Thursday, November 20, 2025

Hilda Emery (nee Penny) of Cheltenham and Cora Lynn

The Koo Wee Rup Sun in July 1932 had the following short obituary of Mrs Hilda Emery of Cora Lynn. Mrs Emery was buried at the Cheltenham Pioneer Cemetery, where generations of her family and her husband's family are also buried.


Hilda Emery's obituary
Koo Wee Rup Sun, July14 1932. p.1

Hilda Eleanor Emery was born in Cheltenham on March 22, 1888 to Edwin Thomas Penny and his wife Sarah Ann (nee Coleman). (1) Sarah's father, William, built the Bridge Hotel, in Mordialloc in the early 1860s. William Coleman, who died in 1878 and  his wife Mary Ann (nee Chapman) who died in 1872 are buried at the Cheltenham Pioneer Cemetery (2)  

Edwin's parents, Thomas and Henrietta Penny, had taken up land in Cheltenham in 1852. As noted by local historian Graham Whitehead, they had settled on ten acres of land on Bay Road (later the address was noted as Jack Road) Cheltenham. There Thomas set about clearing the land of scrub, wattle and gum trees to create an orchard and engage in market gardening. Three acres of the land was devoted to fruit trees with the remaining arable land being given over to vegetables. After the death of his father on May 26, 1866 Edwin took over the 10 acres of freehold land on the east side of Jack Road. He was about 17 years of age. Later he purchased or leased more land. Shire of Moorabbin Rate Records reveal an additional seven acres in Jack Road, the ownership of 5 acres in Barkly Street Mentone (later renamed Rogers Street) and the lease from the Mercantile Bank of 18 ½ acres in Tulip Road (later renamed Park Road) He also purchased land in Coape Street Cheltenham. When in 1915 presenting as a witness to a Royal Commission into fruit and vegetable growing Penny was asked by the chairman how much land he worked. He replied ‘about 25 acres’. (3)

Edwin and Sarah had married on September 7, 1876 and Hilda was their seventh and last child and their only  daughter - her brothers, as listed on her birth certificate, were Albert Edwin, aged 9; Percival Thomas, dec.; Lytton William aged 7; Reubin Ernest, aged 6; Edwin Clarence, aged 4 and Clifford Frederick, aged 2. (4)  Sadly for the family,  Sarah died on July 17, 1890 aged only 35 and is buried at Cheltenham Pioneer Cemetery. (5)


Penny Family - Hilda and her father and brothers. Standing, from left -  Clifford,  Reubin and Edwin. Seated, from left -  Herbert, Edwin Thomas Penny, Hilda and Lytton. 
Image: Kingston Heritage collection, City of Kingston, Victorian Collections

Edwin remarried the next year to Emily Haselgrove and they had two sons, Leslie and Robert, so Hilda was still the only girl in the family. (6)  Edwin was very involved in the community including the  Cheltenham Church of Christ and the Sons of Temperance Friendly Society. He was also a Shire of  Moorabbin Councillor and the Shire President from 1898 until 1900. (7)  Edwin died on December 9, 1916 and is buried in the same grave as Sarah, their infant son Percival and his second wife, Emily. Edwin's parents - Thomas who had died in 1866 and Henrietta on June 3, 1888 - are also buried in the Cheltenham Pioneer Cemetery. (8)  As a matter of interest, the area known as Pennydale in Cheltenham is named for Edwin Penny. (9)

In 1897, Hilda had a narrow escape from death and this graphic report is from the Caulfield and Elsternwick Leader -
A daughter of Cr. E. T. Penny, the popular South riding representative in the shire of Moorabbin, narrowly escaped a horrible death by burning about a week ago. It appears that Cr Penny, who resides at Cheltenham, told one of his boys to burn the handle out of an axe, and in order to do so the little fellow lit a fire in the yard. The girl, who is about ten years of age, must have approached too close to the flames, when her clothes caught fire. Hearing a scream Cr Penny rushed in the direction from which it came, and was horrified to see his daughter almost enveloped in a mass of flames. There was nothing at hand to wrap around her and the father at once set to work to beat the flames out with his hands, the girl meanwhile guarding her face with her hands. With commendable presence of mind the young lad ran into the house and brought out a tablecloth which he wrapped around his sister and his father's hands. By this means the flames were extinguished, but Cr Penny had sustained terrible injuries to his hands, the palms being literally roasted, the only portions which escaped being the tips of two or three fingers.

Assistance was obtained and the girl was taken into the house and attended to. It was found that beyond a few burns on the hands and arms she had escaped serious injury, and is now, we are happy to say, on the road to recovery. Cr Penny's injuries, however, were of a much more serious nature, and it will be a long time before he is able to use his hands again. He asserts that he could feel his flesh roasting and his sufferings afterwards were simply intense.....Singular to say, Cr Penny had intended going into a paddock some distance away to effect some repairs, but sat down and decided to wait for dinner. But for this fortunate circumstance his daughter must have been burnt to death because there was no one else handy to render assistance.
(10)

When Hilda was 24, she married 26 year old Robert John 'Jack' Emery, a market gardener of Warren Road, Mordialloc. The wedding took place on October 5, 1912 at the Christian Chapel in Cheltenham. Jack, born on May 19, 1886, was the third and last child of  Charles Joseph Hicklin Emery and his wife Esther Eliza (nee Nunn) - his brother Charles was born in 1880 and his sister Esther in 1883 - all in Ballarat. His father Charles, was a compositor and worked for the Ballarat Courier.  However, at some time and certainly by 1903 the Emery family moved from Ballarat to Keys Road, South Brighton (Moorabbin), where Charles had a career change and became a  market gardener.  This move was no doubt influenced by the fact that Esther had came from South Brighton, in fact she had married Charles at St Matthews Church of England at Cheltenham in 1879 and her parents, James and Sarah Nunn operated a market garden in Cheltenham Road, South Brighton. James and Sarah Nunn, who both died in 1904, are buried at the Cheltenham Pioneer Cemetery. (11)

Hilda and Jack began their married life in Mitchell Street in Mentone, but sometime around 1920 they moved to Lower Dandenong Road in Mentone. By then, they had two children - Charles, born August 15, 1915 and Nancy, born March 14, 1917. (12)  In 1922, Robert and Hilda purchased 95 acres on Eight Mile Road, Cora Lynn, on the Koo Wee Rup Swamp. The children, who had been at Mordialloc North State School, transferred to Cora Lynn State School (13).  Jack's parents, Charles and Esther also moved to the Eight Mile Road property, which they named Agricola. Agricola was sheep farm (14) which was unusual for the Koo Wee Rup Swamp, most of the neighbouring farms would have been dairy farms; but they may also have had dairy cows. 

I assume that after young Charles left school in 1929, he worked on the family farm with his father and grandfather. Nancy, who finished school in 1931, worked for a few years as the sewing mistress at Cora Lynn State School from April 1936 until May 1938. The Inspector's report described her as conscientious. A sewing mistress did teach sewing, but in small one-teacher schools such as Cora Lynn, they would often give lessons to the younger children. Nancy's time at school as a sewing mistress overlapped with the time that my aunts Nancy and Dorothy Rouse and my uncle Jim Rouse were at the school, so she would have likely have taught Dorothy and Jim, but possibly not my aunty Nancy, who left in 1937 (15) 

I wondered what involvement the Emery family had with the local community - young Charles is mentioned in the playing list for the Bayles Football team (Bayles is the town next to Cora Lynn). Nancy was the Honorary Secretary of the Cora Lynn Red Cross when they held a ball to raise money for the victims of the 1939 Bush Fires. (16)


Nancy Emery, Secretary of the Cora Lynn Red Cross
Koo Wee Rup Sun February 23, 1939 p. 1

Whilst they were living at Cora Lynn, Esther died on October 16, 1928 at Pakenham, aged 75;  and then Hilda passed away on July 10, 1932, aged only 44; and finally Charles (Esther's husband) died on August 17, 1939 at the Melbourne Benevolent Asylum at Cheltenham, aged 83. Esther and Charles are buried together at the Cheltenham Pioneer Cemetery, with their daughter Esther who had died in 1899 at 15 years of age old. Hilda is in a separate grave at the same cemetery. (17) 


Cora Lynn in the October 1937 flood. This flood would definitely have impacted the Emery property on Eight Mile Road, as would had the more devastating December 1934 flood.  
The flooded Main Drain  (or the Bunyip River is on the right.) The Hall is the building on the top left; the road to the left, which looks like a river, is  the Nine Mile Road. The small building on the corner is the old E.S. & A Bank, the next building is the General Store  store, then there is a house. The  Cora Lynn Cheese Factory, is over the drain, on the right of the photo. The Cora Lynn State School where Charles and Nancy Emery went to school and where Nancy was sewing mistress at the time of the flood is on the left, behind the group of trees, at the back of the store,
The Australasian October 23, 1937 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article141810942

