Beavis Street, Elsternwick.  
Loch Street is about  3 km walk from the Church - Fitzroy Street to Grey Street then to Inkerman Street and Beavis Street is about a 2.5 km walk - up Orrong Road and into Inkerman Street. Not really convinced either of these are the right M. Kelly, but best I can do.

Knight, Lyal James (SN 69054) I believe this is the right man, even though he religion is listed as Methodist and not Church of England, but I can't find another L. Knight with a local connection. Lyal had served for 38 months with the Welsh Regiment, British Expeditionary Force, before enlisting in the AIF on March 5, 1918; he was not sent overseas from Australia and was discharged due to the War ending. Lyal was a 26 year old salesman and his next of kin was his father, George, of 38 Hopetoun Street, Elsternwick. Lyal married Gladys Kane in 1920.


Lyal's engagement announcement to Gladys Kane in 1919


Lambert, A.W I do not know who this is, cannot find anyone with those initials (or W. A. Lambert) with a local connection.

Lister, Eyrl George (Captain).  Eyrl enlisted on October 20, 1915.  He was a  28 year old clerk and his next of kin was his wife, Gertrude, of Eyrlsleigh, 9 Wilgah Street, East St Kilda. Captain Lister was Mentioned in Despatches and received the Distinguished Service Order. He Returned to Australia May 15, 1919. Eyrl also served in World War Two, enlisting on July 3, 1940 at the age of 52, with the rank of Lieutenant Colonel. He was placed on the 'retired list' in May 1944.  Eryl's address at the time of enlistment in 1940 was 15 Sidwell Avenue, East St Kilda.

McCready, John Francis (SN 1613) John enlisted on July 5, 1915. He was a 22 year old baker. John Returned to Australia September 22, 1919.
McCready, William Henry (SN 1609) William enlisted the same day as his brother John, he was 18 years old and a grocer. William Returned to Australia May 20, 1919.
John and William were born in Trentham and their next of kin was their father, John, of 33 Leslie Street, East St Kilda. John married Jessie Isabella Fairley in 1921 and William married Florence Gillies in 1926.


I came across this article about John McCready being charged at the St Kilda Court with theft of some coats. It was a apparently a prank on the part of John and his friends, including Joseph Winbanks (not Windbanks as the article states), whose name is also on this Honour Board. 


Marshall, H. Another mystery, I cannot find a H. Marshall with a local connection.

Mathews, Ernest Oscar Collier (SN 1062)  Ernest enlisted on November 30, 1914. He was a 20 year old traveller and his next of kin was his father, Joseph, of 10 Alexandra Street, East St Kilda. Sergeant Mathews Returned to Australia April 21, 1918 and was discharged on medical grounds - Thrombosis,  left leg. Ernest also served in the Army in World War Two, from October 1940 until June 1944; he had the rank of Captain.

Mays, George Percival (Lieutenant) George was a 41 year old soldier in the Royal Australian Garrison Artillery, when he was commissioned as a Lieutenant in the A.I.F on April 1, 1916. His next of kin was his wife, Sarah, of Tasma, 15 Wilgah Street, East St Kilda. George Returned to Australia November 8, 1918 due to medical reasons - thrombosis and an ulcer.

Nutting, Foster Ulric  (SN 2199) Foster enlisted on July 13, 1915. He was a 20 year old clerk and his next of kin was his father, Charles Nutting, of Northcote Avenue, Caulfield. Sergeant Nutting Returned to Australia July 31, 1919. Foster married Marjorie Edith Dentry in 1922.


Marriage notice of Foster Nutting and Marjorie Dentry.


Paul, Thomas Giles  (SN 121) Thomas was a 31 year old Theological Student at St John's College when he enlisted on August 21, 1914. His next of kin was his father, who lived in England. He attained the rank of Captain and was awarded the Military Cross. Before he returned to Australia in 1920 he attended Merton College, Oxford, where he continued his Theological studies. After the War he was the Minister at various parishes in New South Wales including St Paul's, Stockton and St John's, Camden where he served from 1927 until 1943 (7).


The Reverend Thomas Paul's business card.
National Archives of Australia www.naa.gov.au
First Australian Imperial Force Personnel Dossiers, 1914-1920

Peel, Norman Arnold  (SN 18181)  Norman was also a Theological student at St John's College when he enlisted on September 18, 1916. He was 28 years old and his next of kin was his father, Thomas, of Cleveland West in Queensland. Norman was 6 ft, 2 inches in height, very tall for the times.  Norman Returned to Australia September 6, 1919. His short obituary, below, tell us of his life after the War.