Two happy events took place in 1939  - the marriage of Jack and Hilda's two children - Charles and Nancy. Nancy was married  on August 19 (two days after her grandfather died) to local Cora Lynn man, Leonard Leslie Donnelly, at St George's Church of England in Koo Wee Rup. They initially lived in Bayles, but later moved to Maffra. (18)  Ten days  after Nancy married,  Charles was married on August 29, his bride was Beryl Muriel Green of Yallock, and the marriage took place at the Church of Christ in Oakleigh. (19)

In 1940, Jack Emery sold the Eight Mile property and moved to Main Road, Clematis. Jack was living there with his wife Kathleen (whom he married in 1934), and Charles and Beryl. Jack and Charles are listed in the Electoral Roll as market gardeners.  They were still in Clematis in 1949, but in the 1954 Electoral rolls, Charles and Beryl had a market garden in Heatherton Road in Clayton. (20)

When Jack died on November 19, 1953 at the age of 67, he was living at 24 Gadd Street in South Oakleigh. (21) He was cremated at Springvale Crematorium and for some reason not buried with Hilda in her unmarked grave at Cheltenham Pioneer Cemetery.

I realise there are many names and dates in this post, but just to summarise the Cheltenham Cemetery burials - Hilda Emery (nee Penny) is buried there, as are her parents Edwin and Sarah (nee Coleman) Penny and both sets of grandparents - Thomas and Henrietta Penny and William and Mary Ann Coleman.  Hilda's husband, Jack Emery is not at Cheltenham but his parents, Charles and Esther (nee Nunn) Emery are, as are his maternal grandparents - James and Sarah Nunn. 

The Penny family and the Emery family represent a time when families, through intensive market gardening, could make a living on what would now be considered very small farms. They also represent a time when Cheltenham, Mordialloc and surrounding areas were close-knit communities of farmers, intermarrying with other local families; it is almost hard to imagine this landscape now as these farms are covered in houses, shops and other businesses. 

Footnotes
(1) Hilda's Birth certificate.
(2) Whitehead, Graham William Coleman: Publican and Councillor  https://localhistory.kingston.vic.gov.au/articles/680  and Friends of Cheltenham and Regional cemeteries database -  https://www.focrc.org/
(3) Whitehead, Graham Edwin Thomas Penny: Councillor, Orchardist and Pioneer https://localhistory.kingston.vic.gov.au/articles/653
(4) Marriage notice in The Argus, September 9, 1876, see here;  Hilda's birth certificate. 
(5) Friends of Cheltenham and Regional cemeteries database -  https://www.focrc.org/
(6) Whitehead, Graham Edwin Thomas Penny: Councillor, Orchardist and Pioneer   https://localhistory.kingston.vic.gov.au/articles/653
(7) Ibid.
(8) Friends of Cheltenham and Regional cemeteries database -  https://www.focrc.org/
(9) Beazley, Sue Cr Edwin Thomas Penny J.P (1849 – 1916) The Tale of Pennydale, published in Raves from the Graves August 2020.     
(10) Caulfield and Elsternwick Leader, November 20, 1897, see here. I found out about this incident from The Cheltenham Pioneer Cemetery: Where History Rests by Travis M. Sellers (Friend of Cheltenham Regional Cemeteries, 2015) pp. 96-97.                             
(11) Penny/Emery marriage certificate; Emery/Nunn marriage certificate; Robert John Emery birth certificate;  Index to Victorian Births, Deaths and Marriages; Electoral Rolls on Ancestry.com. Charles Joseph Hicklin Emery's death notice notes that he worked for the Ballarat Courier


(12) Electoral Rolls on Ancestry.com; Birth certificates
(13) Shire of Berwick Rate Books; Cora Lynn State School pupil list.
(14) Reports of sheep and lamb sales from the Emery farm - The Argus, February 3, 1927, see here; The Age, June 5, 1935, see here.
(15) Cora Lynn State School pupil list; Public Records Office of Victoria Teacher Record Books  VPRS13579.
(16) Football - Bunyip and Garfield Express, June 24, 1938, see here; Bunyip and Garfield Express, June 16, 1939, see here.
(17) Friends of Cheltenham and Regional cemeteries database -  https://www.focrc.org/  Esther's death notice - The Argus, October 17, 1928, see here; Hilda's death notice - The Age, July 12, 1932, see here; Charles' death notice - The Age, September 9, 1939, see here. Charles is listed in The Melbourne Benevolent Asylum: Haven of Rest by Travis Sellars  (Friend of Cheltenham Regional Cemeteries, 2012).


Esther Emery's death notice
The Argus, October 17, 1928 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article3963260

(18) Reports of Nancy's wedding in Bairnsdale Advertiser, August 25, 1939, see here. The Donnellys had previously lived at Bruthren. There was also a wedding report in The Herald of August 19, 1939, see here and the Dandenong Journal, August 30, 1939, see here. Addresses from Electoral Rolls on Ancestry.com
(19) Reports of Charles' marriage in The Argus, October 10, 1939, see hereDandenong Journal, October 11, 1939, see here Charles died in Dingley  in 1962, aged 47, and was cremated at Springvale.
(20) Shire of Berwick Rate Books; Electoral Rolls on Ancestry.com
(21) Friends of Cheltenham and Regional cemeteries database -  https://www.focrc.org/ Jack's death notice was in The Argus, December 21, 1953, see here.

Wednesday, November 5, 2025

Newport Mechanics' Institute - a short history

This post has transcriptions of several newspaper articles connected the history of the Newport Mechanics' Institute and its opening in 1935. The name of the building was changed to the Newport Public Library in 1936.  The history was written by Leo Harrigan, the author of Victorian Railway to ‘62. At the end of the post are biographical details of everyone mentioned in the articles in connection to the Mechanics' Institute.


Newport Mechanics’ Institute, 1960s.
Image: Wesson collection, Mechanics’ Institutes Resource Collection (MIRC).

The opening of the Newport Mechanics' Institute

On July 6, 1935 The Herald (see here) reported on the opening of the Newport Mechanic’s Institute and Free Library –
With the assistance of the Williamstown City Council, a fine building has now been completed on the reserve, and was officially opened today. Incorporated in it is a public reading room, subscriber’s library, children's free library, and reference library, together with a small hall.

The building, which is of concrete, was designed by Mr J. W. Parry, architect, and was erected under the supervision of Mr H. Rose, Williamstown City Engineer. Complete with all appointments, the total cost is estimated at more than £2000. 
The institute's committee of management is: - Cr. W. Roberts, president; Messrs G. Young, J. Carroll, J. Adam, G. Paine, S. Wookey, Cr. W. H. McDonald and Mr L. J. Harrigan, who is honorary secretary.

In the comprehensive Williamstown Advertiser report of the opening of the building,  published on July 13, 1935 (see here) they noted an Honor Board was unveiled and also provided a description of the building  - 
It was fitting that the honor board should be unveiled by the member of the third generation of the family of Mr. J. Harrigan. The site of the building was once overlooked by the house of Mr. Michael
Durkin, another of the trustees, and the foundation stone of the building was provided by an ex-mayor of Williamstown, the late Mr. Bliss. Mr. Harrigan’s little daughter, the grand-daughter of the original trustee, then unveiled the honor board, the inscription on which read as follows: ‘'This tablet was erected in 1935 by the committee of management, in commemoration of Samuel Rowley Peel (1830-1900), James Dickson (1883-1898), James Styles (1841-1913 ), George Paine (1833-1913), James Horsley (1817-1886), and Michael Durkin, who were appointed in 1886 as the first trustees of the Newport Mechanics’ Institute.

The building, which cost about £1700, contains a small hall, a public reading room, a library, an office and a kitchen. The library itself is in three sections - a subscribers’ library, a reference library and children’s free library. The building was designed by Mr. J. W. Parry, A.R.A.I.A, and constructed under the supervision, of Mr. H. Rose. Included in the reference library are copies of sample lessons for the revised curriculum, covering the full course for history, handiwork, geography, general science and health. They are available for all teachers who desire to refer to them, and they will probably be in frequent use. Cr. McDonald is responsible for the addition of this useful and unique feature to the library.

The history of the Newport Mechanics’ Institute by L.J. Harrigan

The erection of the building had been a long process and the Williamstown Advertiser of October 14, 1933 (see here) reported on this issue in the following interesting article, under the headline - Long Deferred Hopes. History of Newport Movement. Mechanics’ Institute and Free Library Proposal. The history was a report was of Leo Harrigan's speech from a public meeting. 

Long Deferred Hopes. History of Newport Movement. Mechanics’ Institute and Free Library Proposal.
Speaking at a public meeting at Newport on Monday evening Mr. L. J. Harrigan said:— “In outlining the history of the movement to establish a Mechanics’ Institute and Free Library at Newport from its inception in 1886 to the present day, the fact must be emphasised that a period of nearly 48 years is covered, disclosing a series of blighted efforts and unrealized hopes for the promotion of the welfare of the community. In February 1886, inquiries were made of the Lands Department, on behalf of the residents of Newport, for the reservation of certain land in Mason street as a site for a Mechanics’ Institute and Free Library. In March 1886, acting on the advice of the Secretary for Lands, a meeting of the Newport residents nominated five trustees, and their names were duly gazetted, and the site definitely reserved for the purpose, on March 26, 1886. The trustees were: James Dickson, James Horsley, George Paine, Samuel Rawley Peel, and James Styles.

Money Received and Broken Promises.
The first recorded meeting was held at Grindlay’s Hotel (now the Junction Hotel) on April 26, 1886. A general committee was elected, consisting of the usual officers. Mr. S. R. Peel, foreman of the Newport workshops, was the first president, Mr. James Styles, of the Strand, was treasurer, and Mr. John McCraith, station master at Newport, the secretary. A set of rules for the Institute was drawn up by a special committee and later adopted. Less than one month after the first meeting, Mr. Horsley, one of the trustees, died, and his place was filled by Mr. Michael Durkin (after whom Durkin street is named), one of the very early residents of the district. The committee was very active during 1886, and Mr. J. E. Harrigan was, in November of that year, elected secretary in place of Mr. McCraith, who had left the town. Various ways and means were discussed for raising funds with which to erect the Institute, and a sum of £60/8/6 was received in donations. Meetings were continued at fairly regular intervals during 1887, and efforts were made to achieve the object of a Mechanics’ Institute. Plans for a building, submitted by a Mr. Jones, a Melbourne architect, had been selected, but lack of funds prevented the work being proceeded with. At June 30, 1887, a balance of £53/11/ was on deposit in the Commercial Bank. Promised financial support never materialized, and this is ubstantiated by the fact that over £210 was listed on subscription sheets, but only the £60 mentioned beforehand was received.

Incident of Bank Failures in Land Boom.
From August 26, 1887, to January 9, 1893, research has disclosed no record of any active interest in the matter, but tradition mentions unsuccessful attempts to stimulate public support. On January 9, 1893, at the offices of the now defunct Newport Gas Company, a revival was brought about, but no definite results ventuated. During the period of the early ’nineties history records the financial upheaval and depression which came as the aftermath of what is known as the “Land Boom,” and which probably accounts for the lack of success in the attempts to erect the Mechanics’ Institute. Among several banks which failed at the time was the Commercial Bank of Australia, in which the Institute funds were on deposit. On the reconstruction of this Bank, six £10 preference shares, of a face value of £60, were allotted on behalf of the Newport Mechanics’ Institute on May 1, 1893. These shares were listed in the names of James Dickson, James Edward Harrigan, George Paine, and Samuel Rawley Peel. The shares are still in existence at the present time, 40 years after, and their accumulated dividends have considerably increased the funds of the Institute.

Flux and Re-Flux.
From the attempted revival in 1893, no progress was made, and interest again lapsed. More than seven years passed before any further action of note was taken. In this period, the discovery of the Coolgardie and Kalgoorlie goldfields in Western Australia caused a general exodus of Victorians to those locations and, no doubt, many residents of this district were included, thus being the probable cause of some loss of support for the Institute. On November 19, 1900, a meeting was held, and nine new trustees for the site were appointed. A new committee was elected, and Mr. J. E. Harrigan re-appointed secretary. On February 7, 1901, a public meeting was held in the Jubilee Hall (where the Salvation Army Hall now stands) in North road, at which the mayor of Williamstown (Cr. George Bevis) presided. Subscriptions were solicited at the meeting, and the sum of £20/9/ was promised, but only £3/3/ was actually received. During the course of the next few months, further donations were acknowledged from well-wishers in other districts, and two or three entertainments brought in small sums, the combined results adding £16/8/6 to the funds of the Institute.

At this time, the Lands Department had been endeavoring to revoke the reservation of the site, but strenuous efforts made by Mr. Harrigan and Crs. W. E. Treganowan and H. J. Carter prevented such action. At one stage, the land had actually been sold by the Department, as it was claimed that the site was not being used for the purpose for which it had been granted. Also, by this time, 15 years after the inauguration of the Newport Mechanics’ Institute movement, death had removed many of the active members of the original trustees and committee, and others had left the district. 

Despite the election of new trustees and committee, no practical action was taken. Perhaps the events of the time exerted a depressing influence. The Boer War was in progress, and the death of Queen Victoria in January, 1901, reacted against the Institute by causing a postponement of the public meeting from January 31 to February 7, as mentioned. It is sufficient to state that the Newport Mechanics’ Institute and Free Library again passed into obscurity.

Mr. Lemmon’s Activity.

Another ten years passed. Early in 1912, the Lands Department again attempted to revoke the reservation of the site, desiring to make a sale, as the land was not being applied to the use for which it was allotted. Mr. John Lemmon, M.L.A., in conjunction with Mr. Harrigan, was successful in retaining the site for the citizens. In March, 1912, a new group of five trustees was appointed by a public meeting, and later officially gazetted. Their names were: Cornelius Bishop, J. P. Carroll, R. H. Drew, Rowland Walker, and W. G. N. Young. At present, only Messrs. Carroll and Young remain, the other three gentlemen being dead.

About this time, the Newport Progress Association joined forces with the trustees and the remnants of the committees in the hope of bringing about the desired result. In 1913, after strenuous efforts, the site was fenced by a working bee of local enthusiasts. A sum of £14/14/3 was raised for the purpose by public subscription, and the Williamstown Town Council donated £15, enabling the cost of £29 to be paid without further anxiety to the committee.

Events had long since made it apparent that dissension among the various committees as to the suitability of the site was a strong factor in retarding the progress of the Institute. One of the sources of disagreement was the contention that the site was in too close proximity to an hotel, but the objection of those years is now over-ruled by the six o’clock closing law. Many suggestions had been made that the land should be sold and a new location selected. In June, 1914, a motion was passed by a majority of the committee that the Minister for Lands obtain a valuation of the site and offer it for sale at an enhanced price on account of the fence. Probably the idea was to then obtain reservation of another site and utilize the money received from the sale of the original towards the erection of a building. However, there is no evidence of any further action in that regard being taken. 

The outbreak of war in August 1914, evidently put the matter of the Institute again into the background, and nothing was done till 1917.

On July 5, 1917, the mayor of Williamstown (Cr. H. J. Neal) presided at a public meeting in the Masonic Hall, Newport, and which was attended by Mr. Lemmon, M.L.A. A new committee was appointed to consider ways and means of raising sufficient funds with which to commence the building of the Institute, and to report to a future meeting. Such meeting never eventuated, and sixteen years passed by without further action in so far as the actual objective of the Newport Mechanics’ Institute was concerned.

Mr. Harrigan's Splendid Pertinacity.

In March, 1931, Mr. Harrigan again successfully intervened against the Lands Department’s suggestion that, as forty-five years had passed after the original reservation, and the land was not being used for the purpose for which it was granted, it be offered for sale by public auction. At this stage, a record must be made of the services rendered to the citizens by Mr. Lemmon, M.L.A., for it was only by his strenuous support of Mr. Harrigan that the site still remains available for public use. And thus 1933 is reached, and the purpose now is to detail a statement of the Institute funds in the Commercial Bank, and to give citizens an opportunity to express their wishes as to how this money shall be applied. These funds consist of the six £10 preference shares already mentioned, together with an accumulation of share dividends, deposits of additional small donations, etc., and interest. For many years, Mr. Harrigan was the sole surviving member of the four in whose names the shares were allotted. Messrs. Dickson and Peel died about 1901, and Mr. Paine died some years later.

With the passing of time, Mr. Harrigan desired to be relieved of the guardianship of the fund on account of his advancing age, and failing health, but he was unsuccessful in this regard, though he was approached on many occasions with suggestions to apply the funds to some other public scheme or organization. There existed, however, no authority for such action, and the necessary proceedings to obtain such authority were not taken by those interested.