Norman Peel's obituary
Brisbane Courier Mail October 3, 1947 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article49659077

Reynolds, Charles Evelyn (SN 6405) Charles enlisted at the age of 33 on July 27, 1915. He was a gardener and his next of kin was his mother, Emma Brooks of 15 Prentice Street, East St Kilda and later his wife, Ellen, of 91a Powlett Street, East Melbourne. Charles Returned to Australia on December 12, 1918 suffering from being gassed, influenza and 'Effort syndrome' which is similar to chronic fatigue syndrome. After the War, Charles and Emma are listed in the Electoral rolls at Marcus Hill and Queenscliff, his occupation being a farmer.

Sanderson, Frederick John  (SN 134 / Lieutenant) Frederick was another Theological student at St John's College when he enlisted at the age of 25 on August 21, 1914. His next of kin was his father, who lived in Euroa. Frederick served at Gallipoli and then in France where he was Killed in Action on May 4, 1917.


Informal portrait of Privates Eggington and Sanderson, 6th Battalion, outside their tent at Mena camp in Egypt. Private Henry Tunstall Eggington (SN 79) was later promoted to Lieutenant; he was invalided back to Australia on November 24, 1916. Private Frederick John Sanderson (SN 134) was later promoted to Second Lieutenant; he was killed in action on May 4,  1917.
Caption and Image P06424.010 from Australian War Memorial



Death notices for Fred Sanderson


Shaw, Garnet Eric (Chaplain) The Reverend Shaw was the first Vicar of the newly created St James' Parish, St Kilda East. He enlisted  at the age of 38, on February 8, 1916 and served as a Chaplain at the various Army bases in Victoria; this was not his first stint with the military as he had previously served for 18 months as a Chaplain of the Royal Australian Navy.   He was discharged on February 2, 1917 and rejoined a month later and this time continued his work as a chaplain overseas. Garnet Returned to Australia on October 11, 1919 and was appointed to various parishes in Victoria including South Sassafras and Sunbury.  He was described in a newspaper article as a fine type of cleric and one who has made himself very popular (8).  Garnet married Henrietta Elliott in 1941 and died at the age of 76 in 1955. 

Smeeton, John Edward  (SN 6895) Listed as J. L. Smeeton on the Honor Board. John was 21 years old  when he enlisted on February 16, 1917. His mother Emily of 3 Malakoff Street, East St Kilda was his next of kin. Sergeant Smeeton was Killed in Action in France on May 14, 1918. His Roll of Honour circular at the Australian War Memorial lists his occupation as a butcher, although his attestation paper says he was a motor driver. 


Death notices for John Smeeton. His finance, Lorna Smiley, listed in the second notice, 
married James Weir in 1925.


Storey, Charles Ralph (SN 17361) Charles enlisted on January 10, 1916. He was a 23 year old bootmaker. He married Winifred Carver in England on December 20, 1919 and Returned to Australia April 16, 1920.
Storey, David Burn (SN 1143) David was a 21 years old clerk when he enlisted on July 1, 1915. He was captured by the Germans on July 20, 1916, but as he had been shot in the back and was wounded they transferred him to Switzerland for treatment after which  he was transferred to England and Returned to Australia July 31, 1918. David married Agnes Lenore Fawns in 1919.
Storey, James Burn (SN 1144) James enlisted the same day as his brother, David, July 1, 1915. He was a 19 year old clerk. James Returned to Australia January 1, 1918 and was discharged on medical grounds - loss of right eye. James married Flora May Atherton in 1919.
Storey, Henry Burn - Henry enlisted in 1915, aged 25, but his file at the National Archives is not digitised.   His file is part of Series MT1486/1  - this series consists of records for those individuals who applied to enlist in the Australian Imperial Force, and were either rejected, discharged while still in training, or went on to serve within Australia only [usually as depot troops or camp guards]. The most common reason for rejection is on medical grounds. Henry married Grace Beatrice Pont in Perth in 1912.
The brothers were the sons of Henry Burn Storey of 341 Hotham Street, Elsternwick. Henry senior, also appears on the Honour Board
Storey, Henry Burn - Henry was a Warrant Officer with the Commonwealth Permanent Military Forces. 


Death notice of Henry Burn Storey, senior
The Argus, January 13, 1934 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article11729371

Swift, Benjamin Meade. Benjamin enlisted at the age of 43, around 1915 was was rejected. His file, like that of Henry Burn Storey junior (see listing above) is part of Series MT1486/1 at the National Archives and has not been digitised.
Swift, Francis Richard Meade (SN 2019) Francis was an 18 year old Clerk when he enlisted on January 18, 1915. He Returned to Australia August 17, 1916 and was discharged on medical grounds - I believe it was due to Tachycardia and  a hernia. Francis was born in Port Elizabeth South Africa and is the son of Edith and Benjamin (above)  whose address was  St Helen, Clarence Street, Elsternwick. Francis also served in World War Two, enlisting in the Army at the age of 45 in September 1942. He attained the rank of Major and was discharged in July 1944. 

Taylour, Eric Lyell (SN 3731) Eric enlisted on December 18, 1917. He was a 21 year old hardware salesman. Eric embarked on March 6, 1918 on the Ormonde  (the same day and ship as Frederick Thompson, below) and Returned to Australia July 23, 1919. Eric married Ruby Edna Long in 1927. 
Taylour, Harold (SN 7592) Harold was a mining engineer and enlisted on September 23, 1916. He Returned to Australia February 4, 1920. During World War Two, Harold who was in New Guinea, served with the New Guinea Volunteer Rifle from October 1939 until August 1941, with the rank of Captain.
Eric and Harold were the sons of William Taylour of Trippleton, Inkerman Road, Caulfield.


Harold Taylour in New Guinea in 1940.
Papuan Courier April 19, 1940 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article250526513

Thompson, Frederick William Baxter (SN 3752) Frederick was  a 27 year old private secretary when he enlisted on December 19, 1917. His mother, Emerentia, of Yangor, Inkerman Road, Caulfield was his next of kin. He embarked on March 6, 1918 (on the same day and ship as Eric Taylour, above) and Returned to Australia July 23, 1919. Frederick married Olive Esselbach in November 1920; the couple lived on the island of Nauru.


Marriage notice of Frederick Thompson to Olive Esselbach
 Adelaide Chronicle December 4, 1920 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article89193853


Thoresby, Cecil Peel (SN 124) Cecil enlisted in the Royal Australian Naval Bridging Train on March 19, 1915. For an explanation of RANBT, see under William Thomas Barber, above. Cecil was a 25 year old seaman and had already served in the Royal Australian Navy for 8 years; his next of kin was his wife, Violet, of 414 High Street, St Kilda. On April 2, 1917 Cecil transferred to the A.I.F. and he Returned to Australia November 25, 1918. Sadly, his marriage did not survive the War, they were divorced in 1919 and he married Lily Ross in 1927.
Thoresby, L.T. I cannot find an L.T. Thoresby who enlisted, there is, however, 
Thoresby, Francis Laban (SN 3819). Francis was a 29 year old sailor when he enlisted in the A.I.F. on November 3, 1915.  His next of kin was his mother, Annie, of 21 Shirley Grove, East St Kilda. Francis Returned to Australia April 13, 1919. Francis married Mary Ferguson Maclellan in 1919.
Thoresby, Ralph Hedley  Ralph enlisted in 1917 at the age of 26 and was rejected. His file, like that of Henry Burn Storey junior (see listing above) is part of Series MT1486/1 at the National Archives and has not been digitised.
The boys were the sons  of Sidney Francis and Margaret Annie (nee Grice) Thoresby. Sidney died in Papua in 1924 and Annie died at 1 North Road, Elwood in January 1940.


The death of Sidney Thoresby in Papua. He leaves a considerable amount!
Cairns Northern Herald, September 24, 1924 https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/148993092


Topliff, James (SN 2427)  James, a 19 year old bricklayer,  was born in England and when he enlisted on July 9, 1915 his next of kin was his father, who lived in England. James'  address on the Embarkation roll was  53 Leslie Street, East Kilda. James Returned to Australia April 13, 1919 and he married Ethel Maud Tullett in 1920.

Tucker, Gerard Kennedy (Chaplain) Gerard was the son of the Reverend Horace Tucker, who along with the Reverend Charles Strong, implemented the Tucker Village Settlement Scheme in 1892. Gerard studied at St John's Theological College, entering in 1908, and after serving as  a Deacon was eventually ordained in 1914. When he was refused permission to act as a Chaplain, he joined the AIF  as a soldier, on August 5, 1915 at the age of 30. A few months later he was appointed as Chaplain and served until late 1917, when he was discharged on medical grounds. In 1930, Reverend Tucker, along with the Reverend Guy Colman Cox founded the Brotherhood of St Laurence, a religious order of the Anglican Church and named for St Laurence, the patron Saint of the Poor (9).  

Tullett, Harry (SN 2428) Harry was the father-in-law of James Topliff, listed above. When he enlisted on July 10, 1915, he said he was  born in England, was a brick layer and was 45 years old. His address was 53 Leslie Street, in what he called Balaclava, although James called it St Kilda. His next of kin was his wife, Miriam. Harry's enlistment paper said he had also served in the Egyptian War, 1881-1882 and the Burmese War 1889-1890. If you are wondering how he could have served in the Egyptian War, when according to him he was born 1870, it's because he lied about his age. He was actually born May 15, 1860, so was 55 when he enlisted. Harry applied to be sent back to Australia in January 1918 due being nearly 58, his wife being sick, he was suffering from rheumatism, had two sons in the AIF and that he was an old soldier. His application was accepted and he was sent back to Australia in April 1918. You have to admire Harry for doing his bit for the War effort. He mentioned two sons, one was Albert George Tullett (SN 1394) and I can't work out who the other one was, unless he was referring to his son-in-law, James Topliff. 