Sole Survivor’s Demise.
After the death of Mr. Harrigan in December 1932, his family communicated with the Attorney-General and placed the subject of the Institute funds under that Minister’s jurisdiction. After lengthy consideration and enquiry, the Attorney-General instructed the representative of Mr. Harrigan’s family that an opportunity be given the site trustees to proceed with the erection of the Mechanics’ Institute. From this direction has eventuated the public meeting of October 9, 1933. The value of the Institute funds in the Commercial Bank at the present time amounts to £212/14/6, comprising £60 as represented by the six preference shares, and the sum of £152/14/6 in cash.

Remember the Pioneers.
It may be here mentioned that the donors to the original fund, from which the shares were obtained, and which, by its accumulations, constitutes the greater part of the money in the bank, are all now dead. It is to be sincerely hoped that the intentions of those early residents of Newport are not lost sight of, and that their memory may be honored in any action taken by the present generation, for it was their generosity which now places a large sum of money at the disposal of the citizens.

What's in a Name?

The Williamstown Advertiser of July 13, 1935 (see here) in their report on the opening of the Newport Mechanics’ Institute had the following paragraph – 
NAME THAT IS ANACHRONISTIC AND UNDEMOCRATIC.
We cannot help thinking that a common mistake is perpetuated in the name “Mechanics’ Institute.” Are we so unimaginative as to be unable to see that the title is a misnomer? - that, descriptive of such a building, it is quite inappropriate? In truth the name has a lineage that is distasteful. In the old world Mechanics’ Institutes were founded by a concession of superior people “for persons of the artizan class,” in order to rescue them from ignorance. By means of approved lectures it was desired that workers -  using the word in its narrowest connotation - should be kept on traditional lines of conservative thought and taught the restraints due to their station in life. In other words, such institutes stood for the recognition of a lower class. This is all foreign to the Australian atmosphere. To us, “class” is anathema. We all rank as working citizen -  though material possessions are diversified by unequal economic conditions - and an artizan or any kind of worker resents patronage by any man. 

How stupid it is, then, to go on speaking of Mechanics’ Institutes where, eligibility to membership has nothing whatever to do with the nature of anyone’s occupation. The People’s Institute would be a simple and literally correct appellation, and certainly one worthy of adoption, in Newport; where mechanics or artizans or manual and brain workers are not a class apart from other denizens of the locality. Mechanics did not by any means monopolise Saturday’s proceedings, and we may be sure that the membership will, embrace people generally, without distinction. It could be wished, therefore, that the democratic fibre of the residents will assert itself in the adoption of a name in which it is implied that equality and fraternity have a comprehensive application.


It was reported on October  17, 1936 in the Williamstown Chronicle (see here)  that at a public meeting attended by 200 people - Mr Harrigan's motion that the name be changed from the "Newport Mechanics' Institute and Free Library" to "Newport Public Library" was carried.

The 1925 building

Interestingly, Mr Harrigan did not mention the proposed 1925 building. In that year, as reported in the Williamstown Advertiser of December 12, 1925 (see here)  the Williamstown Council -  
caused the preparation of plans and specifications of the proposed hall by Messrs. Gibbs, Finlay and Morsby, architects, of Collins-street, Melbourne. It is proposed that the building be erected on the triangular block of land opposite the Newport railway station, which is now used as a plantation. The completed hall will seat 1,148 persons on the ground floor, and 376 on the balcony tiers. The plans refer also to four large shops at the front of the building, facing Melbourne-road, which, in view of their favourable position and easy accessibility, will undoubtedly command a substantial rental. Provision is to be made for a members’ library and reading room, and a free library with two billiard tables. Upstairs will be provided a large lodge room, a committee room, and a supper room with cloak rooms and other requirements. The estimated cost of the building is £20,000, and its annual revenue, apart from the free library and the Mechanics Hall, will be at least £l,500.


A 1925 illustration of a proposed Mechanics’ Institute for Newport. It was never built and the locals had to wait another ten years before they had their own building.
Williamstown Advertiser, December 12, 1925. http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article270740976

Who's Who - information about the people mentioned above in connection to the Newport Mechanics' Institute.

The Electoral Rolls on Ancestry. com are the main source for full names, addresses and occupations. I also looked at death notices and obituaries in the newspapers. 

Adam, J. On the Committee of management of the Newport Mechanics' Institute, when it opened in 1935. This is likely John Fraser Adam of 491 Melbourne Road, Newport, occupation - Iron worker. He died in 1954, aged 74; his obituary from the Williamstown Advertiser of  March 12, 1954 (see here) reads in part - 
After an illness of a few weeks, Mr. John Fraser Duthie Adam died on Sunday, at his residence, 491 Melbourne Road, Newport. He was born at Leith, Scotland, and for many years was employed as a fitter at Newport Workshops. Deceased leaves a widow, one daughter and three sons. 

Bevis, George. Mayor of  the City of Williamstown, and lived at lived at The Anchorage, Melbourne Road, Williamstown.  He died in June 1909, aged 64. The Williamstown Chronicle had this obituary on June 26, 1909 (see here) - 
Last  Monday forenoon the flags at the Williamstown Customs House and Council Chambers flew at half-mast out of respect to the memory of the late Mr. George Bevis, for some years a local resident whilst occupying a position in the Victorian Pilot Service. He was for six years a municipal councillor, representing the South Ward, and in 1901-2 was Mayor of Williamstown. At the period of demise he was the honorary treasurer of the Williamstown Racing Club. 

Deceased was an esteemed member of the Stock Exchange, having been elected to that institution in 1889. As a tribute to his memory the Exchange was closed on Monday to admit of members going to the funeral, which left Mr. Bevis' late residence, Kooyong Road, Armadale, on Monday afternoon. Before entering the pilot service he had been master of a ship, and after leaving it was one of the nautical assessors of the Marine Board and an examiner in pilotage.

Bishop, Cornelius. Appointed as a Trustee of the Mechanics' Institute site in 1912. Lived at 69 Hope Street, Spotswood and was  a glassmaker. He died in 1928 and the Williamstown Advertiser, August 11, 1928 (see here) had a short obituary -
Mr. Cornelius Bishop, a colonist, 84 years of age, and one of the original secretaries of St. Mark’s Church of England, Spotswood, passed away on August 2. After a service at the house of his son at Lyons st., Williamstown, conducted by Rev. Mr. Danne, the funeral left for the Williamstown
cemetery. A memorial service is to be held to-morrow (Sunday).

Bliss, Edward.  Donated the foundation stone for the Mechanics' Institute. Lived at 25 Farm Street, Newport; occupation - mason. died in November 1934 - this short obituary was in the Williamstown Advertiser of November 24, 1934 (see here) -
Mr. Edward Bliss, a well-known resident, of Farm St., Newport, died suddenly on Monday at the age of 72 years. Born at Newport, he was a son of the late Mr. H. Bliss, a pioneer monumental mason. The deceased was a local councillor for 12 years, and was mayor in 1921-22. He was a leading member of the Church of England, and was prominent in lodge and sporting circles. He is survived by a widow and one son.

Caroll, James Patrick.  Appointed as a Trustee of the Mechanics' Institute site in 1912 and on the committee of management when it opened in 1935. Listed in the Electoral Rolls at 43 Mason Street, Newport; occupation - clerk. This is part of his obituary from the Williamstown Advertiser, of  November 2, 1946 (see here) - 
Mr. James Patrick Carroll, 75, who died somewhat suddenly on October 26 at his residence in Mason St., Newport, was a well known and highly esteemed resident of nearly 50 years’ standing. Until retirement some years ago he held a responsible position in the Taxation Department. As a citizen he interested himself in public movements and institutions and served actively and fruitfully in various official capacities. A devoted member of the Church of the Sacred Heart, Mr. Carroll was an ardent church worker. He will be greatly missed in Newport, where he was a familiar figure. 

Carter, Herbert James. Fought to retain the Mechanics' Institute site in the late 1890s. Williamstown Councillor, and Mayor at one time representing the Victoria Ward.  Lived at 9 Forrest Street, Spotswood; occupation - tailor.  This is his obituary from the Williamstown Advertiser, of April 11, 1942 (see here) -
Mr Herbert J. Carter,  chairman of directors of Eastaugh Ltd., has died at the age of 81 years. A son of James Carter, a master of English at Cambridge, where he was born, the late Mr. Carter came to
Victoria 69 years ago. For many years he was associated with the firm of Carter and Carter, tailors, of Collins St. He became chairman of directors of Eastaughs on its inception, thirty years ago. He was a director of the Union Building Society and Mallee Hotels Ltd. A widow and one son (Mr. H. D. Carter) survive him. A son was killed in action in the last war. The late Mr. Carter was a well-known
resident of Williamstown more than 30 years ago. He was a councillor and in 1904-5 was mayor.