Turnes - listed as Ternes on the Honour Board, the surname is actually Turnes.
Ternes, Albert James (SN 3469) Albert was a 27 year old joiner, when he enlisted on July 1, 1915. Due to an injury to his right foot he Returned to Australia May 4, 1917 and was discharged on medical grounds. Albert married Gerte Jackson in 1918.
Ternes, Frederick Victor (SN 3380). Victor was a 19 year old plumber when he enlisted on June 7, 1917. He Returned to Australia July 20, 1919. Victor married Adeline Grace Sanders in 1923.
Albert and Frederick, both born in Bairnsdale, were the sons of John Ternes of Safrano, Wilgah Street, East St Kilda.

Van Assche, Ivan Paul Edward  (SN 49). Listed as Van Asche on the Honour Board. Ivan enlisted at the age of 17 years and nine months on November 20, 1914 in the 13th Light Horse. His next of kin was his father, Oscar Van Assche, of Montague House, Esplanade, St Kilda. Ivan embarked May 28, 1915 and  Returned to Australia on February 9, 1919. Ivan was very well connected, as this obituary, below,  of his grandmother,  Lady Holroyd, tells us. Ivan married Dorothy Boyd in 1925. Ivan was a champion hockey player, being captain of the Victorian Hockey team for many years. 


Obituary of Ivan's grandmother, which lists his four cousins also on active service.

Wonnacott, Horace Edgar  (Lieutenant) Surname listed as Wannacott on the Honour Board. Horace enlisted at the age of 23 on July 7, 1915. He was a commercial traveller and his next of kin was his mother Annie, of Armadale and later of  Kalymna Grove, then 14 Loch Avenue, East St Kilda. Horace Returned to Australia August 28, 1919.

Horace Wonnacott's commission

Westbrook, Harry Cecil (SN 975) Harry was a 19 year old clerk when he enlisted on August 19, 1914. His next of kin was his mother, Juanita Amy Westbrook (or Mrs H.J Westbrook as they list her with her husband's initials - he was Harry Joshua). Her address was Aberdare, Chapel Street, St Kilda. Harry Returned to Australia December 9, 1918. He married Lois Winifred Rae in 1935.

Winbanks, Joseph Henry  (SN 3964). His surname is listed as Windbanks on the Honour Board.  Joseph was charged with John McCready (see listing and the court case article, above) and two others with the theft of  a couple of overcoats in July 1915. It was just a prank and it was stated that defendants intended to enlist, and the cases were adjourned for thirteen weeks. Joseph enlisted on July 12, 1915; he was a 21 year old pastry cook. His next of kin was his father, David, of 4 Balston Street, East St Kilda. He Returned to Australia July 24, 1919.


Interesting report about evidence given by Joseph's father at an inquiry 
into the management of the St Kilda Cemetery.
Lismore Northern  Star, December 3, 1907  http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article71872524


Acknowledgment
Thank you to Father Paul Bower who generously gave us a tour of St James the Great Church. He also gave us a copy of  the history of the Church St James the Great East St Kilda: scenes from the first hundred years by John B. Willis. It was published in June 2018. We went there specifically to see the pillars, so for me the Honour Board was a bonus.  Thank you also to my research colleague, Isaac Hermann, for the photos and organising the visit.

Footnotes
(1) Willis, John B St James the Great East St Kilda: scenes from the first hundred years (The Author, 2018)
(2) Some of the pillars came from St Patrick's Hall, Bourke Street, demolished in 1957. I have written about this building here, When I was doing my research came across this article from The Age and this prompted our eventual visit to St James the Great.


The Age, February 7, 1959, p. 8
 
(3) Stawell News, December 19, 1917, see here.
(4) Tasmanian Archives, https://www.libraries.tas.gov.au/Pages/Home.aspx
(5) The life of James Hardingham  https://www.awm.gov.au/articles/blog/coventry-cross-of-nails
(6) Albury Banner, November 6 1936, see here.
(7) https://www.awm.gov.au/articles/blog/anzac-connections-centenary-digitisation-project-09
(8) Table Talk, March 2 1922, see here.
(9) Information about the Reverend Horace Tucker and Reverend Gerard Tucker is from their joint Australian Dictionary of Biography entry https://adb.anu.edu.au/biography/tucker-gerard-kennedy-9259