Dickson, James (1883-1898) Appointed in 1886 as one of the first Trustees of the Mechanics' Institute site. He died in 1898, aged 65, and this is part of his obituary from the Williamstown Advertiser, of November 12, 1898 (see here) -
A very highly esteemed townsman has passed away in the person of Mr. James Dickson, grocer, Melbourne road, Newport. His familiar figure will be sadly missed by all classes of the community in Newport. He was born at Straban, in the county Tyrone, Ireland, and spent the most of his childhood in Londonderry. After being brought up to business in Belfast, he emigrated to Victoria in 1854, at the time of the Port Curtis gold rush, but was unsuccessful. In 1857 he went into the ballast trade at Stony Creek (now known as Spottiswoode,) and prospered. He invested in land fronting North road, and other parts of the town, and at one time owned a considerable area in the centre of Newport. Being severely burned with lime, he was forced to quit the ballast work. He sold the land and set up in business as a grocer in 1874. His store was one of the first in Newport, and the business has ever since been firmly established.

Drew, Robert Hibbard. Appointed as a Trustee of the Mechanics' Institute site in 1912. In that year he lived at 17 River Street, Newport; occupation - armourer. The Williamstown Advertiser of June 11, 1932 (see here) this obituary - 
Mr. Robert Hibbard Drew, aged 75, of 100 River street, Newport, died suddenly on Sunday. Deceased leaves a son and married daughter (Mrs. Bird). The son, Mr. Harry Drew, was formerly attached to the staff at the Williamstown post office. The remains were interred in the Williamstown cemetery by Nelson Bros. Among the floral tributes were wreaths from the following: Newport Baptist Y.P.S.C.E., Girls’ Guild, Newport Baptist Church Choir, Newport Baptist S.S., members of the Newport Baptist Church, Senior Girls’ Missionary Union; Newport Baptist Men’s Class, members B.W.M.U., and the Women’s Auxiliary. The late Mr. Drew had been a member of the Newport Baptist Church for over 40 years, and was secretary of the Sunday school for over 30 years.

Durkin, Michael. Appointed in 1886 as one of the first Trustees of the Mechanics' Institute site and an early resident of Newport. His daughter Mary married James Harrigan and their son Leo wrote 1933 history of the Mechanics'  Institute, published above. Michael died on November 29, 1896, aged 69; his address at the time was 53 North Road, Newport. I am surprised I can't find any obituary to him.

Gibbs, Finlay and Morsby. Architects, of Collins street, Melbourne who designed the 1925 building. They designed the Williamstown Town Hall, which opened in 1927 and the Ancient Order of Druids building in Swanston Street, which opened the year before. 
Gibbs and Finlay, who were in partnership from 1899,  had already died when these two buildings were designed, but the firm retained their names.  Gibbs was Harry Browse Gibbs, who died in April 1918, aged 59.  He was elected to the St Kilda Council in 1903 and was Mayor twice, and chairman of the St Kilda Foreshore Trust. You can read his obituary in the Prahran Chronicle of April 6, 1918, here
Finlay was Alexander Kennedy Finlay, who died on December 29, 1921, at the age of 48, when the motor boat, Tamar, sank in Lake Tyers. The Age of January 28, 1922 (see here) reported on the Inquest. 
Morsby was Frederick Morsby, who trained in England and was elected a Fellow of the Royal Victorian Institute of Architects in August 1928. he died in 1973, aged 79. (Journal of the Royal Victorian Institute of Architects. Vol. 27, No. 5; November 1929, see here

Harrigan, James Edward. Secretary at one time of the Mechanics' Institute and one of the six men to whom shares were allocated in the name of the Institute in 1893; fought to retain the Mechanics' Institute site in the late 1890s.  James married, as noted above, Mary Durkin and they lived at 55 North Road in Newport; occupation - machinist in the Victorian Railways. James died on December 31, 1932.  This is part of his obituary from the Williamstown Chronicle, of January 7, 1933 (see here) -
 A very popular and well-known resident of Newport, Mr. James  Edward Harrigan, died on Saturday evening, 31st ult., at the local hospital, after an illness of some weeks' duration. Deceased was born at West Melbourne 72 years ago, but had resided locally nearly all his life. He was employed at the Newport Work shops as a machinist for many years, where he was popular for his genial disposition and his rendering first aid in accident cases. He was a well known worker on behalf of the local hospital and a prominent member of the A.O.F. (Court Williamstown). The A.O.F is the Ancient Order of Foresters. 

Harrigan, Leo John. The author of the history published above. Leo John Harrigan was born in 1900 to James Edward Harrigan and his wife Mary Margaret (nee Durkin).  Leo worked for the Victorian Railways and is the author of the book Victorian Railway to ‘62, published by the Victorian Railways and well worth tracking down  a copy if you have an interest in Railway history. The short biography of Leo in this book reads -
Mr Harrigan was born at Williamstown, cradle of the Victorian Railways. With his grandfather, father, brothers and uncles all railwaymen, he joined the Railways in December, 1914, as a junior clerk. Even at this early age he had a keen personal interest in general history; this interest narrowed to Australian, and finally Victorian history. In 1930, he turned to Australian railway history, with the accent on his own Department.

Leo married Margaret Entwistle in 1930; who she died in July 1951, aged 44. They had one daughter Margaret (who unveiled the honor board on opening day) and a son Leo, who died at one day old in 1938. Her short obituary in the Williamstown Advertiser of  July 13, 1951 (see here) noted that Leo was also the well known secretary of the Old Williamstown Association. Leo died in 1968.

Harrigan, Mary  Mary, the mother of Leo, died in July 1947 and she had a short obituary in the Williamstown Chronicle, of August 1, 1947 (see full obituary here
Mrs. M. Harrigan one of this city's oldest residents, Mrs. Mary Harrigan, died on Monday morning at her residence, 53 North Road, Newport, after a brief, illness. Deceased was born at Newport 89 years ago and was the widow of the late Mr. James Edward Harrigan, and a daughter of  the late Michael and Jane Durkin, old pioneers of this district, after, whom Durkin Street, Newport, is named. She leaves one daughter and six sons to mourn their loss. 

Horsley, James (1817-1886). Appointed in 1886 as one of the first Trustees of the Mechanics' Institute site, but died one month after his appointment, at the age of 68, and was replaced by Michael Durkin.
The Williamstown Chronicle of April 17, 1886 (see here) had this obituary -
Mr. James Horsley, the well known contractor, died at his residence, Newport, after a short illness, on Saturday. Deceased came to the district about the time the foundation of the Railway Workshops were laid - close on 30 years ago - and, later on, he took part in the making of the Alfred Graving Dock. Deceased was at one time a member of the local council, and up to the time of his last illness took a deep interest in municipal matters. 

Jones, Mr. The Melbourne architect who drew up plans in 1887 for the building, but lack of funds prevented its construction. My best guess is Mr J.R. Jones who is connected to several buildings in Williamstown in the 1880s and had the following advertisement in the Williamstown Advertiser, of May 22, 1886 (see here)


Lemmon, John (1875-1955). Local Member of the Legislative Assembly, who fought to retain the Mechanics' Institute site, after the Lands Department wanted to sell it off. he was member for Williamstown from 1904 until 1954. You can read his Australian Dictionary of Biography entry here https://adb.anu.edu.au/biography/lemmon-john-7168 

McCraith, John. Secretary of the first Mechanics' Institute committee established  in 1886. He was the Station master at Newport, having been appointed in September 1885. He resigned from the Victorian Railways in December 1893. John then became a salesman for Victoria Brewery and in 1905 took up the licence of the Waverley Hotel, in Collins Place, located between Flinders Lane and Collins Street. He was badly burnt in  a gas explosion at the Hotel in November 1905 and died. (Source: Bendigo Independent, November 21, 1905, see here; Adelaide Advertiser, November 21, 1905, see here and  Rigg of the Railways: stationmasters of the Victorian railways by Tom Rigg (published by the Author, 2001).

McDonald, William Henry. On the Mechanics' Institutes committee of management when it opened in 1935. He was a Williamstown City councillor. He lived at 64 Home Road, Newport; occupation - civil servant, he worked for the Education Department. William served in the First World War, he enlisted on August 17, 1914 and served for 1715 days and was wounded three times.  He died in 1959, aged 72. I can't find an obituary, but a short and informative  biography appeared in the Williamstown Advertiser, of March 9, 1935, see here.

Paine, George  (1833-1913).  Appointed in 1886 as one of the first Trustees of the Mechanics' Institute site. His obituary in the Williamstown Chronicle of July 19, 1913  (see here) reads in part -
At the ripe old age of 80 years and over, Mr. George Paine, senr., on Monday last departed "for that bourne whence no traveller returns." For 58 years a colonist and identified with Williamstown, until stricken by a severe sickness, he was a well-known figure in our streets. Despite his retiring nature he was in the early seventies one of the most prominent of our local sporting men, coursing being his particular hobby. It is likewise recorded of him that he was a dead shot. Deceased was a native of Somersetshire, England, in which county he was born in 1832.

The late Mr. Paine was one of the pioneers of Newport. It is stated that he was the first man to take a regular business of transporting houses from one portion of Williamstown to another; sometimes from here to another suburb. In later years he founded a stone-crushing and asphalting industry, now being carried on by his family

Paine, George.  On the Mechanics' Institutes committee of management when it opened in 1935.There are two George Paines in the 1936 Electoral Roll - George Alexander Paine  of Woods Street, Newport; occupation - contractor. The second one is George Henry Paine, 79 Wilkins Street, Newport; occupation - manager. I presume one of these men was on the committee of management, and one or both are also related to George Paine, above.


The Newport Library in March 1987, located in Paine Reserve. The Reserve was no doubt named for one of the three Paine men, written about, above.
Image: Mechanics’ Institutes Resource Collection (MIRC).

Parry, John William. The  Architect who designed the Mechanics' Institute. In the 1930s he  lived at the family home at  52 Electra Street,  Williamstown. His father Captain John Parry, was a Port Phillip Sea pilot (Williamstown Chronicle, April 14, 1934, see here.) J.W. Parry, amongst his other work,  designed buildings in Williamstown such as alterations to the Liston Oval tennis pavilion in 1930, the Masonic Hall in 1931 and the Kindergarten in 1951.  John died in July 1970, aged 66.  

Peel, Samuel Rawley (1830-1900) Appointed in 1886 as one of the first Trustees of the Mechanics' Institute site. Samuel died in July 1900 at his home on The Strand, Williamstown. He had been a councillor for five years and was serving as Mayor when he died. The Williamstown Chronicle published an obituary on July 28, 1900 (read it in full, here) - 
Mr Peel was a native of York, England, and came out to the colonies in the early fifties. He entered the Victorian railway service in 1877, and for many years occupied the position of foreman of the carriage and waggon department of the Newport Government workshops. He had sole charge of the east block until in 1895, he retired from active service on a well-earned pension. He was by trade a carriage-builder, and boasted of riding in the first train running between Williamstown and Melbourne, at that time working in conjunction with Mr Williams, a well known Melbourne carriage builder. In fact, to Mr Peel belongs the honor of inaugurating, at Williamstown the first Government locomotive workshops. Throughout his active career, he won the respect and admiration of one and all, and was especially regarded by those working under his charge. At the time of his death he was 69 years of age.

Roberts, William  On the Mechanics' Institutes committee of management when it opened in 1935. He was a Williamstown City councillor, and Mayor 1939/1940. He was a foreman at the Railways Newport Workshops and a keen singer, as reported in the Williamstown Chronicle, of August 22, 1941, see here.

Rose,  Harold Norton Innes (1895-1966)  Williamstown City Engineer, who supervised the construction of the Mechanics' Institute in 1935. He was appointed in 1932 and was still there, at least until 1951. 

Styles, James (1841-1913 )Appointed in 1886 as one of the first Trustees of the Mechanics' Institute site. James was a contractor and engineer, worked on Victorian Railways projects and Melbourne Harbour Trust projects. Held the  seat of Williamstown from 1894 until 1900 and was elected to the Senate in 1901 and defeated in 1906. You can read his Australian Dictionary of Biography entry here  https://adb.anu.edu.au/biography/styles-james-8710

Treganowan, William Henry.   Williamstown City councillor who fought to retain the Mechanics' Institute site in the late 1890s. He died in 1941 and The Argus of July 14, 1941 (see here) had the following obituary -
Mr. W. H. Treganowan, of Emerald, who died on Thursday, arrived in Melbourne at the age of 12 in
the sailing ship Southern Empire in January, 1869, with his mother and 2 brothers, John, now aged 82, of Dunolly, and Tom, 80, of Upwey. In 1890 Mr. Treganowan was elected to Williamstown Council, and served as a councillor for 25 years. He was also a Commissioner of Melbourne Harbour Trust, Board of  Works, and Board of Public Health. In 1916 he retired from business and acquired property at Emerald, later serving on Ferntree Gully Council for 12 years, for 2 terms as president. He was also chairman of Nobelius Station Estate Pty. Ltd , and took an active interest in the development and beautification of Emerald, where the popular Lake Treganowan was named after him. He is survived by a daughter and 2 sons.

Walker, Rowland.  Appointed as a Trustee of the Mechanics' Institute site in 1912. Lived at 63 William Street, Newport; occupation: striker (an assistant to a blacksmith). He died in 1917 and this is his obituary from the Williamstown Chronicle of  March 3, 1917 (see here) -
Mr. Rowland Walker, of  William street, Newport, died last Tuesday at the age of 56 years.  He was prominently associated with the Progress Association as secretary, until ill-health compelled him to resign. The remains were interred in the Footscray Cemetery on Thursday.  Deceased leaves a widow and one son (on active service) and two daughters. Some years ago he was a member of the Williamstown Band, and was also associated as a conductor of church choirs at Newport.

Wookey, Sidney John.  On the Mechanics' Institutes committee of management when it opened in 1935. This is part of his obituary from the Williamstown Advertiser of September 17, 1954 (see here) - 
The death occurred on Tuesday night of Mr. Sidney John Henry Wookey, at his home, 57 Farm Street, Newport, after a long illness. He was 54 years of age and was very well known throughout the district, particularly in connection with his trades union activities. The late Mr. Wookey is survived by his wife, one daughter, Betty (Mrs. R. Harley), and one son, Sid, the prominent Williamstown footballer.

Deceased was the secretary of the Federated Society of boilermakers, Melbourne Branch, for the past eight years and prior to that organiser for three years. He was formerly employed as a boilermaker at the Newport Railways Workshops, and was honorary secretary of the Williamstown Branch of the Boilermakers’ Society for 18 years. He was a Justice of the Peace and a well known sportsman, being in his youth a champion amateur boxer and titleholder of the Victorian Railways for four years. He was also keenly interested in the formation of the Mechanics’ Institute (now the Public Library) at Newport and was a foundation member.

Young, William George Newbery.  Appointed as a Trustee of the Mechanics' Institute site in 1912 and on the Mechanics' Institutes committee of management when it opened in 1935. He died in 1949, aged 74. His obituary was in the Williamstown Advertiser of October 29, 1949 (see here)
A well known resident of Newport, Mr. William George Newbery Young, died on Saturday at his residence, 48 William St. He was born at Eaglehawk 74 years ago and for many years was employed as foreman moulder at Newport Workshops. He was prominently associated with Freemasonry, being a past master of the Excelsior Lodge and the Lodge of Endeavor, and he was also a past chief ruler of Newport Tent, I.O.R., and one of the founders of the Old Williamstown Association. Deceased is survived by a widow, two sons and four daughters. 

Monday, October 20, 2025

The Bain family of the Border Hotel / Berwick Inn in Berwick

Robert and Susan Bain were the proprietors of the Border Hotel, also known as the  Berwick Inn, in  High Street in Berwick, at the intersection of Lyall Road.


The Border Hotel in 1858.
Image: Casey Cardinia Libraries

The hotel was established by Robert Hudson Bain (1831-1887) in 1857 which was four years before the town of Berwick was gazetted. (1) The book, Early Days of Berwick has this to say about the name of the establishment -  at a very early age, possibly the late 1840's the district was marked out for Police administrative purposes embracing the Port Philip area and with its limits at Bacchus Marsh and Berwick respectively. This theory that Berwick was the 'border' of this administrative area and thus the hotel was named the Border Hotel, is supported by the fact that there is an historic hotel in Bacchus Marsh called the Border Inn, construction of which started in 1850. The book goes on to to say  when the original Port Phillip Farmers' Society was formed [in 1848] two branches one at Berwick and one at Bacchus Marsh were formed so that district links existed between these two places. (2) The other theory suggested by Early days of Berwick is that Bain named it after his birth place, the border town of Berwick-on-Tweed, however Richard Myers, author of the book, Berwick Mechanics' Institute and Free Library has dismissed this idea, as  Bain was born in Falkirk in Scotland. (3)

Robert Bain came to Australia in 1855, on the George Marshall, when he was 24 years old. (4) He married Susan Stewart in 1859 and they had eleven children, but more about them later.

Robert was very much involved with the civic life of Berwick. He was Post Master from 1859 to1872, he was the first secretary of the Berwick Road Board which was formed in this building in 1862, and held their meetings there until the Council chambers were built further up High Street in 1865. He was on the board of the Berwick State School from 1862. The hotel was the venue for the first Police Court in 1865. It was also the first meeting place for the Berwick Mechanics' Institute. A block of land had been reserved for a Mechanics' Institute on the corner of Peel Street and Rutland Road (previously known as Irby Street) and a building was constructed on the site in  1866. This building was moved to its present site in High Street in 1877 or 1878. The site was donated by Robert Bain on a 500 year lease on the condition that the land continued to be used for a Mechanics' Institute. The rental was one shilling per annum, if demanded. A framed copy of the original lease can be seen at the Berwick Mechanics' Institute. (5)


The Border Hotel in 1877
Township of Berwick, Australasian Sketcher October 27, 1877
State Library of Victoria image A/S27/10/77/125

The Berwick  Inn  is one the oldest buildings in the area. The earliest section of the building, the triangular single storey part, dates from 1857. This is made of hand-made bricks from local clay. An archway to the rear garden was erected in 1876; and the next year, in 1877, a two-storey section was added facing High Street. Between 1887 in 1891 another two-storey section was added to the  Lyall Street frontage. (6)


The Border Hotel in 1887. The building on the right with the colonnades is the Post Office and Court House; the next building up the hill is the Rechabite Hall, then the Church of Christ. St Andrew's Presbyterian Church is on top of the hill.
Berwick 1887 (28 miles from Melb.), 1887. Photographer:  Field Naturalists' Club of Victoria. 
State Library of Victoria image H2012.114/2 

Robert Bain died on February 24, 1887 at the age of 56. His obituary in the South Bourke and Mornington Journal can be read here but it reads in part - 
Connected with school, with Mechanic's Institute, with Cemetery, with everything that concerned the town ship; he was always ready to do his part, and, though latterly he could not help with his presence, his interest remained as keen as ever. He was possessed of a rare simplicity of spirit; and, although he made little show or pretence, did many kindly things in a quiet way which reflected great honor on his heart. Even within the last few days I have discovered many actions of this sort, and I know of one action especially which I shall never forget, showing a delicacy of sensibility that is only too rare among.us. Scandal, whether to hear or to utter, was abhorrent to him. He was full of humanity toward all, ever ready to give honor to whom honor was due, and help them who were in need. His end came peacefully and was such as we could wish our own to be. His funeral was held at St Andrew's Presbyterian Church, conducted by the Reverend John Martin, and he is buried at the Berwick Cemetery. (7)


Rose Series post card of High Street, Berwick, c. 1923, which was the year Mary Byrne and her brother Daniel took over the Hotel.
Image: Casey Cardinia Libraries


The Berwick Inn, 1949. Photographer: Colin Caldwell
State Library of Victoria image H84.276/6/5a


The Berwick Inn, 1949. Photographer: Colin Caldwell. This shows the 1877 two storey extension facing High Street.
State Library of Victoria image H84.276/6/5b


The Berwick Inn, 1949. Photographer: Colin Caldwell. This photo shows the 1876 archway to the rear garden.
State Library of Victoria image H84.276/6/5d

We know that Robert gets much deserved credit for his role in public life, but Susan was in the background raising their eleven children and when her husband died in 1887 and her youngest child was only eight, Susan took over as the licensee of the hotel, and operated it until shortly before her death at the age of 69 on June 26, 1908. This is her obituary from The South Bourke and Mornington Journal
It is our painful duty to record the death of one who was most highly respected in Berwick and surrounding district  - we refer to the recent death of Mrs. Bain, senr., aged 69 years. The sad event occurred at Heidelberg on Friday, 26th inst. It will be remembered that in April last the late Mrs. Bain relinquished the management of the Border Hotel, and went to Heidelberg for the benefit of her health, and, notwithstanding constant attention by Dr. Buchanan, and trained nursing, the end came peacefully, as stated above. For years deceased had been a patient sufferer, and was at all times satisfied to make little of the pain she endured. Deceased had resided in Berwick for 50 years, and it is now 21 years since her late husband died ; her many good deeds will long be remembered by residents in and around Berwick. On Sunday last the funeral took place, and was probably the largest seen in Berwick, the remains being interred in the Presbyterian portion of the local cemetery, where a most impressive service was conducted by the Rev. Mr. Cope, many at the grave-side being moved to tears. Mr Grant attended to the mortuary arrangements, in conjunction with Mr Apps. To the bereaved relatives we extend our deepest sympathy. (8)  

Susan was born on December 28, 1838 in Scotland, the daughter of Robert Stewart and Catherine Campbell, and she arrived in Melbourne in 1857 and as we saw before, married Robert two years later. (9) Her sister Margaret also lived in Berwick with her husband George Brown. George owned a drapers shop in the town. Margaret died July 28, 1884 at the age of 50. Her only child, George was killed in 1887 at the age of 23, accidentally hit by a train whilst walking back to Berwick from Beaconsfield along the railway tracks. George Brown later married Mary Jane Patterson and built Inveresk in 1891, the house on the corner of High Street and Rutland Road in Berwick. I have written about them here.  (10)


The Bain family taken in the 1880s.
Photo: Berwick Mechanics' Institute and Free Library by Richard Meyers, p. 41  (see footnote 3)


The Hotel, Mrs Bain (seated) watching the croquet, 1900
Image: Casey Cardinia Libraries


Death notice of Susan Bain
South Bourke and Mornington Journal, July 1, 1908 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article66147962

As you can see from the death notice, above, by the time Susan passed away in June 1908, only three of her eleven children were still alive.  
Here is a list of Robert and Susan's children. (The date of birth is actually the date the birth was registered)
  • Catherine - born 1860 - died October 4, 1900, aged 40 - known as Kate, married John Murray Leggatt in 1878. (11)  
  • Jane Hudson - born 1861 - known as Jean, she is the Mrs W.S Withers listed in the death notice. Jean married Walter Seward Withers in 1886, they are listed in the 1911 English Census, living in the town of Goodworth Clatford, near Andover, in Hampshire and she died on June 7, 1926 at Andover. (12)
  • Margaret Anne Stewart  - born 1863, known as Maggie, married Charles Allen Champion in November 1889 and died on February 28, 1891 at the age of 28 - the same day as her stillborn son (13) 
  • James - born 1865 - died January 15, 1908, aged 41 (14)  
  • Robert - born 1867 - died January 18, 1902, aged 34  (15) 
  • Harry Wilson - born 1869 - died April 1, 1902 aged 32. (16)   
  • George Alexander - born 1871 - cannot confirm death date, however as he is listed in his mother's death notice he was still alive in 1908 (17)
  • Edwin Clarence - born 1873 - died 1875. (18)
  • Susan Stewart - born 1875 - died 1876. (19)
  • McCulloch Stewart - known as Jock - born 1877 - died January 19, 1908, aged 29. (20)  
  • Donald Stewart - born 1880 - died January 24, 1937, aged 56. (21)  
Sadly, there were two deaths in early 1902 - Robert and Harry - then in January 1908, James and McCulloch died in a heat wave. The South Bourke & Mornington Journal reported -
Berwick - The heat wave that has just passed over a greater part of the continent has been the cause of many premature deaths. Our small community has been smitten by the death of two brothers, comparatively speaking young men. Their ages being respectively 43 and 39 and the eldest and fourth son of Mrs. R. Bain of the Border Hotel. Much sympathy has been expressed for Mrs. Bain in her sad bereavement, more especially as she has been ill herself for close on a fortnight. The funeral of both her sons were largely attended, Mr. J. C. Bain who has been in business here for some years as estate and land agent leaves a wife but no children. Mr M. S. Bain was unmarried. As he was a member of the I.O.O.F. lodge here the members attended the funeral and walked in procession at head of the hearse to the cemetery. (22)  

Licensees after the Bain family
The Bain family owned the Hotel for a few more years after Susan died, but the Berwick Shire Rate Books are a bit unclear about when it was sold from the family.

Here is a list of all the licensees and owners of the Border Hotel/ Berwick Inn after the Bain family; it is as complete as I can make it. Note: the Local Government year used to run from October 1 to September 30, thus for instance the 1914/1915 Rate books cover activities from October 1, 1914 to September 30,1915. You will see that the information from the Rate Books does not always correspond with the newspaper reports. I don’t have the Rate Books after 1960, so I have just had to rely on advertisements for the licence transfers in The Age (on newspapers.com). It appears that after the Blackburnes the Hotel was owned by a company and later sold to other companies. 

Shire of Berwick Rate Books

Licensee as listed in Rate Books and Owner (if listed).

Newspaper  report

1906/1907

Susan Bain

 

1907/1908

Alfred Britchnell Steele Owner: Donald Bain

South Bourke and Mornington Journal 1/4/1908 - Licence transferred from Mrs Bain to  Alfred Steele at Dandenong Police Court hearing held 31/3/1908.

http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article66147509 

1908/1909

1909/1910

Alfred Britchnell Steele

 

1910/1911

Alfred Britchnell Steele

Owner: Englehardt

 

1911/1912

Alfred Britchnell Steele

Owner: Inglehardt [sic]

 

1912/1913

Alfred Britchnell Steele

South Bourke & Mornington Journal 14/8/1913 – Sale of Hotel from Steele to Triado.

http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article66183831 

1913/1914

John  Peter Michael Triado

Berwick Shire News ad 17/9/1913 lists A.B. Steele as licensee;  Berwick Shire News ad 24/9/1913 - licensee is John P.M. Triado

1913/1914 again

 

South Bourke & Mornington Journal  2/7/1914 – lease of hotel for nine years from Triado to ‘Mrs Falkiner’ (Mrs F was not there for 9 years).

http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-page6367531

Berwick Shire News ad 22/7/1914 lists J.P.M. Triado as licensee;  Berwick Shire News ad 29/7/1914 – licensee is J. Faulkner - Proprietress

1914/1915

George Fawkner

Owner: John  Peter Michael Triado

Police Court hearing  23/7/1914 Licence transferred from Julia Fawkner to John Triado.

http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article66185742

1915/1916

George Fawkner

Owner: John  Peter Michael Triado

South Bourke & Mornington Journal  6/7/1916 – Mrs and Mrs Triado took over management of Border Hotel.

http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article66190157

1916/1917 to 1919/1920

John  Peter Michael Triado

 

1920/1921

John  Peter Michael Triado and from 4/2/1921 L.A. Parish

The Argus 31/5/1920 Transfer of licence from  J.P.M. Triado to  Selina Parish.

http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article1707160

1921/1922

L.A. Parish and from  10/4/1922 Margaret Graham

The Argus 8/10/1921 Transfer of licence from Laura Selena Parish to Margaret Graham.

http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article4640971

1922/1923

Arthur L. Morrow (Margaret Graham crossed out)

The Argus 31/7/1923 – transfer of licence from Arthur L.H. Morrow to Mary Byrne.

http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article2009036

1923/1924

Miss Mary  Byrne and Daniel Byrne

 

1924/1925

Miss Mary  Byrne and Daniel Byrne.

Owner: A.L. Morrow

 

1925/1926

Mrs N. Wright  (Byrnes crossed out)

Owner: A.L. Morrow

Sun News Pictorial 9/6/1926 - Transfer of licence from Mary Byrne to Nora Wright.

http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article274984054

1926/1927

A.  Hartshorne [name also spelt Hartshorn]

The Age 14/6/1927 – transfer of licence from Nora Wright to Annie Hartshorn.

http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article205803860

1927/1928

1928/1929

A.Hartshorne

Owner: A.L. Morrow

 

1929/1930

Helen Struth – date of takeover  8/8/1930

1.Dandenong Journal 29/5/1930 Miss Struth has vacated Springvale Hotel and is taking over Berwick Hotel.

http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article201079860

2. The Argus 30/7/1930 – sale of furniture etc at Berwick Hotel.

http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article4102544

3. Dandenong Journal 7/8/1930 – Hartshornes leaving district.

http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article201080596

1930/1931 to 1946/1947

Helen Struth

Helen Struth  died in Cheltenham aged 76 on June 15, 1959. She is buried at Springvale Botanical Cemetery (23)

1947/1948

George Robert and Royall Blackburne - 3/9/1948 is the date of take-over as listed in Rate books

Dandenong Journal 9/6/1948 – licence passed from Miss Helen Struth to Mr & Mrs Gordon Blackburne on 26/5/1948.

http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article214581727


Blackburnes  

 

 Information about Gordon Blackburne (1905-1979) here https://upperbeaconsfieldhistory.au/g0/p842.htm#i25245 including an informative obituary which appeared in the Pakenham Gazette. Blackburne Square in Berwick is named for Mr Blackburne.

September 1960

Transfer of licence from the Blackburnes to the  Ye Olde Berwick Inn P/L

The Age 17/9/1960, p. 53

May 1964

Freehold of Hotel auctioned on 20/5/1964 

Various advertisements in The Age

July 1965

Application for transfer of licence from Ye Olde Berwick Inn P/L to John Francis Fallon

The Age  17/7/1965, p. 53

March 1969

Application for transfer of licence from Ye Olde Berwick Inn to George Kevin Barfoot and Betty Ann Barfoot

The Age , 15/3/ 1969, p.92

July 1971

Application for transfer of licence from the Barfoots to Francis Barry Johnson and Ann Therese Johnson

The Age, 10/7/1971, p. 53

November 1984

Application for transfer of licence from the Johnsons to Carl David Strachan

The Age,  21/11/1984, p. 64.

2017

Sale from ALE Property Group

https://www.afr.com/property/commercial/a-good-time-to-sell-ale-puts-berwick-inn-on-the-market-20171004-gyu1hx

Hotel freehold for auction on May 20, 1964
The Age, April 29, 1964, p.18

The Hotel, November 26, 1961. Photographer: John T. Collins
Border Hotel, Princes Highway, Berwick. State Library of Victoria image H2010.1/499


The City of Berwick was proclaimed on October 1, 1973 and the inaugural City of Berwick Council meeting was held that day at 10.00am at the Berwick Inn.  Cr Barry Simon was elected as Mayor. 
Barry Simon is at the front, then the other councillors are (left to right)  David Lee, Jack Thomas, Keith Wishart, Sid Pargeter, Jan Bateman, Jim Alexander, Joan Phillips, Ron Irwin, George Chudleigh, John Byron and Bill Hudson. 
Image: Casey Cardinia Libraries


Acknowledgment - This is a much expanded  and updated version of a post, which I wrote and researched, which appeared on my work blog, Casey Cardinia Links to Our Past.

Footnotes
(1) Berwick was gazetted on February 25, 1861, same day as Cranbourne and over 250 other towns - https://gazette.slv.vic.gov.au/images/1861/V/general/29-a.pdf
(2) Early days of Berwick and its surrounding districts - Beaconsfield, Upper Beaconsfield, Harkaway, Narre Warren and Narre Warren North, complied by Norman Beaumont, James Curran and R.H Hughes. It was first published in 1948. 3rd edition, p. 20.
(3) Myers, Richard Berwick Mechanics' Institute & Free Library: a history (BMIFL, 1999)
(4) Early Settlers of the Casey-Cardinia District compiled by the Narre Warren and District Family History Group (2010)
(5) Early Days of Berwick, op. cit; Myers, Richard, op. cit.
(6) Context P/L Heritage of the City of Berwick: identifying and caring for important places (City of Berwick, 1993), pp. 311-313
(7) South Bourke and Mornington Journal,  March 16, 1887, see here.
(8) South Bourke and Mornington Journal, July 1, 1908, see here.
(9) Early Settlers of the Casey-Cardinia District, op. cit.
(11) The Argus, October 6, 1900, see here
(12) From Ancestry.com -  England Census 1911; England & Wales, National Probate Calendar (Index of Wills and Administrations), 1858-1995
(13) The Age, March 2, 1891, see here.
(14) The Argus, January 17, 1908, see here.
(15) The Argus, January 20, 1902, see here.
(16) The Herald, April 2, 1902, see here.
(17) Many sources on Ancestry.com list George Alexander Bain's date of death as October 25, 1945; however I purchased the death certificate of this person - it lists his name as Alexander,  his place of birth as Seymour; his father as Robert, occupation railway foreman and his mother as Margaret, maiden name unknown. This is clearly not the George Alexander born in Berwick in 1871 (registration number 14310/1871). This death certificate of Alexander Bain refers to the man born in Seymour to  Robert and Margaret (nee Bourke) in 1872 (registration number 19676/1872)
(18) Indexes to the Victorian Births, Deaths and Marriages
(19) Indexes to the Victorian Births, Deaths and Marriages
(20) The Age, January 21, 1908, see here.
(21) The Age, January 25, 1937, see here.
(22) South Bourke and Mornington Journal, January 22, 1908, see here.
(23) Death certificate